Do Gym Selfies Signal Narcissism? What the Facebook Study Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2017-10-07.

Fitness Posts and a Study of Narcissistic Traits

Do people who constantly post their workouts on Facebook tend to be narcissists? A 2015 study from Brunel University London found a link: among 555 Facebook users, those who scored higher on a measure of narcissism posted more often about their achievements and about their diet and exercise. Those posts also tended to collect more likes and comments.

That does not mean everyone who shares a gym selfie or a 10K time is a narcissist. The study measured tendencies across a group, using questionnaires, and the effect sizes in this kind of research are usually modest. Here is what the researchers actually found, what "narcissism" means in this context, and how to think about your own posting habits.

What the Brunel study found

The research was led by psychologist Tara Marshall with Katharina Lefringhausen and Nelli Ferenczi and published in the journal Personality and Individual Differences in 2015. The team asked 555 Facebook users to complete online surveys covering the "Big Five" personality traits (extraversion, agreeableness, conscientiousness, neuroticism and openness), self-esteem and narcissism, and to report which topics they wrote about in their status updates.

Several patterns stood out:

  • Narcissism was linked to more updates about accomplishments, which the authors tied to a need for attention and validation. Narcissistic users also posted more about diet and exercise, which the researchers interpreted as a way of showing off the effort they put into their appearance.
  • Low self-esteem was linked to more posts about a current romantic partner.
  • Conscientiousness was linked to more posts about one's children.

Marshall summed up the starting point plainly, saying it might come as little surprise that status updates "reflect people's personality traits".

The likes paradox

One of the more interesting findings concerns feedback. Users who posted about their achievements reported receiving more likes and comments on those posts. On the surface, that sounds like the audience approves.

Marshall offered a more cautious reading: friends might "politely offer support while secretly disliking such egotistical displays". In other words, a like is a cheap social gesture. It can mean admiration, encouragement, habit, or simply not wanting to seem unsupportive. The study did not measure what friends privately thought, so this part remains a hypothesis rather than a result.

It is easy to see how the loop could work, though. Someone who craves validation posts a workout, receives a burst of likes, and is rewarded for posting again.

What "narcissism" means in research like this

In everyday speech, "narcissist" often means a selfish or manipulative person. In psychology there are two quite different ideas.

Narcissistic personality disorder is a clinical diagnosis made by a qualified professional. It involves a long-standing, pervasive pattern of grandiosity, need for admiration and lack of empathy that causes real problems in a person's life.

Studies like this one instead measure everyday, or "subclinical", narcissism, usually with questionnaires such as the Narcissistic Personality Inventory, first developed by Raskin and Hall in 1979. These tools ask people to choose between paired statements and capture traits such as vanity, a sense of superiority, exhibitionism and a desire for authority. Everyone sits somewhere on this scale. A higher score does not mean someone has a disorder, and the inventory itself has been criticised because its scores partly overlap with healthy self-esteem.

So when a headline says gym posters "are narcissists", what the data really show is that, on average, people who post more about exercise scored a little higher on a trait that everyone has to some degree.

Limits of the study

This was a useful, well-designed survey, but it has the limits of most social-media personality research:

  • Correlation, not cause. Posting about the gym does not make someone narcissistic, and the study cannot show that narcissism causes the posting.
  • Self-report. Participants described their own traits and their own posting habits, and people are not always accurate about either.
  • One platform, one moment. The data come from Facebook in the mid-2010s. Instagram, TikTok and fitness apps such as Strava have since changed how and why people share workouts.
  • Many motives. People post fitness updates to stay accountable, to celebrate recovery from illness, to find training partners, to inspire friends, or as part of their job. A single trait cannot explain all of that.

Why people share workouts

Fitness is a natural topic for social media. Progress is visible and measurable, and training often involves real effort and discipline, so it feels worth celebrating. Public commitment can also help people stick with a habit: telling friends you are training for a race makes it harder to quit quietly.

There is a community side too. Running clubs, gym groups and online challenges rely on people sharing their sessions, and many beginners say seeing ordinary people's progress helped them get started. For people recovering from injury, illness or a difficult period, a workout post can be a way of saying "I'm back".

Narcissism, in the study's sense, describes a different motive: posting mainly to be admired, and feeling uneasy when the admiration does not come.

Practical takeaways for your own feed

The researchers suggested that greater awareness of how status updates come across could help people avoid topics that irritate friends more than they entertain them. A few questions can help:

  • Who is this post for? If it would help a friend, share a tip, or mark a genuine milestone, it is likely to land well.
  • How often? A finished marathon is news. A daily mirror photo can start to feel like a performance.
  • How do I feel after posting? If your mood depends heavily on the number of likes, that is worth noticing, and it may be a sign to spend less time on the app.
  • Is there a better audience? Training apps, club chats and accountability partners often give more useful feedback than a general feed.

Above all, keep the workout itself at the centre. Exercise is good for body and mind whether or not anyone sees it.

Sources: ScienceDaily: Brunel University London release on Facebook status updates (May 2015); Marshall, T. C., Lefringhausen, K. and Ferenczi, N., Personality and Individual Differences 85 (2015); Wikipedia: Narcissistic Personality Inventory.

COMMENTS