Why We Work 40 Hours a Week: History, Debt and Consumerism

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2017-02-15.

Opinion and analysis: this piece examines a popular argument about work, money and consumerism.

The Forty-Hour Workweek and an Argument About Economic Dependence

The 40-hour week was not invented to trap anyone. It was won by workers. In the nineteenth century factory labourers often worked 10 to 16 hours a day, six days a week, and the eight-hour day became one of the labour movement's central demands. In the United States the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 turned a maximum standard week into federal law, with overtime pay beyond it. Yet many people today feel that same schedule leaves them financially dependent, short of time and spending to compensate. That feeling is the starting point of a widely shared essay, inspired by documentaries such as Zeitgeist: Addendum and Ethos, which describes modern work as "wage slavery" driven by inflation, debt and consumerism.

Some of that argument holds up, and some of it rests on myths about how money works. Below we separate the history, the economics and the parts that are really about choices we can make.

Where the 40-hour week came from

In 1817 the Welsh reformer Robert Owen coined the slogan "Eight hours' labour, eight hours' recreation, eight hours' rest." In the US, labour publications were calling for an eight-hour day as early as 1836, and the demand fuelled strikes and protests for decades, including the 1886 campaign linked to the Haymarket affair in Chicago.

Employers moved slowly. Henry Ford's decision in January 1914 to cut shifts from nine hours to eight while doubling pay to five dollars a day was a landmark, and Ford later adopted a five-day week as well. Internationally, the very first convention adopted by the International Labour Organization in 1919 dealt with hours of work in industry.

The US Fair Labor Standards Act, signed in June 1938 and in force from 24 October that year, set a maximum workweek of 44 hours at first, with the 40-hour standard phased in by 1940, plus a minimum wage of 25 cents an hour. It initially covered industries employing only about a fifth of the workforce. So the 40-hour week was a ceiling meant to protect workers, not a quota designed by banks.

Why has it barely moved since? Economists offer several reasons: rising productivity was often taken as higher pay and consumption rather than more leisure, employer-paid benefits such as health insurance make it cheaper to hire fewer people for longer hours, and many jobs are organised around full-time positions. In recent years, four-day-week trials in several countries have reopened the question.

Inflation: real, but often explained wrongly

The essay claims that a dollar from 1913, the year the Federal Reserve was created, needed about $21 to match its value in 2007. That is roughly right: US consumer prices rose by a factor of about 21 over that period, meaning the dollar lost around 95% of its purchasing power.

The explanation offered, however, does not match how the system works. It describes the government asking the Fed for a loan, the Fed buying newly printed Treasury bonds directly, and the money being "created out of thin air" in that swap. In reality the Federal Reserve buys government securities from banks and dealers in the open market rather than directly from the Treasury, and, as the Bank of England has explained in detail, most money in a modern economy is created when ordinary commercial banks make loans.

Inflation also has more than one cause, including supply shocks such as energy prices, wage and demand pressure, and expectations. Moderate, predictable inflation is a deliberate policy target in most advanced economies (around 2% a year), because falling prices tend to bring their own problems. The real complaint for workers is when wages fail to keep up with prices, which has happened in several periods, and that deserves attention on its own terms.

Debt: does interest make repayment impossible?

A popular claim in Zeitgeist: Addendum is that because money is created as debt, the interest on that debt "does not exist," so someone must always go bankrupt and the nation can never get out of debt. It sounds logical, but it is a misunderstanding.

Interest paid to banks does not vanish. Banks spend it on wages, rent and dividends, and that money circulates back into the economy, where borrowers can earn it again. Repaying a loan does cancel the deposit money that the loan created, but cash, central bank reserves and other money remain. Household and national debt can grow dangerously, but that comes from borrowing and spending decisions, not from an arithmetic trap built into money itself.

Where the essay touches something real is in how debt changes people's choices. Someone with a mortgage, student loans and credit-card balances has far less freedom to work fewer hours, change careers or take a risk. Debt does not enslave anyone, but it can narrow options for years.

Productivity, profits and pay

The essay also points to research suggesting office workers are truly productive for less than three hours a day. That figure comes from a 2016 survey of UK office workers, not a controlled study, so it should be read as an indication of how people perceive their days rather than a measurement.

The broader point is better supported. In the United States, labour productivity grew much faster than typical worker pay from the 1970s onwards, a gap documented by many economists, while corporate profits rose strongly in the 2010s. How to explain that gap (technology, globalisation, weaker unions, measurement choices) is debated, but it helps explain why many people feel they are working as hard as ever without getting ahead.

Consumerism and the habits it built

The essay traces modern consumer culture through a series of turning points, and most of them are historically sound:

  • Buy now, pay later. General Motors created the General Motors Acceptance Corporation in 1919 to finance car purchases on credit, a model soon copied for other goods.
  • Keeping up with the Joneses. The phrase comes from a newspaper comic strip that began in 1913. In the 1920s, General Motors under Alfred Sloan popularised the yearly model change, encouraging buyers to trade up before their old car wore out.
  • Postwar spending. After the Depression and the rationing of the Second World War, pent-up demand and rising incomes fuelled a consumer boom.
  • Charge it. Diners Club launched in 1950 as the first widely used charge card, and bank credit cards followed.
  • Unsolicited cards. In the late 1960s banks mailed millions of credit cards to people who had not asked for them, until Congress banned the practice in 1970.

Marketing aimed at children is another example. In the 2003 documentary The Corporation, marketing executive Lucy Hughes discussed research into "the nag factor," children pestering parents to buy things, and said that consumers can be manipulated into wanting products: "It's a game."

The essay's sharpest insight is about time. When long workdays leave little energy for anything else, people tend to buy convenience and quick pleasure, such as takeaways, streaming subscriptions and impulse purchases, and spend less time on free things like walking, reading, hobbies and friends. Spending then requires income, which requires the hours. Whether you call that a cycle or a trap, many people recognise it in their own lives.

Is "wage slavery" a fair description?

The term has a long history among labour activists and philosophers, who used it to criticise total dependence on an employer. As rhetoric it can make a point, but it is worth being careful with it. Slavery meant people owned as property, without the right to leave, earn or refuse; comparing a salaried job to that can trivialise real slavery, which still affects millions of people today in the form of forced labour.

A more useful way to frame the argument is economic dependence: if losing one paycheck would put you in crisis, your bargaining power over hours, pay and conditions is limited. That is a real problem, and it has practical responses.

Practical ways to regain some freedom

  • Build a buffer. Even a small emergency fund gives you more choice when a job becomes unbearable.
  • Tackle high-interest debt first. Credit-card interest is often the most expensive drain on income.
  • Audit "time-poverty" spending. Notice purchases made because you are tired or short of time, and see which ones a little planning could replace.
  • Ask about flexibility. Part-time, compressed or remote arrangements are more common than they used to be, and in some countries employees have a legal right to request them.
  • Act collectively. Historically, shorter hours came from organised workers and new laws, not individual willpower. Unions, professional bodies and voting still matter.

The 40-hour week was a hard-won protection. Asking whether it still fits modern life is a fair question, and it is best answered with accurate history and economics rather than conspiracy.

Sources: Wikipedia: Eight-hour day; US Department of Labor: FLSA history; Wikipedia: Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938; Bank of England: Money creation in the modern economy; US Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI inflation calculator. The original essay was published by Anon HQ and shared via Collective Evolution, drawing on David Cain's essay.

COMMENTS