In April 2017 astronomers announced what looked like the first atmosphere ever found around a rocky, roughly Earth-sized planet beyond our solar system: GJ 1132b, about 41 light-years away in the southern constellation Vela. The short answer to whether that claim held up is no. Follow-up work in 2018 failed to confirm it, and observations with the James Webb Space Telescope analysed in 2025 point to a bare planet with little or no atmosphere at all. The story is still worth knowing, because it shows how hard these measurements are and why astronomers treat early detections with caution.
What was announced in 2017
A team led by John Southworth of Keele University in the UK, publishing in The Astronomical Journal, reported that GJ 1132b appeared slightly larger at one infrared wavelength than at the others. The simplest explanation seemed to be an atmosphere that blocks starlight at that wavelength, making the planet's silhouette look bigger. Their models suggested a thick envelope, possibly rich in water vapour or methane.
Southworth framed it carefully, saying the team had taken "the first tentative step into studying the atmospheres of smaller, Earth-like, planets." He also floated the idea that the hot planet might be a "water world" wrapped in steam. Headlines were less restrained, and many readers came away thinking a potentially habitable twin of Earth had been found. That was never the claim: the planet orbits extremely close to its star and is far too hot for life as we know it.
The planet and its star
GJ 1132b was discovered in 2015 by the MEarth-South project, a set of small robotic telescopes in Chile that watch nearby red dwarfs for planets crossing in front of them. It has about 1.6 times Earth's mass and a diameter only about 13% larger, which points to a rocky composition broadly like our own planet.
Its year lasts just 1.6 Earth days, and it circles its star at about 2.2 million kilometres, far closer than Mercury is to the Sun. Even though the star is a small, dim red dwarf, that proximity makes the planet hot. JWST measured its dayside at roughly 709 kelvin, about 436 °C, hot enough to melt lead. The planet is almost certainly tidally locked, with one side in permanent daylight.
The system has since become more interesting. Radial-velocity measurements in 2018 revealed a second planet, GJ 1132c, of at least 2.6 Earth masses, and there is an unconfirmed hint of a third.
How astronomers try to detect an atmosphere
The method used in 2017 is called transmission spectroscopy. Each time GJ 1132b passes in front of its star, it blocks a tiny fraction of the starlight. The Southworth team used the GROND instrument on the 2.2-metre MPG telescope at ESO's La Silla Observatory to record that dip in seven wavelength bands at once.
If a planet has no air, it blocks the same fraction of light at every wavelength. If it has an atmosphere, gases absorb certain colours more strongly, so the planet looks a little larger in those bands. The difference is minute, often a few parts in ten thousand of the star's brightness, so small errors in calibration, weather or the star itself can mimic or hide a signal.
A second approach measures the planet's heat. When the planet slips behind its star, the drop in infrared light reveals how hot the dayside is. A thick atmosphere would carry heat around to the night side and lower the dayside temperature; a bare rock stays as hot as the starlight makes it.
What later observations found
The claim unravelled in stages.
- 2018: Caroline Diamond-Lowe and colleagues observed several transits with the larger Magellan telescopes in Chile and found no sign of the extended atmosphere reported in 2017.
- 2021: A team led by Mark Swain used Hubble data to suggest a second-generation hazy atmosphere containing hydrogen, methane and hydrogen cyanide. Within months, independent analyses of the same kind of data, by Mugnai and colleagues and later Libby-Roberts and colleagues, found a flat, featureless spectrum.
- 2024: JWST's measurement of the dayside temperature ruled out thick carbon-dioxide atmospheres and dense steam atmospheres, and fitted best with little or no air.
- 2025: K. A. Bennett and colleagues combined four JWST transits observed with the NIRSpec instrument. Three agreed on a featureless spectrum. The odd one out, which had seemed to show water, coincided with more cool starspots on the star, which can imprint water-like features on the measurement.
The current picture, then, is a hot, bare or nearly bare rocky world. A very thin steam layer cannot be fully excluded, but the authors consider it unlikely.
Why red dwarf planets are hard to read
Red dwarfs are the most common stars in the galaxy and frequently host small planets, which is why GJ 1132b drew so much excitement. If rocky worlds around them can keep atmospheres, the number of potentially habitable places in the universe would be enormous.
Two problems stand in the way. First, red dwarfs are often magnetically active, especially when young, blasting nearby planets with flares and ultraviolet light that can strip away gas over time. Second, their surfaces are blotched with cool spots and bright faculae. Because those patches contain molecules such as water, a planet crossing an uneven star can appear to have water in its atmosphere when the signal actually comes from the star. The GJ 1132b story is one of the clearest examples of that trap.
Similar caution applies to other famous nearby worlds of that era, including Proxima b and the seven planets of TRAPPIST-1. For each, early hopes about habitability have been tempered by the realities of living next to an active red dwarf, and early JWST results have reportedly found no evidence of thick atmospheres on the innermost TRAPPIST-1 planets.
What the episode teaches
None of this means the 2017 team did poor work. They reported a tentative result, described its limits and called for follow-up, which is exactly how science is supposed to work. The follow-up did its job. What went wrong was mostly in translation, when "possible atmosphere on a hot rocky planet" became "Earth-like planet with an atmosphere" in popular coverage.
For readers, a few habits help with any exoplanet headline:
- Check the temperature and orbit. "Earth-sized" is not the same as "Earth-like" or "habitable".
- Look for words like "tentative", "hint" or "consistent with", and treat them seriously.
- Wait for independent confirmation, ideally from a different telescope or method.
- Remember that the star can fake a planetary signal.
JWST, which finally launched in December 2021 after years of delays, is now testing exactly the question GJ 1132b raised: can small rocky planets around red dwarfs hold onto air? So far most answers have been no, but the search continues, and each careful null result narrows down where to look.
Sources: Originally reported by ScienceAlert; Keele University press release (2017); Southworth et al., The Astronomical Journal (2017); Gliese 1132 b (Wikipedia); Gliese 1132 (Wikipedia); Universe Today, August 2025.
Related:- TRAPPIST-1: Seven Small Planets, Big Atmosphere Questions
- Kepler’s Three Super-Earths: What the Discovery Really Means
- Inside the Project Apollo Archive’s Remarkable Photos
- NASA’s PubSpace: How to Find Publicly Available Research
- Earth’s “Second Moon”: What 2016 HO3 Really Is
- BioCarbon Engineering’s 2015 Proposal for Drone-Assisted Tree Planting
- NASA just detected oxygen in the Martian atmosphere
- NASA Confirms Evidence That Liquid Water Flows on Today’s Mars
- Hubble’s Andromeda Mosaic: From 2015 to 2.5 Billion Pixels
- Earth’s Magnetic “Portals”: Reconnection Explained
- Russia Doesn’t Believe U.S. Landed On The Moon, Wants International Investigation
- Enceladus’ Hidden Ocean: What Cassini Found Beneath the Ice

have fun getting there
ReplyDelete