6 ÷ 2(1+2): Is the Answer 9 or 1? The Order of Operations Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
6 ÷ 2(1+2): Why a Viral Equation Splits People Between 9 and 1

The short answer: 6 ÷ 2(1+2) gives 9 if you follow the rule taught in most schools today, where multiplication and division have equal rank and are worked from left to right. It gives 1 if you treat the “2(1+2)” part as a single unit, a convention many mathematicians, physicists and some calculators use. Both readings are defended by people who know their maths, which is why the puzzle keeps going viral. The expression is ambiguous, and the honest fix is to write it more clearly.

Here is how each answer is reached, where the two conventions come from, and why answers like 0, 3 or 6 are simply mistakes.

Working it out step by step

Everyone agrees on the first move: brackets come first, so 1 + 2 becomes 3. That leaves

6 ÷ 2 × 3 or, written the way it appeared, 6 ÷ 2(3)

From here the paths split.

Route to 9: strictly left to right

Multiplication and division share the same level of priority. When they appear side by side, you take them in the order they are written. So 6 ÷ 2 = 3 first, and then 3 × 3 = 9. Most school textbooks in the US, UK and elsewhere teach exactly this, and it is how virtually every programming language reads a typed version such as 6/2*(1+2), where the multiplication sign is explicit.

Route to 1: the bracket term stays together

In ordinary algebra, writing two things next to each other, called multiplication by juxtaposition, often signals that they belong together. Most people would read 1/2x as one over 2x, not as half of x. Apply the same habit here and 2(3) is treated as a single quantity, 6. Then 6 ÷ 6 = 1. Some calculators, including many modern Casio models, give priority to implied multiplication in this way, while Texas Instruments models do not, which is why two phones or calculators in the same room can disagree.

Why the rules disagree

The order of operations is a convention, not a law of nature. It exists so that people reading the same line of symbols reach the same number. The core of it is widely shared: brackets, then powers, then multiplication and division, then addition and subtraction. Mnemonics vary by country, with PEMDAS in the US, BODMAS or BIDMAS in the UK and BEDMAS in Canada.

Where the conventions run out is exactly the corner this puzzle hits. Style guides used by some scientific publishers, such as the Physical Review journals, and well-known textbooks including Concrete Mathematics treat juxtaposition as binding more tightly than a written division sign. School rules, on the other hand, typically make no such exception. Neither is wrong; they are different agreements.

The division sign itself adds to the confusion. The obelus (÷) is rarely used beyond primary school, and the international standard for mathematical notation, ISO 80000-2, advises against it altogether in favour of a slash or a fraction bar. Puzzles like this one combine a symbol that professionals avoid with a layout they would never write.

The YouTube creator Presh Talwalkar, who runs the channel MindYourDecisions, explains in the video below that older textbooks often read such expressions in a way that leads to 1, while modern teaching leads to 9. Watch it and see which reasoning convinces you.

Common mistakes and myths

  • “PEMDAS means multiply before you divide.” It does not. The M and D are a pair of equal rank, as are A and S. Reading the letters strictly in order is the single most common cause of wrong answers in viral puzzles.
  • “The answer is 0, 3 or 6.” These come from slips such as forgetting the 2 outside the brackets (6 ÷ 2 = 3) or dropping the bracket entirely (6 ÷ 2 × 1 + 2 = 5, or similar). They do not follow any accepted convention.
  • “My calculator proves it.” A calculator only shows which convention its designers chose. Simple chain calculators even give 1 + 2 × 3 = 9, which almost everyone agrees is wrong.
  • “Real mathematicians argue about this.” Mostly they do not, because they would never write it this way. A working mathematician would use a fraction bar or extra brackets.

The same fight, a different number

In July 2019 a near-identical puzzle, 8 ÷ 2(2+2), split social media again: 16 by left-to-right order, 1 if 2(2+2) stays together. The Cornell mathematician Steven Strogatz wrote about it in The New York Times. His point was that the convention favouring implied multiplication is common in algebra but not universal, and that what matters most is agreeing on a rule, especially for the people who program calculators and spreadsheets.

Others have called such problems a “gotcha” game: they are built to be misread, not to test understanding. That is a fair description. Spotting the ambiguity is a better mathematical skill than defending one answer.

How to write it so nobody argues

If you mean 9, write (6 ÷ 2)(1 + 2) or 6/2 × (1 + 2). If you mean 1, write 6 ÷ (2(1 + 2)) or put 6 over 2(1 + 2) as a fraction. One extra pair of brackets ends the debate.

The same habit is useful far beyond puzzles. In spreadsheets and code, add brackets whenever there is any doubt about order. They cost nothing, they make your intention obvious to the next person, and they protect you from tools that follow a different convention from the one in your head.

Try these yourself

Using the standard school rule (left to right for × and ÷):

  1. 12 ÷ 3 × 2 = ?
  2. 2 + 3 × 4 − 1 = ?
  3. (2 + 3) × (4 − 1) = ?
  4. 20 − 10 ÷ 5 × 2 = ?

Answers: 8, 13, 15 and 16. If you got all four, you understand the rules perfectly well, whatever you said about 6 ÷ 2(1+2). Struggling with the viral version is not a sign of being bad at maths; it is a sign that the question is badly written.

Which answer did you reach first, and did reading this change your mind? Let us know in the comments.

Sources: Wikipedia: Order of operations; Cornell University, August 2019: The math equation that tried to stump the internet; video explanation by Presh Talwalkar, MindYourDecisions (YouTube).

Related:

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 11
  1. Why is he changing the parenthesis to multiplication ?! It's suppose to be like "of", the "O" of the BODMAS rule. . Which you have to evaluate first ! The number associated to the parenthesis is given precedence !!

    ReplyDelete
  2. There is no "old way" and "new way". There is a right way, and a wrong way. And if you get 9 as the answer, you are doing it the wrong way. You haven't resolved a bracket/parenthesis until you have multiplied ALL the numbers within the bracket with the number outside. So, it would be 6/((2*1)+(2*2))=6/(2+4) =6/6 = 1.
    You can't just change the way the operators work, and claim it to be a "new way" and hence right. Please don't fall for this

    ReplyDelete
  3. The answer is 1.
    Anyone who can prove otherwise please do.
    If you can, then the problem with this equation is that it is not elegant.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is 9. Division and multiplication have the same rank, so the priority is done from left to right, 6/2*3,there is no brackets in 2*3, so it should go 6/2 and then multiply by 3. If you don't believe me, search in Google =6/2(2+1) or put it in a scientific calculator

      Delete
    2. Another way is, we know that dividing by 2 is the same as multiplying by .5, so we have 6*.5*3, and since multiplication is associative you can do it in the order you like it and you will have 9

      Delete
    3. When you write "6/2*3" you already changed the expression in a non valid way. After adding the numbers in the parentheses you should the correct statement is: 6/2(3). You cannot remove the parentheses until you have calculated all factors in front of it.
      The part that reads 2(1+2) is a shortening for ((1+2) + (1+2)). It is just two times what is in the parentheses. So when you want to remove them, you need to get rid of the factor. In algebra that rule is: 2(a+b) = 2a+2b

      Delete
  4. Wait...what? I got 1. Why is it 9...?

    ReplyDelete
  5. The equation is poorly written, leaving no clearly correct answer. The question boils down to grouping symbols. Is the implied multiplication between the 2 and the parentheses also a grouping symbol or not? Algebraically, which is correct, 6÷2x=3x OR 6÷2x=3/x? The former is what the authors are claiming is correct, and gives the result of 9. The latter may be correct, and would give a result of 1.

    ReplyDelete
  6. What happened to PEMDAS. Parentheses, exponents, multiplication, division, addition and subtraction. In that order. The correct answer is 1. Working from left to right is how it was solved 40 years ago when I was in high school .

    ReplyDelete
  7. I was taught arithmetic in the 1950s and 1960s in Scotland, birthplace of many notable mathematician: NB John Napier! Our teachers taught us that the answer is 1. when did the so-called change take place?

    ReplyDelete
  8. Answer is 1. 2 and (1 +2) in 2(1+2) cannot be treated as separate with out solving it.

    ReplyDelete