Originally published 2017-10-24.

Looking for deep questions to think about on your own or to bring to a dinner table, classroom or late-night conversation? Here are seventy, grouped by theme: the mind, knowledge and reality, identity, right and wrong, the good life, love and relationships, and the universe itself. Where a question has a famous history, a short note tells you who asked it first and where the debate stands, so you have a starting point rather than a dead end.
Philosophy rarely hands out final answers. What it does well is sharpen a question until you can see exactly where people disagree and why. Use these that way: pick one, define your terms, try an example, and see where it leads.
Questions about the mind and consciousness
Consciousness is the one thing each of us knows directly and the thing science finds hardest to explain. Philosopher David Chalmers called this the "hard problem" in the mid-1990s: why do physical processes in the brain come with any inner experience at all?
- What is consciousness, and what is it for?
- Is your experience of the colour red the same as mine? Thomas Nagel's 1974 essay "What Is It Like to Be a Bat?" argues that experience has a subjective side no outside description can fully capture.
- At what point does a developing human become conscious?
- Where do thoughts come from before you notice them?
- Is there a soul, or is the mind entirely the work of the brain?
- If a soul exists, where is it located? Descartes famously suggested the pineal gland; few people today accept that answer, but the question of how mind and body connect is still open.
- Is there a real boundary between madness and creative genius?
- What is intelligence, and can it be measured with one number?
- How sure are you that you can tell imagination from reality?
Questions about knowledge, truth and reality
Epistemology asks what we can know and how. These questions test how much of your everyday confidence rests on assumptions.
- Is there one truth that holds for everyone, everywhere?
- How do you know your senses are giving you an accurate picture?
- Is there anything at all you can be completely certain of? Descartes concluded that the one thing he could not doubt was that he was doubting, and therefore thinking.
- Could your whole life be a dream? The Chinese philosopher Zhuangzi asked whether he was a man who had dreamed of being a butterfly, or a butterfly dreaming of being a man.
- Could we be living in a computer simulation? Nick Bostrom's 2003 argument does not claim we are; it argues that one of three possibilities must be true, one of which is that most minds like ours are simulated.
- If a tree falls with nobody nearby, does it make a sound? Often credited to George Berkeley, though he never wrote it; the answer depends on whether "sound" means air vibrations or the experience of hearing.
- Does the act of observing something change what happens? In quantum physics "observation" means physical interaction with a measuring device, not a person looking, which is a common source of confusion.
- Why do people accept claims they have never seen evidence for?
- Can thinking positively really attract events into your life? The "law of attraction" has no scientific support, though optimism can change how people act, which in turn affects outcomes.
Questions about identity and free will
- What makes you the person you are?
- Is a person defined by their actions, their memories or something else?
- Do genes or upbringing shape personality more? Twin studies suggest both matter substantially, and that they interact.
- How many of your choices are truly yours, and how many are made by habit or other people?
- Do we have free will, or is every choice determined by prior causes?
- How much of your life is really under your control?
- What is stopping you from doing the things you most want to do?
Questions about right and wrong
Ethics questions are the easiest to start and the hardest to finish. Most people find that their gut reactions do not fit any single neat rule.
- Is it more important to do the right thing or to do things the right way?
- Where do the ideas of good and evil come from? Plato's Euthyphro asks whether something is good because the gods approve of it, or whether they approve of it because it is good.
- Who gets to decide what counts as moral?
- Is a wrong act still wrong if nobody ever finds out? In Plato's Republic, Glaucon tells the story of the Ring of Gyges, which makes its wearer invisible, to ask whether anyone would stay just without fear of being caught.
- If lying is wrong, why do so many people think small, kind lies are acceptable?
- Would it be right to sacrifice ten people to save a hundred? This is the logic of the trolley problem, raised by Philippa Foot in 1967 and named by Judith Jarvis Thomson. Most people will pull a lever to divert a runaway trolley but refuse to push someone off a bridge to achieve the same result.
- Are some things right or wrong regardless of culture and time?
- Does honour still mean anything in modern life?
Questions about happiness and a good life
- What does real happiness consist of?
- Money cannot buy happiness, but can a person be happy with none?
- Would happiness mean anything if we never felt sadness?
- What is the difference between living and merely being alive?
- Is there one best way to live?
- Does life need a reason to be worth living?
- Does life have a meaning, or do we create it?
- Which is worse, trying and failing or never trying at all?
- Why do we fear losing things we never really owned?
- What is freedom, and how would you know if you had it?
- If someone reached enlightenment, what would they want next?
- If you could change one thing about the world, what would you choose?
- What advice would you give a newborn, if it could understand you?
- What is education for?
Questions about love, friendship and other people
- What makes someone a good friend?
- What is true love, and how is it different from attraction?
- Do family ties still matter as much as they once did?
- Is trust more important than love?
- Is it easier to love someone or to be loved?
- Is it better to have loved and lost than never to have loved? Tennyson answered yes in his 1850 poem In Memoriam A.H.H.
- Would you rather be admired or respected?
- Who is really powerful?
- What is real beauty?
Questions about the universe, time and mathematics
- Is there life on other planets?
- Does God exist?
- Are there powers or beings greater than us?
- How did the universe begin, and was there a "before"?
- What will happen when the world ends?
- Does the universe have an edge?
- What happens to us after death?
- Where were we before we were born?
- What exactly is a number? Does "three" exist anywhere apart from three things?
- Is mathematics invented or discovered?
- What is infinity, and can anything real be infinite?
- What is gravity, at the deepest level? Newton described how it behaves; Einstein recast it as the curving of space-time; how it fits with quantum physics is still unresolved.
- What is time? Augustine wrote that he knew what time was until someone asked him to explain it.
- If life evolved from simple organisms, why are there still simple organisms? This rests on a misunderstanding: evolution does not say later life came from today's amoebas. Living groups share extinct common ancestors, and one ancestral population can give rise to several lineages that continue side by side, as the National Center for Science Education explains.
How to get the most out of a big question
Large questions can feel either thrilling or pointless, depending on how you approach them. A few habits make them more productive:
- Define one key word first. Half of most disagreements about "freedom", "love" or "truth" turn out to be about different meanings of the word.
- Bring a concrete example. A real or imagined case keeps the discussion grounded and lets others test your answer.
- Look for the exception. If you think lying is always wrong, ask about the person hiding refugees from soldiers. Exceptions show what your principle is really about.
- Accept a clearer disagreement as progress. Ending with "we disagree because you value fairness and I value outcomes" is more useful than a vague consensus.
- Write your answer down and revisit it. Your views on the same question at 20, 40 and 60 can be strikingly different, and seeing that change is a lesson of its own.
Some of these questions you will answer in seconds, and others may stay with you for years. Both are fine. The value lies less in the final answer than in noticing what you already believe and asking whether you still agree with it.
Sources: Wikipedia: Hard problem of consciousness; Wikipedia: Simulation hypothesis; Wikipedia: If a tree falls in a forest; Wikipedia: Euthyphro dilemma; Wikipedia: Ring of Gyges; Wikipedia: Trolley problem; NCSE: common misconceptions about evolution.

COMMENTS