First published December 5, 2017.
Is the tomb inside Jerusalem’s Church of the Holy Sepulchre really the one Roman Christians venerated in the fourth century? Mortar dating published after the 2016–2017 restoration says yes: material sealed directly above the rock-cut burial bed was dated to around A.D. 345, the reign of Constantine’s sons. What science cannot say is whose body once lay there. Those are two very different questions, and the headlines of 2017 often blurred them.
Below is what the restorers found, how the dating works, and why the result matters to historians whatever your beliefs about the Resurrection.
The short answer: an ancient shrine, not a named grave
Ancient writers say that around 326 Emperor Constantine ordered a pagan temple in Jerusalem torn down so that a church could be built over the spot local Christians remembered as Jesus’ grave. When the builders cleared the ground, a tomb cut into the limestone came to light, and Bishop Macarius of Jerusalem identified it as the burial place described in the Gospels. The basilica raised around it was consecrated on 13 September 335.
For centuries, though, nobody could show that the cave visible today was the same one. The church was attacked, burned and shaken by earthquakes. Worst of all, on 18 October 1009 the Fatimid caliph al-Hakim ordered it demolished, and the tomb itself was almost entirely smashed. The earliest building work anyone could point to inside the shrine was medieval.
The new dates close that gap. They show that the surviving limestone remains were being built into a monument in the mid-fourth century, exactly when the written sources say Constantine’s workers enshrined the tomb. That links the present structure to the one Roman pilgrims saw. It does not, and could not, identify a first-century occupant.

Why the Edicule had to be opened
The small chapel that encloses the tomb is called the Edicule (sometimes Aedicule). Its present outer shell dates from 1809–1810, when the Greek architect Nikolaos Komnenos of Mytilene rebuilt it in Ottoman Baroque style after a fire in 1808 brought down the rotunda’s dome. That red limestone cladding weathered badly. From 1947 the British authorities held the whole shrine together with iron girders, which stayed in place for seventy years.
Before the work began, the Israel Antiquities Authority had declared the structure unsafe. Repairs were complicated by the church’s famous Status Quo, the arrangement fixed by Ottoman decrees in 1757 and 1852–53 under which the Greek Orthodox, Roman Catholic and Armenian Apostolic churches share custody, with smaller rights held by the Syriac, Coptic and Ethiopian Orthodox. Even minor changes need all of them to agree. The best-known symbol of this caution is the “immovable ladder” that has leaned under a window since at least 1757.
Agreement was eventually reached, and an interdisciplinary team from the National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), led by chief scientific supervisor Antonia Moropoulou, worked on the Edicule from May 2016 to March 2017. The project cost about $4 million, funded mainly through the World Monuments Fund, with a major gift from Mica Ertegün and a contribution from King Abdullah II of Jordan.
What was under the marble
On 26 October 2016 the marble slab that covers the burial bed was lifted for the first time since at least 1555, when the Franciscans rebuilt the shrine. Beneath it the team found fill material and then a second, older marble slab, broken and carved with a small cross. Under that, by 28 October, the original limestone bench on which a body would have been laid was confirmed to be intact. Parts of the cave’s walls also survive behind the later masonry.
The cross-marked slab immediately raised a puzzle. Some specialists assumed it was Crusader work of the 12th century. Others thought it might be older still, already in place and cracked when al-Hakim’s men wrecked the church. The tomb was soon resealed, so the answer had to come from samples taken while it stood open.

How the mortar was dated
The team took mortar from several points in the Edicule and had it dated independently at two laboratories, NTUA’s materials science lab and the archaeometry lab of the University of the Peloponnese. They used optically stimulated luminescence, or OSL.
OSL works because natural radiation slowly builds up trapped electrons inside grains of quartz and feldspar. Sunlight empties those traps. When mortar is mixed and laid, the sand grains in it are exposed to light for the last time, and the clock starts again. In the lab, the grains are stimulated with light, and the glow they give off tells scientists how much radiation they have absorbed since. Divide that by the local radiation rate and you get an approximate age.
The method dates when the mortar was laid, not when the rock was carved or when anyone was buried. Every OSL result also carries a margin of error, so a single number like 345 should be read as “around the middle of the fourth century”.
The results, sample by sample
- Between the burial bed and the cross-marked slab: about A.D. 345. This is the key result, showing the older slab was set in Roman times, not by Crusaders.
- The south wall of the burial cave: two dates, about 335 and 1570. The second matches the documented 16th-century Franciscan restoration.
- The tomb entrance: 11th century, in line with the rebuilding that followed the 1009 destruction and was finished in 1048 under Emperor Constantine IX Monomachos.
The sequence fits what historians already knew from texts, which is what makes it persuasive. Moropoulou told National Geographic that the mortars “provide evidence for the earliest shrine on the site”. Martin Biddle, the archaeologist whose 1999 study traced the tomb’s history, was blunter: “Obviously that date is spot-on for whatever Constantine did.” The full study appeared in 2018 in the Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports.
What dating cannot prove, and common myths
Myth: science “authenticated” Jesus’ tomb. No laboratory test can identify a person buried in an empty first-century tomb. Calling it “authentic” only makes sense in a narrower way: the cave today is the one Constantine’s builders identified and enshrined. Whether that identification was right rests on local Christian memory of about three centuries, plus history and faith, not on mortar.
Myth: the tomb was lost in 1009. The new dates suggest that, although the shrine was badly damaged, parts of the original structure survived and were rebuilt around.
Myth: there is no other candidate. Many Protestant visitors know the Garden Tomb north of the Old City, popularised after 1883 by the British general Charles Gordon. Israeli archaeologist Gabriel Barkay has shown it was cut in the 8th–7th centuries BC, far too early for a burial in Jesus’ time. The Holy Sepulchre site, which most scholars place just outside the city wall of Jesus’ day, remains the stronger historical candidate.
A useful takeaway for anyone reading a “tomb of…” headline: ask what was actually dated, which event the method measures, and whether the claim goes beyond it. Here the answer is clear and still remarkable. A small limestone bench in Jerusalem has been venerated as one person’s grave for at least 1,680 years.
Visiting and the keys
The church is open to visitors daily, with long queues at the Edicule. One detail visitors often enjoy: since the time of Saladin in the late 12th century, two Muslim families have kept the keys and opened the great door each morning, a duty they still perform.
Photos: AP Photo/Sebastian Scheiner.
Sources: National Geographic (Kristin Romey); Church of the Holy Sepulchre (Wikipedia); Optically stimulated luminescence (Wikipedia); Garden Tomb (Wikipedia).

If compelling evidence are presented, I will believe
ReplyDelete