Intelligence and Prejudice: What the Brandt and Crawford Study Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2017-09-19.

Cognitive Ability and Prejudice: Looking Beyond a Simple Ranking

Are smarter people less prejudiced? A widely shared answer says yes, but the research behind it tells a more interesting story. In a 2016 study, social psychologists Mark Brandt of Tilburg University and Jarret Crawford of The College of New Jersey found that people across the whole range of cognitive ability express prejudice. What changes with ability is not how much people dislike others, but which groups they tend to dislike.

Below we look at what the study measured, what it found, why earlier headlines oversimplified it, and what decades of research say actually helps reduce prejudice.

What the study measured

Brandt and Crawford, publishing in the journal Social Psychological and Personality Science, used data from the 2012 American National Election Studies, a large long-running survey of US voters; the analysed sample covered 5,914 people. Participants rated how warmly or coldly they felt towards 24 different groups, from ethnic minorities and gay people to big business, Christian fundamentalists, the Tea Party and the military.

Cognitive ability was measured with a short vocabulary test, a common stand-in in surveys because vocabulary scores correlate fairly well with general intelligence. It is not a full IQ test, which is worth remembering when reading headlines about “low-IQ” or “high-IQ” people.

The researchers defined prejudice simply as a negative evaluation of someone based on their group membership, whether that group has high or low status in society. That definition matters: much earlier research looked only at attitudes towards disadvantaged minorities, which can make one side of the spectrum look far more prejudiced than the other.

What they found: both ends show bias

According to Live Science’s report on the paper, participants with lower scores were more negative towards groups seen as liberal and towards groups people do not choose to belong to, such as Black, Hispanic and Asian Americans and gay and lesbian people. Participants with higher scores were more negative towards groups seen as conventional or conservative and that people choose to join, such as big business, Christian fundamentalists, the Tea Party and the military.

The paper’s abstract states that people with higher and lower ability show roughly the same overall level of intergroup bias. In other words, higher cognitive ability did not switch prejudice off; it shifted its target. Brandt summed it up: “Both people with high and low cognitive ability seem to express prejudice towards people they disagree with.” He also called the pattern “depressingly robust.”

Both factors, how liberal or conservative a group seems and whether membership is chosen, independently predicted dislike. The findings are associations in survey data. They show who tends to hold which attitudes, not that intelligence itself causes them.

Correcting the popular version

Many viral write-ups of this research claimed the study “proves” that intelligent people are open-minded and only less intelligent people are prejudiced. That is not what the authors reported. A fairer summary is that prejudice is found at every level of ability, and that people at different levels tend to direct it at different groups.

The study does fit with earlier work. A 2015 meta-analysis in the European Journal of Personality found that lower cognitive ability is associated with socially conservative views and with prejudice towards traditional target groups. Brandt and Crawford’s contribution was to widen the list of target groups and show that the picture changes when you do.

Explaining their findings to Broadly, the authors said:

“People dislike people who are different from them. Derogating people with different worldviews can help people maintain the validity of their own world view.”

That idea, known in psychology as the worldview conflict hypothesis, suggests prejudice is partly about protecting one’s own sense of what is right.

Why people keep their distance from others

Dislike is only part of the explanation. People also sort the world into “us” and “them” quickly and automatically, and groups that seem very different can feel less predictable. Some research suggests that seeing others as clearly separate can make them feel less threatening, because they seem to belong to a different sphere of life.

Values also play a role. Brandt’s other work has found that people tend to dislike those they believe hold different moral values. Yet he has stressed that disagreement and dislike are not the same thing: you can reject someone’s views without rejecting them as a person.

What reduces prejudice, according to research

The best-studied approach is contact between groups. The psychologist Gordon Allport proposed in 1954 that contact reduces prejudice most when people meet as equals, share a common goal, cooperate rather than compete, and have support from institutions or social norms. A 2006 meta-analysis by Thomas Pettigrew and Linda Tropp of 515 studies found that contact generally does reduce prejudice, and works better when Allport’s conditions are present, as summarised in Wikipedia’s overview of the contact hypothesis.

The research has limits. Many studies measure attitudes only a short time after the contact, and people who are already less prejudiced may be the ones who seek out contact. Negative or forced encounters can even make attitudes worse.

The ten-minute conversation

One encouraging result came from a 2016 field experiment published in Science by David Broockman and Joshua Kalla. Canvassers in the Miami area held conversations of about ten minutes with voters about transgender rights, asking them to recall a time they themselves had been judged for being different. The conversations measurably reduced prejudice towards transgender people, and the effect lasted for months, according to the researchers. The method is known as deep canvassing.

This study replaced an earlier, widely publicised paper on a similar idea that was retracted in 2015 after its data were found to be falsified. Broockman and Kalla, who helped uncover that problem, ran a new and properly documented experiment, and later field studies by the same team have found further effects from non-judgemental, story-based conversations.

Practical takeaways

  • Assume you are not immune. The research suggests everyone has groups they view unfairly; the question is which ones.
  • Notice who you are quick to judge, especially people you see as having chosen their beliefs or lifestyle.
  • Separate disagreement from dislike. You can argue against an idea and still treat its holder with respect.
  • Seek real contact on equal terms: shared projects, teams, travel, volunteering, conversations where you listen to someone’s story.
  • Apply the same standard of evidence to claims about groups you like and groups you don’t.

Intelligence may shape where our biases point, but it does not free anyone from them. Curiosity, humility and genuine contact with people unlike ourselves seem to do more than raw brainpower to make us fairer.

Sources: Live Science: Does IQ determine if you’re prejudiced? It’s complicated (September 2016); Tilburg University: Brandt & Crawford, Answering unresolved questions about the relationship between cognitive ability and prejudice; Contact hypothesis, Wikipedia; Deep canvassing, Wikipedia

COMMENTS