Arthur Aron's 36 Questions: What the Closeness Study Really Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-01-05.

Short answer: no list of questions can make a particular person fall in love with you. What the famous "36 questions" can do, according to the research behind them, is help two people feel noticeably closer in under an hour. That is a real and useful effect, and understanding how it works makes the exercise far more valuable than the viral promise ever did.

Can Thirty-Six Questions Build Closeness? What the Idea Means

The questions come from social psychologists Arthur and Elaine Aron and their colleagues. They were built as a laboratory tool for studying closeness, and only became a dating phenomenon decades later. Here is where they came from, what the study found, how to use them well and where the popular story goes too far.

The couple behind the questions

The story starts with a romance. In 1967 Arthur Aron was a psychology graduate student at UC Berkeley when he fell for a fellow student, Elaine Spaulding. Recalling that period for Berkeley News in 2015, he said simply: "I fell in love very intensely."

As a budding social psychologist, he went looking for scientific work on love and found that there was almost none. That gap shaped a career. Arthur went on to earn a PhD at the University of Toronto and later became a professor of psychology at Stony Brook University in New York, best known for the self-expansion model, the idea that we are drawn to close relationships partly because they help us grow. Elaine became a psychologist too and wrote the bestselling book The Highly Sensitive Person. The two married and spent decades researching relationships together.

What the 1997 study actually tested

The questions first appeared in a 1997 paper in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin titled "The Experimental Generation of Interpersonal Closeness," by Aron, Melinat, Aron, Vallone and Bator. The researchers wanted a reliable way to create closeness between strangers in a lab, so they could study it under controlled conditions.

Pairs of participants spent about 45 minutes taking turns on self-disclosure and relationship-building tasks that grew steadily more personal. A comparison group spent the same time on small talk. The pairs who worked through the escalating questions reported feeling clearly closer afterwards.

Two other findings are less famous but just as interesting. Matching people who agreed on important attitudes did not significantly boost closeness, and neither did telling pairs in advance that they would probably like each other. In other words, what mattered was the gradual, mutual opening up, not shared opinions or expectations.

How the three sets are designed

The 36 prompts are split into three sets of twelve, and the order is the whole point. Each set asks a little more of both people than the one before it.

  • Set one is light and curious: think of questions about who you would invite to dinner if you could choose anyone, or what an ideal day looks like to you.
  • Set two turns toward values and memories: what you are proudest of, what friendship means to you, how your family shaped you.
  • Set three is the most vulnerable, inviting each person to say what they already appreciate about the other and to share a personal problem and ask for advice.

Some prompts are tasks rather than questions, such as telling your life story in a few minutes or naming things you have in common. The full list appears in the appendix of the original paper and is widely reproduced online, so it is easy to find if you want to try it.

The structure mirrors how closeness grows in everyday life. Friends rarely bond by trading their deepest fears on day one. They share a little, see that it is received kindly, and share a little more. The questions simply compress that back-and-forth into one sitting, and they keep it balanced so neither person does all the revealing.

Why closeness matters so much

Learning to build closeness is not a trivial skill. One of the longest-running studies of adult life, the Harvard Study of Adult Development, which began in 1938, has followed participants for decades. Among its reported findings: men who were most satisfied in their relationships at age 50 tended to be physically healthier at 80. Research like this is a big reason psychologists treat relationship quality as a serious factor in wellbeing, not a soft extra.

Aron himself has argued that long-term couples get used to each other over time, and that doing new and challenging things together can refresh a relationship. Structured conversation is one of those new things. His team has also tested a version in which two couples who do not know each other answer the questions together, including in a 2014 study on whether self-disclosure could rekindle romance in long-term partners.

From lab tool to love story

For nearly two decades the questions were mostly known to researchers. That changed in January 2015, when writer Mandy Len Catron published a Modern Love essay in The New York Times describing how she and an acquaintance tried them and later became a couple. Her essay also recounts that two participants from the original lab work reportedly went on to marry. The column went viral, and the list was soon being shared everywhere as "the 36 questions that lead to love."

The Arons have been clear that this was never the goal. As Elaine Aron put it: "We had not created the 36 questions to help you fall in love." Berkeley News, reporting on their work, noted that the questions have helped many strangers form friendships and some romances, but that lasting closeness is not guaranteed. Some connections made in the lab endure; others fade, just as they do outside it.

Where the questions are used today

Beyond dating, the questions have been used in hundreds of studies, in research on friendships across racial and ethnic lines, and in programmes aiming to build understanding between police officers and community members. That range is a good reminder of what they really are: a tool for mutual understanding.

Using them well, and common myths

If you want to try the exercise with a date, a partner or even a new friend, a few habits make it work better:

  • Agree on it together. It should feel like a shared experiment, not a technique one person runs on the other.
  • Take turns. Both people answer each prompt. The balance is what creates trust.
  • Allow passes. In the research, participants could decline to share anything they were not comfortable with. Keep that rule.
  • Go in order and do not rush. Skipping straight to the deepest questions removes the gradual build that makes the exercise work.
  • Listen more than you perform. The aim is understanding, not impressing.

Myth: the questions make anyone fall in love

They reliably increase a feeling of closeness in the moment. Attraction, compatibility, timing and shared values still decide whether that turns into romance. Closeness and love overlap, but they are not the same thing.

Myth: the effect is permanent

A single conversation can open a door. Keeping a relationship close takes ongoing attention, which is exactly why Aron's broader work focuses on shared new experiences over time.

Myth: it is a way to win someone over

Using intimate questions to pressure someone who is not interested misses the point entirely. Consent and comfort come first; if the other person is not into it, that is the answer.

Seen for what it is, the exercise is a gentle, well-tested way to get past small talk. Whether it leads to romance, friendship or simply a better conversation, it shows something hopeful: given the right structure and a little courage, strangers can understand each other surprisingly quickly.

Sources: Aron et al. (1997), The Experimental Generation of Interpersonal Closeness | Berkeley News: Love in the lab | Wikipedia: Arthur Aron | Wikipedia: Grant Study (Harvard Study of Adult Development) | Original idea: Ideapod

COMMENTS