Why Loners Make Loyal Friends: Solitude, Trust and Friendship

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2017-10-07.

Enjoying Solitude and Building Dependable Friendships

Image: Curious Mind Magazine

People who like their own company are often misread. A colleague who skips the after-work drinks, a friend who answers messages a day late, a neighbour who walks alone every evening: it is easy to assume they are sad, shy or unfriendly. Very often they are none of those things. They simply prefer a small circle, and they guard it carefully.

That is the real reason the "lone wolf" has a reputation as a loyal friend. Someone who keeps only a handful of close relationships tends to put more into each one. Getting into that circle can take time, but once you are there, the friendship is usually steady, honest and long-lasting. Below we look at what being a loner actually means, how it differs from loneliness, what psychology says about solitude and personality, and how to build a good friendship with someone who needs more space than most.

Being alone is not the same as being lonely

Psychologists draw a clear line between solitude and loneliness. Solitude is time alone that a person chooses and often enjoys. Loneliness is the painful gap between the connection someone wants and the connection they have. One is a preference; the other is a kind of hunger.

So a person who feels lonely is, in a sense, the opposite of a loner. The lonely person wants more company than they are getting. The loner usually has about as much company as they want and is content to spend the rest of the time reading, walking, working on a project or just thinking.

Research summarised in the psychology literature describes several benefits of chosen solitude: more freedom from social pressure, room for creativity, time for self-reflection and a calmer, clearer head. Psychologist Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi noted that teenagers who cannot bear being alone often stop developing their creative talents. At the same time, studies of adolescents suggest that the healthiest pattern is a balance: young people who mix time alone with time with friends tend to do better than those who are alone most of the time.

In other words, enjoying solitude is healthy. Being cut off from everyone, against your will, is not.

Why people who like solitude choose friends so carefully

If you only want a few close relationships, you naturally become selective. Many loners are not interested in small talk for its own sake, office gossip or large gatherings where nobody really listens. They would rather spend an evening with one person who is curious and sincere than with twenty acquaintances.

This selectiveness is not arrogance. Most loners are fairly realistic about themselves, flaws included. The care they take comes from valuing their time and energy. They observe people, notice how others behave when nobody is watching, and slowly decide whom they trust.

That slow approach has a useful side effect. Friendships that form gradually, through repeated honest conversations, are often sturdier than those built on a burst of excitement. Communication researcher Jeffrey Hall estimated that it takes roughly 20 to 60 hours of time together in the first weeks to turn an acquaintance into a friend, and well over a hundred hours to build a close friendship. A person who invests that time deliberately, in a small number of people, is making a serious commitment.

Two kinds of loners: outgoing and quiet

Not every loner is an introvert. It helps to think of two broad styles.

The sociable loner

Some people who keep a tight circle are perfectly comfortable in a crowd. They can chat with a stranger at a wedding, give a speech or work a room when they need to. What they do not do is turn every pleasant conversation into a close friendship. They are friendly with many and close to few, and they keep a polite distance until someone proves trustworthy. If one of these people starts treating you as a real friend, it usually means you have shown, without knowing it, that you are honest and reliable.

The quiet loner

Others find crowds, noise and long social events draining. They are unlikely to be at the front of a concert or the centre of a party. Their idea of a good evening is a quiet meal, a walk or a long talk with one or two people they trust. If a quiet loner regularly chooses to spend time with you, take it as a compliment: they feel relaxed and free to be themselves in your company.

Both types tend to value the same things in a friend: sincerity, genuine interest, kindness and a mind that likes to explore ideas.

What psychology says about introverts, loners and intelligence

The words "introvert" and "extravert" were popularised by the Swiss psychiatrist Carl Jung in the early twentieth century. Modern personality research, including the widely used Big Five model, treats extraversion as a scale rather than two boxes. Most people sit somewhere in the middle, a position sometimes called ambiversion, and introverts and extraverts overlap a great deal in how they actually behave day to day.

A few popular claims deserve a closer look:

  • "Loners are more intelligent." There is no solid evidence that liking solitude makes someone smarter. Older studies linked introversion with academic success, but more recent large analyses paint a mixed picture, with some parts of extraversion also linked to higher cognitive ability. Intelligence is not a personality style.
  • "Loners are shy or socially anxious." Not necessarily. Introversion is a preference for quieter settings; shyness and social anxiety involve fear or distress. Plenty of loners are confident, and plenty of outgoing people are anxious.
  • "Loners are always more loyal." A preference for solitude does not guarantee loyalty, depth or kindness. What it does often mean is that each friendship receives more attention. Judge any friend by how they treat you over time, not by a personality label.

Writer Susan Cain, author of Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World That Can't Stop Talking, reports studies suggesting that between a third and a half of Americans are introverts. Being one is common, not strange.

How to be a good friend to someone who values space

If a person you care about enjoys solitude, a few habits make the friendship easier for both of you:

  • Ask how they like to stay in touch. Some prefer a planned coffee to a surprise visit, or a thoughtful message to a stream of daily chats.
  • Do not read silence as rejection. A slow reply often just means they were busy, recharging or thinking.
  • Keep invitations low-pressure. Make it easy to say "not this time" without guilt, and keep inviting.
  • Choose settings that suit them. One-to-one time, a walk or a small dinner is often better than a big party.
  • Be honest, especially when you get something wrong. People who choose friends carefully tend to value sincerity above almost anything. A straightforward apology goes a long way; pretending usually does real damage.
  • Keep confidences. Reliability and discretion are among the qualities Mayo Clinic lists as the foundations of strong friendships.

When solitude stops being healthy

Chosen solitude is fine. Sometimes, though, what looks like a preference for being alone is a sign that something is wrong. Long periods of isolation that a person did not choose can feed loneliness and low mood, and withdrawing from people you used to enjoy can be an early sign of depression or anxiety.

Worth noticing in yourself or a friend: losing interest in things that used to bring joy, avoiding people out of fear rather than preference, or feeling empty rather than rested after time alone. If that sounds familiar, gently checking in, or talking to a doctor or counsellor, is a sensible step.

The friendship worth waiting for

Friendship research keeps reaching a similar conclusion: the quality of a few close relationships matters more for well-being than the number of people you know. Strong social ties are linked with better health, lower stress and a greater sense of belonging.

People who like their own company tend to understand this instinctively. They are not collecting contacts. They are looking for a few people with whom they can be completely themselves. If you are one of those people for someone, you have something valuable: a friend who chose you on purpose and is likely to stay. Treat that trust with care, and it will usually be returned many times over.

Sources: Wikipedia: Solitude; Wikipedia: Extraversion and introversion; Wikipedia: Friendship (Hall, 2019, on hours needed to form friendships); Mayo Clinic: Friendships, enrich your life and improve your health. Header image: Curious Mind Magazine.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1