Originally published 2017-11-11.
In the summer of 2017, volunteers from the marine conservation group Sea Shepherd spent about ten weeks in the Faroe Islands, the self-governing North Atlantic archipelago that belongs to the Kingdom of Denmark. Travelling as ordinary tourists between July and September, they photographed nine whale and dolphin hunts. According to Sea Shepherd, as reported by the Daily Mail, the hunts they witnessed killed 436 long-finned pilot whales and 198 Atlantic white-sided dolphins.
The hunts are called the grindadráp, or simply the grind. Boats drive a pod into a shallow bay, the animals strand, and men on the beach kill them with a spinal lance before cutting them to bleed. The meat and blubber are eaten locally. To the islanders it is a centuries-old food tradition; to campaigners it is an unnecessary slaughter that turns whole bays red.
Below are the photographs the volunteers released, each with a note on what it shows and the facts behind it, followed by what has changed since. Many images are graphic and are blurred until you tap them.
How the grind works
Pilot whale hunting in the Faroes goes back to the Norse settlers; bones in household remains date to about 1200, rules appear in the 1298 Sheep Letter, and written catch records begin in 1584. The islands’ government estimates that roughly 100,000 pilot whales live in the surrounding waters, and the catch has averaged about 700 a year over the long term.
A hunt starts when a pod is spotted near shore. Boats herd it into one of the bays approved for whaling. Since 2015 the law requires the mønustingari, a lance that severs the spinal cord in one stroke, and since January 2017 only certified men on the beach, using the approved hook, lance and knife, may kill the animals. Spears and harpoons have been banned since 1985.
The 2017 photographs

The hunt seen from a distance: pilot whales lie in the reddened shallows below a village while people walk among them. Scenes like this one, photographed by Sea Shepherd volunteers in summer 2017, are what the Faroese call a grind. The red colour comes from the cut that is made to bleed each animal after it is killed.

Boats, an inflatable and onlookers gather around a beached pod at a harbour. Drives are organised at community level and anyone with a boat may join, which is why modern fishing vessels and small craft often work side by side. Sea Shepherd’s watermark in the corner marks the group as the photographer.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
Men in high-visibility vests work among the whales in a bay overlooked by a small church. Only people on the beach holding the approved tools may kill the animals, under rules that took effect in January 2017. The second frame shows whales still in the water as the kill moves along the shore.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
A man uses a mønustingari, the Faroese spinal lance, on a dolphin held at the water’s edge. The tool is designed to cut the spinal cord with one deep stroke behind the blowhole; it came into use in 2011 and became compulsory in 2015. Faroese authorities say this makes death fast, while critics question how long the whole drive and stranding lasts.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
Close-ups of Atlantic white-sided dolphins after the kill, showing the deep cut at the back of the head. These smaller, black-grey-and-white dolphins are caught alongside the far larger pilot whales. Since 2000 the islands have averaged roughly 300 white-sided dolphins a year, though totals vary widely.

Before the beach comes the drive. A line of boats herds a pod toward a shallow bay; stones on lines are traditionally thrown behind the whales to keep them from turning back to sea. A hunt can only go ahead in bays approved for whaling, and the district foreman must authorise it.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
White-sided dolphins laid out on a quay after a hunt, with locals and visitors looking on. Measuring and laying out the catch lets officials record each animal before the meat is divided. Every grind is logged, and those records stretch back to 1584.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
Three frames of pilot whales and dolphins at the shoreline, roped and bleeding. Ropes and the blunt blowhole hook, the blásturkrókur introduced in 1993, are used to pull the animals onto land. Spears and harpoons were banned in 1985.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
Spectators watch from the rocks while men wade into the bloodied water. Whale drives are public events in the Faroes, and whole families often come to the shore. For campaigners, the crowds and the colour of the water are the core of the protest; for many islanders, the hunt is a shared food tradition.

A row of whales and dolphins lies on the harbourside in front of brightly painted houses. Pilot whale meat and blubber are traditionally dried, salted or, today, more often frozen. The catch is traditionally shared among those who took part and local households rather than sold on an industrial scale.
Scenes from the shore and the quay

A deck crane lifts a pilot whale aboard a boat. Long-finned pilot whales can weigh well over a tonne, so moving them from the shore to the quay where they are measured and divided usually needs machinery.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
A slipway and shallow harbour turned red, with whale carcasses in the water. Sea Shepherd’s volunteers said they photographed nine separate hunts between July and September 2017. The group’s campaign aimed to show the scale of what happens on these beaches to an international audience.

A small boat called Eiði pushes a pod through dark water toward land. The drive stage can take hours, depending on how far out the pod was spotted. Animal-welfare groups argue this chase is the most stressful part of the hunt, a point the Faroese government disputes.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
A close view of a pilot whale’s neck wound beside a boot and hook in the red shallows. The cut is made to bleed the animal quickly after the spinal cord has been severed. These are the images that made the 2017 set so widely shared, and so disturbing for many viewers.

Pilot whale meat, dark and almost black, vacuum-packed in plastic. Freezing has largely replaced traditional drying. Faroese health officials have advised adults to eat no more than about one meal of pilot whale a month, and never the liver or kidneys, because of high mercury levels.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
Dorsal fins break the surface of a bloodied bay as dead pilot whales float in the foreground, a coiled rope and hooks on the quay at the right. Laws since 2013 require that whales be beached or grounded on the seabed before they are killed.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
A boy, his face pixelated by the photographers, cuts into a whale with a knife while other children gather round a carcass. Children are often present at a grind, which the Faroese see as part of passing on a tradition and campaigners see as one of the hunt’s most troubling features.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
Left, the head of a dead pilot whale on the quay; right, a man butchering a dolphin. Butchery happens within hours, on the dock, so the meat stays fresh. The division of the catch follows long-standing local custom.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
A man waist-deep in red water hauls a rope tied to a whale. Getting the animals close enough to shore is hard, physical work, and it falls to the men who hold the hunting certificate and tools required by law.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
A boy, face pixelated, holds up hands stained with whale blood. Sea Shepherd chose images like this to provoke reaction abroad, and they did; in the Faroes, many residents said the group framed a normal community event in the most shocking way possible.
After the hunt: dividing the catch
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
A young man with whale blood smeared across his forehead, standing among others at the shore. Pictures like this were among the most shared from the campaign, because they show how close young islanders are to the work of the hunt.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
A man in a high-visibility jacket stands in red water among the bodies of pilot whales. Each district has a hunt foreman responsible for seeing that a grind follows the regulations.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
A pilot whale hangs from a crane on the quay; beside it, a close-up of the neck cut. Whales are measured on the quay so that the catch can be recorded and divided into shares under a traditional system.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
Labelled bags of meat waiting to be collected, and a man cutting up a carcass on a table. The handwritten numbers suggest how the catch is split into shares for collection. The scene is part kitchen, part community hall.

A shop corner with coiled ropes, hooks and Faroese knitwear on display. Equipment like the gaff and rope is part of everyday life on the islands, sold alongside ordinary goods. Wool sweaters are among the islands’ best-known crafts.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
A small child in a buggy watches as an adult cuts into a pilot whale, and a group of children poses near the carcasses. Sea Shepherd blurred the children’s faces. Their presence was one of the group’s main criticisms in 2017.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
A gutted pilot whale on the quay, with others laid out behind it near a lorry. The internal organs are removed first; the liver and kidneys, which carry the highest levels of contaminants, should not be eaten at all according to Faroese health advice.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
Three frames of dead pilot whales floating in blood-red water. The colour is what made the Faroese hunt notorious worldwide, and pictures like these circulated widely on social media after the 2017 campaign.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
Dolphins lined up nose to tail on a dock, with streams of blood running toward the water. Counting the catch is part of the official record: Sea Shepherd said its volunteers counted 198 white-sided dolphins and 436 pilot whales across the nine hunts they documented.
Sensitive photo: tap or click to view
A final wide view of the bay with dead pilot whales in the shallows. Some years see far fewer whales than others: the yearly catch has swung from a few hundred to more than a thousand, which is why critics and officials disagree about sustainability.
Health warnings about whale meat
One of the strongest arguments against eating pilot whale comes from the Faroes themselves. Research led by Faroese physician Pál Weihe and Danish scientist Philippe Grandjean linked mercury exposure before birth to subtle developmental effects in children. In 2008 the islands’ chief medical officer and Weihe recommended that pilot whale no longer be considered fit for human consumption. That was advice, not a ban; official guidance now says adults should limit it to about one meal a month and never eat the liver or kidneys, and that women should take particular care before and during pregnancy. Anyone with questions about their own diet should talk to a doctor.
What has changed since 2017
The debate flared again in September 2021, when more than 1,400 white-sided dolphins were killed in a single drive at Skálafjørður, by far the largest dolphin catch on record (reports give 1,423 or 1,428). It drew criticism even within the Faroes, and the local hunt foreman reportedly had not been notified or approved it. A petition calling for a ban gathered almost 1.3 million signatures.
In July 2022 the Faroese government set a provisional limit of 500 white-sided dolphins a year for 2022 and 2023 while it waited for scientific advice from the North Atlantic Marine Mammal Commission. The pilot whale hunt itself was not restricted, and the government continues to defend it as sustainable and part of local food supply.
Whatever side you take, the most useful facts are these: the hunt is legal, regulated and non-industrial; the pilot whale population is not considered endangered; and the strongest case for eating less of it comes from Faroese doctors worried about mercury.
Sources: Photographs by Sea Shepherd Global volunteers, first published by the Daily Mail (November 2017); Wikipedia: Whaling in the Faroe Islands; Faroese Government: Whaling in the Faroe Islands; Al Jazeera, 10 July 2022.

Shame some other creature, more powerful than us, doesn't have that primal tradition and kill some people once a year...
ReplyDeleteThere is. It's called Government.
DeleteQuá kinh khủng, tôi không thể xem tiếp được nữa. Tôi không hiểu lí do vì sao họ làm việc này nhưng thực sự quá tàn nhẫn.
ReplyDelete