Why Orwell’s 1984 Became a Bestseller Again in January 2017

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Why Orwell’s 1984 Became a Bestseller Again in January 2017

In late January 2017 a novel published in 1949 became the best-selling book on Amazon. George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four, a story about a state that rewrites the past and punishes independent thought, suddenly sold faster than any new release, and its publisher rushed out tens of thousands of extra copies.

Why did it happen, what does the book actually warn about, and what can readers take from it without turning it into proof of every theory going? Here is the story behind the spike, and what it says about how people reach for Orwell when trust in public information wobbles.

What happened in January 2017

The sequence is well documented. After the presidential inauguration on 20 January 2017, White House press secretary Sean Spicer insisted the crowd had been far larger than photographs showed. Asked about this on television, adviser Kellyanne Conway defended him by saying he had offered "alternative facts". Commentators immediately called the phrase Orwellian.

By the evening of Tuesday 24 January, 1984 had reached number one on Amazon's best-seller list, and it was still there the next morning (Fortune). Penguin ordered a 75,000-copy reprint, which a spokesman called "substantial" and larger than its typical reprint for the novel. Other political classics climbed too: Sinclair Lewis's It Can't Happen Here and Aldous Huxley's Brave New World both entered Amazon's top 100 (Christian Science Monitor). Major outlets, including The New York Times and CNN, reported the same link between the phrase and the sales.

Two caveats keep the story honest. First, the book always sells well at the start of the spring semester because it is taught in schools, although Penguin said this surge was unusual. Second, nobody can measure exactly how much one remark moved sales; the timing is suggestive rather than proof.

It was not the first Orwell spike

Readers have turned to Orwell before when news touched his themes. In June 2013, after The Guardian and The Washington Post published reports based on Edward Snowden's documents about NSA surveillance, one edition of 1984 rose almost 10,000% in Amazon sales and reached number three on its list of hottest-selling books; its sales rank jumped from 11,855 to 123 (CNN Money).

The pattern is consistent: surveillance revelations send people to Big Brother and the telescreen; disputes about facts send them to the Ministry of Truth. It also crosses borders. In 2014 protesters in Bangkok silently read books about totalitarian societies, including 1984, after a military coup in Thailand.

What 1984 is really about

Orwell wrote the novel in the late 1940s, after watching propaganda, purges and show trials in the 1930s and 1940s. In his 1946 essay "Why I Write" he said that every line of serious work he had written since 1936 had been written, directly or indirectly, "against totalitarianism" and for democratic socialism (Snopes). 1984 is the fullest expression of that warning. Its key ideas still give readers useful vocabulary:

  • The Ministry of Truth constantly rewrites newspapers and records so that the Party has always been right.
  • Doublethink is the ability to hold two contradictory beliefs and accept both.
  • Newspeak shrinks the language so that dissenting thoughts become hard to express at all.
  • Thoughtcrime and the Thought Police punish private doubt, not just public action.
  • Big Brother and the telescreens make surveillance constant and two-way.

The novel's most chilling point is not that the state lies, but that it demands citizens deny the evidence of their own eyes: the Party tells Winston Smith that two plus two makes five, and his final defeat is believing it.

Using Orwell well, and how the comparison gets misused

Orwell is quoted across the political spectrum, and that is part of his value: his warning applies to any government, party or movement. The risk is using "Orwellian" as a label for whatever one already dislikes. Much of the online commentary around the 2017 spike did exactly that, mixing the real sales story with claims that do not hold up:

  • 9/11 was not a "false flag". The US National Institute of Standards and Technology found that the plane impacts severed columns and stripped fireproofing, and the resulting fires weakened the structure. It found no evidence of explosives or controlled demolition (NIST).
  • The "$540 million fake terrorist videos" story is overstated. A 2016 Bureau of Investigative Journalism report said the PR firm Bell Pottinger worked on US information operations in Iraq. Government records show about $279 million in contracts for 2008 to 2011, and the larger figure covered ordinary commercials and news-style items as well as alleged covert work. The Pentagon did not confirm the fake-video claims (Snopes).
  • "Invisible government" quotes need context. The phrase "Behind the ostensible government sits enthroned an invisible government" comes from the Progressive Party platform of August 1912, Theodore Roosevelt's party, and was aimed at the influence of business money on both main parties (Teaching American History). That is a real and recurring debate about lobbying and campaign finance. It is different from the claim that a secret cabal of "international bankers" runs the world, which, often illustrated with octopus imagery, is a long-standing antisemitic myth (ADL).

Mark Twain's line from The Mysterious Stranger about statesmen inventing "cheap lies" to justify war is a fair companion to Orwell: both describe how people come to accept comfortable falsehoods. The lesson cuts every way, including towards conspiracy theories that flatter their own audience.

Practical lessons from the novel

If the 2017 surge sent you back to the book, a few habits translate its warnings into everyday use:

  1. Keep the record. The Ministry of Truth works because no one can check the past. Archived pages, original documents and dated reporting are the antidote.
  2. Watch the words. Euphemisms that make something sound smaller or cleaner than it is ("alternative facts", "collateral damage") deserve a second look, whoever uses them.
  3. Separate facts from interpretation. That a book topped Amazon is a fact; why it did is an interpretation. Both are worth discussing, but they are not the same thing.
  4. Value disagreement. Orwell's nightmare is a society where doubt itself is a crime. A free press, open courts and the ability to say "I think you are wrong" are what stand between ordinary politics and that world.
  5. Read the book itself. It is more subtle, and darker, than the slogans taken from it.

The January 2017 spike was, in the end, a sign of something healthy: when a public argument about truth broke out, many people chose to answer it by reading a serious novel.

Sources: Fortune, 25 January 2017; Christian Science Monitor, 25 January 2017; CNN Money, 12 June 2013; Snopes: Orwell's "Why I Write"; NIST: WTC towers investigation; Snopes, 3 October 2016; Progressive Party Platform, 1912; ADL: the power myth. Original story idea: Collective Evolution.

Related:

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 2
  1. I'm really surprised at Thinking Humanity for posting crap like this. Such political extremism and conspiracy theory BS seems at odds with all your previous posts. Any more like this and I will be 'unliking' this site.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Great. Another person who doesn't see government for who they are, I'm sure you loved waking up in Nov to see the regime controlling everything. You assume life will actually become better. For you. That's sad. Instead of coming across ignorant, why not pick up a copy of 1984 and read it. As for your threats on "unliking" their page, I'm sure you will not be missed if this is the type of attitude you carry.

      Delete