Artists Linked to Schizophrenia: Van Gogh, Dadd, Barrett and More

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
5 Amazing Artists Who Suffered from Schizophrenia and Their Works

Image Source: Pexels.com

Five creative figures are often named in lists of artists who lived with schizophrenia: the painters Vincent van Gogh and Richard Dadd, the writer Jack Kerouac, the Pink Floyd founder Syd Barrett, and the Chicago musician and artist Wesley Willis. The evidence behind each name is very different. Only Dadd and Willis are generally described as having had schizophrenia. For van Gogh, Kerouac and Barrett the label is a guess, a disputed reading of old records, or something their families rejected.

That difference matters. Below we look at each artist's work and at what is actually known about their health, after a short explanation of the illness itself and the myths that tend to follow it.

What schizophrenia is, and what it is not

Schizophrenia is a mental illness that affects about one in 300 people worldwide, according to the World Health Organization. Its main features can include hallucinations such as hearing voices, fixed false beliefs, disorganised thinking and behaviour, and a loss of motivation and emotional expression. Many people also have problems with memory and concentration.

It is not a "split personality", which is a separate and much rarer condition. Nor is it a life sentence. Medication, family support, cognitive behavioural therapy and rehabilitation all help, and the WHO notes that at least one in three people with schizophrenia can recover fully. Older textbooks divided the illness into subtypes such as "catatonic" or "paranoid", but current diagnostic manuals have largely dropped those categories because they did not predict how a person would do.

Stigma remains one of the biggest problems. People with the condition face discrimination in housing, work and health care, and they die on average about nine years earlier than others, often from heart and metabolic illness that goes untreated. Lists of famous "mad geniuses" can feed that stigma if they get the facts wrong, which is why the details below are worth getting right.

Vincent van Gogh: a famous case with no agreed diagnosis

Starry Sky by Vincent van Gogh

Image Source: Pixabay.com

The Dutch painter (1853–1890) produced around 2,100 works in roughly a decade, including The Starry Night, the Sunflowers series, Bedroom in Arles, Irises and dozens of self-portraits. Much of his best-known work comes from his last two years, which he spent in Arles, at the asylum in Saint-Rémy and finally in Auvers-sur-Oise.

Van Gogh clearly suffered serious mental crises. In December 1888 he cut off part or all of his left ear, and he later spent a year as a voluntary patient at Saint-Rémy. But he has never been diagnosed with schizophrenia in any agreed sense. Doctors and historians have proposed many explanations, including epilepsy (which his own doctors suspected), bipolar disorder, the effects of absinthe and alcohol, an inner-ear disorder, a metabolic disease called porphyria and borderline personality disorder. Schizophrenia is on the list too, but many specialists consider it unlikely because his psychotic episodes came and went, with long lucid periods in between.

He died in July 1890, aged 37, from a gunshot wound to the chest. His death is generally accepted as suicide, although a few biographers have questioned that account.

Richard Dadd: fairy paintings made in a hospital

Richard Dadd (1817–1886) was a promising young Victorian painter of fairy scenes and literary subjects. In 1842 he travelled through the Middle East and up the Nile as a draughtsman for a wealthy patron, and during the journey his behaviour changed sharply. Back in England he became convinced that he was receiving orders from the Egyptian god Osiris, and in August 1843 he killed his father with a knife in Kent before fleeing to France, where he was arrested.

Dadd spent the rest of his life in secure hospitals: about 20 years in Bethlem in London, then Broadmoor in Berkshire, where he died in 1886. Sympathetic doctors allowed him to keep painting, and much of his most admired work was made there, including The Fairy Feller's Master-Stroke, which he worked on from 1855 to 1864 and which now hangs in Tate Britain, Contradiction: Oberon and Titania, a set of watercolours called Sketches to Illustrate the Passions, and a portrait of the physician Sir Alexander Morison. His paintings are known for crowded compositions and extraordinarily fine detail. Modern writers suggest he probably had paranoid schizophrenia, although no diagnosis can be made with certainty so long after his death.

Jack Kerouac: a wartime label, not a lifelong diagnosis

Jack Kerouac (1922–1969) is best known for On the Road, published in 1957, which became a defining book of the Beat Generation alongside the work of his friends Allen Ginsberg, William S. Burroughs and Neal Cassady. He followed it with The Dharma Bums (1958) and Big Sur (1962).

The schizophrenia claim comes from his brief time in the US Navy Reserve in 1943. After only eight days of active duty he was put on the sick list. His medical report quotes him saying that he asked for an aspirin for his headaches and was diagnosed with "dementia praecox", the old name for schizophrenia. He was then discharged on psychiatric grounds as being of "indifferent character", with a diagnosis of "schizoid personality". That is a different and milder label, and there is no record that he was treated for schizophrenia later in life. His most serious health problem was alcohol: he died in October 1969, aged 47, from internal bleeding linked to cirrhosis of the liver.

Syd Barrett: speculation his family rejected

Syd Barrett (1946–2006) was the founding frontman, guitarist and main songwriter of Pink Floyd, writing most of their 1967 debut album, The Piper at the Gates of Dawn. His behaviour became increasingly erratic, and around Christmas 1967 the band brought in David Gilmour as a second guitarist. In April 1968 they announced that Barrett had left. He released two solo albums, The Madcap Laughs and Barrett, both in 1970, before withdrawing from music. Pink Floyd's 1975 tribute, "Shine On You Crazy Diamond", is about him.

Barrett had used LSD heavily, and his former bandmates disagreed about the cause of his breakdown; Roger Waters has said he believes Barrett had schizophrenia. There is no public record of a formal diagnosis, however, and his family said that he neither had a mental illness nor received treatment for one in his later years. He returned to his birth name, Roger, lived quietly in Cambridge, painted and gardened, and died of pancreatic cancer in July 2006, aged 60.

Wesley Willis: an artist who described his illness openly

Wesley Willis (1963–2003) is the clearest case on this list. Born in Chicago, he began hearing voices in the 1980s and was reportedly diagnosed with chronic schizophrenia towards the end of that decade, after a period in hospital. He spoke and sang about it openly, calling his attacks of voices "hellrides", which often struck while he travelled on Chicago's buses.

Before his music became known, Willis was a visual artist who made hundreds of detailed ink-pen drawings of Chicago streets, expressways and skylines, often selling them for $10 to $40. In the 1990s he fronted the punk band the Wesley Willis Fiasco and released a large catalogue of keyboard songs with repetitive structures and blunt, funny lyrics. He was profiled on MTV, appeared on The Howard Stern Show in 1996, and was famous for greeting fans with a gentle head-butt. He died in August 2003, aged 40, from complications of chronic myelogenous leukaemia.

Creativity, illness and a few myths

The idea that great art comes from madness is very old, and it can do harm. Most people with schizophrenia are not artists, and most artists do not have schizophrenia. Some large population studies have reportedly found that close relatives of people with serious mental illness are slightly more likely to work in creative jobs, but the illness itself often makes sustained work harder, not easier. Dadd and Willis made their art despite their illness and with the support of others, not because of it.

It is also a myth that people with schizophrenia are typically violent. Dadd's crime is unusual, which is one reason it is remembered; people with the illness are more often victims of violence than perpetrators.

If you or someone close to you is hearing voices, losing touch with reality or thinking about self-harm, talk to a doctor as soon as possible, or contact your local emergency or crisis service. Early treatment makes a real difference.

Sources: World Health Organization: Schizophrenia fact sheet; Wikipedia: Health of Vincent van Gogh; Wikipedia: Richard Dadd; Wikipedia: Jack Kerouac; Wikipedia: Syd Barrett; Wikipedia: Wesley Willis. Images: Pexels and Pixabay, as credited above. Original article by Alex Moore.

COMMENTS