Originally published 2017-11-16.
Do men really avoid dating women who are smarter than they are? The best-known research on the question suggests a mixed answer. In a series of experiments published in 2015, many men said they liked the idea of a partner who outperformed them intellectually, but when they actually met a woman who had just beaten them on a test, they found her less attractive and showed less interest in seeing her again. That finding is real, but it describes a tendency in some situations, not a rule about all men, and it is no reason for anyone to play down their intelligence.
Here is what the research found, what it does not show, and how intelligent people can approach dating with that in mind.
A first date that ended too soon
New York psychotherapist F. Diane Barth opened a 2016 Psychology Today post with a story many readers recognised. A woman she called Sara met a man online who seemed a promising match. Over coffee they talked easily for about 45 minutes and found plenty in common. Then he checked his watch, said he had to go, and never got in touch again.
Sara, a scientist with advanced degrees, later realised that he left shortly after she mentioned a research paper she had just published. Barth was careful to point out that there could be many reasons for his exit, from simple lack of chemistry to difficulty with closeness. But the pattern of a confident man suddenly cooling off when a woman's achievements come up is common enough that researchers decided to test it.
What the 2015 study actually found
The study, by Lora Park, Ashley Young and Paul Eastwick, appeared in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin under the title "(Psychological) Distance Makes the Heart Grow Fonder". It reported six studies involving about 650 young adults, moving step by step from imagined scenarios to real meetings.
- Imagined women: when men read about a hypothetical female classmate who outperformed them in maths or English, they generally rated her as desirable.
- Real interaction: when men took a test in the same room as a woman and were told she had scored higher, they rated her as less attractive and were less keen to exchange contact details or plan a date.
- Feeling less masculine: men who were outperformed by a nearby woman they might date reported feeling less masculine, which the authors suggested could explain the change.
Popular coverage often added that men moved their chairs further away from a woman who had beaten them. Whatever the exact measures, the core result was summed up by Park herself: "We found that men preferred women who are smarter than them in psychologically distant situations." Up close, the same quality could feel like a threat.
What the research does not show
It is tempting to turn a study like this into a slogan such as "men are scared of smart women". That goes well beyond the evidence:
- The participants were mostly young students. Results from university volunteers in a lab may not reflect older adults, or people who have dated for years and know what they want.
- It measures averages. Even where the effect appeared, plenty of men did not react this way. Barth noted that she knows many men happily married to women they consider smarter than themselves.
- Domain matters. Park stressed that the effect showed up when the skill being tested mattered to the man. Someone who does not care about maths is unlikely to feel threatened by a woman who is better at it.
- It concerns first impressions. Short lab meetings say little about how couples feel once trust and familiarity grow.
One often-repeated claim also needs care. Some articles said the study involved only 105 men, and argued from that small number that the results did not matter. In fact the overall project involved around 650 participants across six studies, so the findings are more solid than that, though still limited in the ways above.
Why some people feel threatened by a smarter partner
The study's explanation is linked to how people protect their self-image. When someone close to us outperforms us at something we care about, it can sting more than when a stranger does. In romantic settings, some men may also carry expectations, picked up from family or culture, that they ought to be the more capable partner. When a date overturns that expectation, the easiest response is to withdraw.
The same reaction is not unique to men. Anyone can feel uneasy when a partner excels in their own field. The difference is in how people handle it: with curiosity and pride in each other, or with distance.
Dating advice for intelligent people
The useful lesson from the research is not to hide who you are but to look for people who are comfortable with it.
- Do not dim yourself. Downplaying your work or knowledge to seem less intimidating attracts people who prefer a smaller version of you, which is not a good basis for a relationship.
- Share, do not lecture. Talking about your interests with warmth and asking about theirs makes intelligence feel like an invitation rather than a contest.
- Watch how they respond. Someone who asks follow-up questions about your research or your job is showing exactly the kind of interest that lasts.
- Treat a quick exit as information. If a date loses interest when your achievements come up, you have learned something useful early, at the cost of a single coffee.
- Hold back emotionally at first. With online dating in particular, it helps not to invest heavily before you know someone, so one disappointing meeting does not knock your confidence.
Finding someone who values your mind
Sara's story had a happy ending. Barth reported that she later met a man who appreciates her intelligence, and the two were living together and planning a wedding. That is a reminder that the research describes some reactions in some moments, not the whole dating world.
Plenty of people actively look for a partner who challenges them and teaches them something new. The aim is not to win over everyone, but to find the person who is glad, not threatened, that you are clever.
Sources: Psychology Today (F. Diane Barth): Do Men Have a Problem Dating Smart Women?; University at Buffalo News: Lora Park on psychological distance and attraction; PsyPost: Attractive qualities admired from afar can be threatening; Psychology Today (Wendy L. Patrick): Are Men Actually Attracted to Smart Women?.
COMMENTS