NASA's Yellowstone Supervolcano Cooling Plan: What It Proposed

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2017-10-10.

A NASA Engineer’s 2017 Idea for Cooling the Yellowstone Supervolcano

In 2017 a NASA engineer floated an unusual idea: drill into the rocks around the Yellowstone supervolcano, pump water through them, and use the heat to make electricity while slowly cooling the magma below. It was not a NASA warning of an imminent disaster, and it was never an approved project. It was a thought experiment by Brian Wilcox of NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory about how humanity might one day reduce one of the planet's largest natural hazards. Volcano scientists found it interesting but doubted it would work.

Here is what the proposal said, what a Yellowstone supereruption would really mean, and what the US Geological Survey says about the risk.

Why a NASA engineer was thinking about volcanoes

Wilcox had served on the NASA Advisory Council's committee on planetary defence, which studies how to protect Earth from asteroids and comets. In an interview with the BBC in August 2017, he said that work had led him to an uncomfortable conclusion: "the supervolcano threat is substantially greater than the asteroid or comet threat."

His reasoning was about frequency. Truly giant eruptions happen more often, over geological time, than impacts by asteroids large enough to threaten civilisation. But unlike an asteroid, which can in principle be nudged off course, there had been little serious thought about whether a supervolcano could be managed at all.

What makes Yellowstone a supervolcano

Volcanologists use the word "supervolcano" for a volcano that has produced at least one eruption of magnitude 8 on the Volcanic Explosivity Index, the top of the scale. That means throwing out more than 1,000 cubic kilometres (about 240 cubic miles) of material in a single event.

Yellowstone has done this, or come close, three times:

  • about 2.08 million years ago, the Huckleberry Ridge eruption, the largest, with more than 2,450 cubic kilometres of ash and rock;
  • about 1.3 million years ago, the much smaller Mesa Falls eruption;
  • about 631,000 years ago, the Lava Creek eruption, which formed today's Yellowstone Caldera, a basin roughly 30 by 45 miles across.

Since then the volcano has produced many smaller lava flows. The most recent, on the Pitchstone Plateau, was about 70,000 years ago. The most recent supereruption anywhere on Earth was the Oruanui eruption of Taupō in New Zealand, roughly 25,500 to 26,500 years ago, according to published estimates.

What a supereruption would do

A repeat of the Lava Creek eruption would devastate the area around the park with pyroclastic flows, fast-moving avalanches of hot gas and rock. Ash would fall across much of the United States, thickest in Wyoming, Montana and Idaho, where it could reach a metre or more, and thinner but still damaging far to the east. Even a few centimetres of ash can collapse roofs, ruin crops, contaminate water and stop aircraft and vehicles.

The global effect would come from sulphur gases pushed into the stratosphere, where they form tiny droplets that reflect sunlight. That can cool the planet for several years, a so-called volcanic winter. Exactly how severe it would be is debated. Studies of the much larger Toba eruption in Indonesia, about 74,000 years ago, have not settled how badly it affected climate or early humans. Claims that a Yellowstone eruption would wipe out most of humanity are the worst-case end of a wide range.

Wilcox's plan: cool the magma and make power

The idea is to treat Yellowstone's heat as a resource. Engineers would drill into hot rock from several miles outside the national park, approaching the magma chamber slowly from the sides and from below rather than from the top, which Wilcox acknowledged could risk setting off the very eruption the project aimed to prevent.

Water would be pumped down the borehole under high pressure, roughly 10 kilometres deep, heated by the rock to more than 600°F (about 315°C), and brought back up to drive turbines in a geothermal power plant. The cooled water would then be sent back down to collect more heat. Wilcox's team estimated that drawing off about 35 percent of the heat flowing up from the chamber might be enough to stop the magma from building toward an eruption.

The estimated cost was about $3.46 billion. Wilcox argued that, unlike most disaster-prevention schemes, this one could pay for itself by selling clean electricity at competitive prices. The catch is time: cooling the system meaningfully would take thousands of years, so any benefit would be felt by generations far in the future.

Wilcox framed the stakes in stark terms. Stopping a supervolcano from wrecking the world's food supply and "causing the deaths of 99 percent of all of humanity, that seems like a worthwhile thing to debate," he told NBC News. That figure is his own worst case, not a scientific consensus.

What volcano scientists say

Outside experts were cautious. Charles Connor, a volcanologist at the University of South Florida, told NBC News the idea was "pie in the sky right now", while adding that it was a useful direction to think about given how unprepared humanity is for such events.

The US Geological Survey, which runs the Yellowstone Volcano Observatory, has been more direct. It says drilling is unlikely to have much effect, because minerals crystallising out of the hot natural fluids would quickly seal any borehole. There are also practical problems: no one has drilled anywhere near that deep into such a hot, active system, and the park's geysers and hot springs are protected.

The USGS also offers some reassurance. It puts the yearly chance of another caldera-forming eruption at Yellowstone at about 1 in 730,000 and says there is no evidence that one is imminent. Its scientists stress that Yellowstone is not "overdue": volcanoes do not erupt on a timetable. The most likely future eruption is a lava flow, like the one 70,000 years ago, which would cause local damage but no global catastrophe.

Common myths about Yellowstone

"NASA warned of a global catastrophe"

No. The story began with one engineer's proposal and a BBC interview. NASA did not issue any warning, and no NASA project to drill Yellowstone exists.

"Yellowstone is about to blow"

Earthquake swarms, ground uplift and new steam vents happen regularly at Yellowstone and are closely monitored. None of them has indicated a coming supereruption. The bigger everyday hazard in the park is hydrothermal explosions, steam-driven blasts that have left more than 20 large craters in the past 14,000 years.

"Recent natural disasters mean the planet is getting more volcanic"

There is no evidence that volcanic activity overall is increasing. We simply hear about eruptions faster than ever, thanks to satellites, sensors and social media.

Why the idea still matters

Even if Yellowstone is never drilled, Wilcox's proposal raised a serious question: should humanity plan for very rare natural disasters the way it plans for asteroid strikes? Better monitoring, ash-fall planning, food reserves and research into geothermal energy are all useful whether or not a supereruption ever comes. For now, the sensible response to Yellowstone headlines is curiosity, not fear.

Sources: NBC News: Scientists hatch bold plan to save the planet from a supervolcano; USGS: Questions about supervolcanoes; Wikipedia: Yellowstone Caldera; Wikipedia: Supervolcano; original interview: BBC Future (2017).

COMMENTS