The 2017 March for Science: How a Reddit Idea Became a Global Protest

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Scientists Planned a March for Science in 2017

Photo: Marcio Jose Sanchez, as published by The Washington Post.

The March for Science was a worldwide demonstration in support of scientific research and evidence-based policy, held on Saturday 22 April 2017, Earth Day. It began as a suggestion in an online forum in January of that year and within three months had grown into a rally in Washington, DC, and satellite marches in hundreds of cities. Organisers estimated that more than a million people took part worldwide.

In its planning stages in early 2017, the march was often described as a protest against climate change denial. Climate was a big part of it, but the final message was broader: fund research, listen to evidence and let scientists talk openly about their work.

How a Reddit comment became a movement

The idea surfaced in late January 2017 on Reddit, in a discussion about climate change references disappearing from the White House website after the new administration took office. One user suggested that scientists should march on Washington, and others quickly took it up. The Washington Post reported on the growing plan on 24 January 2017.

Jonathan Berman, then a postdoctoral researcher, set up the Facebook page, Twitter account and website that gave the idea a home. The public health researcher and science writer Caroline Weinberg and the anthropologist Valorie Aquino became co-chairs. The organisers drew explicit inspiration from the huge Women's March of 21 January 2017. Within days, hundreds of thousands of people had joined the online groups and volunteers were signing up faster than the team could reply, as the tweets below from those first days show.





Why scientists decided to march

Several things came together in the first weeks of the Trump administration. President Trump had earlier called global warming a hoax, including a 2012 tweet claiming it was invented by China. In January 2017, news reports described a freeze on new grants and contracts at the Environmental Protection Agency and instructions limiting what staff at some federal agencies could say publicly. For many researchers, those moves felt like an attack on the idea that publicly funded science should be shared with the public.

Weinberg summed up the mood in an email to The Washington Post: "We were inspired (well, infuriated) by the current attacks on science from the new administration." Her point was that research paid for by taxpayers should not be silenced or defunded for political reasons.

The underlying science on climate was not in doubt. Major scientific bodies around the world agree that the planet is warming and that human greenhouse gas emissions are the main cause. The marchers' worry was less about scientific disagreement and more about policy ignoring that evidence.

The march on Earth Day 2017

The organisers chose 22 April, Earth Day, for the main event. In Washington, speakers and performers gathered on the National Mall in the rain before marching toward the Capitol. Bill Nye, the television science educator, was one of three honorary co-chairs, alongside the paediatrician Mona Hanna-Attisha, who had exposed lead poisoning in Flint, Michigan, and the molecular biologist Lydia Villa-Komaroff.

Organisers estimated about 100,000 people in Washington, with large crowds in Boston, Chicago, Los Angeles and San Francisco, and satellite events in hundreds of cities on every continent, reportedly including a small group of researchers in Antarctica. Signs ranged from earnest to playful, with slogans about peer review, vaccines, clean air and the periodic table.

The official goals described the event as nonpartisan. It aimed to celebrate science, to call for evidence-based policy, to support public funding for research, and to make science more open and inclusive.

Should scientists march? The debate

Not every scientist liked the idea. In a New York Times opinion piece on 31 January 2017, the coastal geologist Robert S. Young argued that a march would turn science into one more interest group and confirm sceptics' belief that researchers have a political agenda. The physicist Sylvester James Gates raised a similar worry. On the other side, the meteorologist Eric Holthaus and others replied that defending evidence is political but need not be partisan.

Conservative commentators criticised the march for a left-leaning tone, and the physicist William Happer, a climate-change sceptic, dismissed it outright. Inside the movement there were also lively arguments about how much to focus on diversity and inclusion in science.

A University of Delaware survey of more than a thousand members of march Facebook groups found that 97 per cent saw encouraging evidence-based policy as very important, while fewer than half said the same about becoming more involved in politics. In other words, most participants saw themselves as defending a method, not a party.

What happened next

The organisers turned the one-day event into an ongoing organisation. A second March for Science took place on 14 April 2018 with around 230 satellite events, and a third in May 2019 at roughly 150 locations. In July 2018 the group held a summit in Chicago for local organisers, known as the SIGNS Summit.

The crowds were smaller after 2017, as is common for protest movements. Supporters argue the bigger legacy was cultural: many researchers who had never spoken publicly began writing to representatives, visiting schools and explaining their work on social media.

Why it still matters

The March for Science raised a question that has not gone away: how should scientists speak up when policy ignores evidence, without appearing to take sides in party politics? A few lessons from 2017 still apply:

  • Explain the evidence, not just the conclusion. People trust science more when they see how it works.
  • Defend openness. Publicly funded research, data and findings should be available to the public who paid for them.
  • Stay focused on policy, not personalities. The most persuasive message of the march was about evidence-based decisions, whoever is in office.
  • Keep showing up. One day of protest matters less than years of patient public engagement.

Sources: Wikipedia: March for Science, The Washington Post, 24 January 2017, True Activist (original report).

Related:

COMMENTS