What Makes People Attractive? A Brain Study Points to Understanding

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published April 19, 2020.

Research Examined Emotional Understanding and Attraction

Looks matter, especially at first sight, but a German brain-imaging study found a quieter force at work: we tend to become more attracted to people whose feelings we feel we can read. In experiments at the University of Lübeck, the more confident volunteers were that they had correctly understood what someone was feeling, the more they wanted to get closer to that person, and the brain's reward system tracked that shift.

That does not make looks irrelevant, and it is not a recipe for instant chemistry. It does suggest that part of what we call "attraction" is the pleasure of understanding someone, and of being understood. Here is what the researchers actually did, what they found, where the limits are, and what it means for real relationships.

What the Lübeck study did

The study, led by Silke Anders, a professor of social and affective neuroscience at the University of Lübeck, was published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) in 2016 under the title "A neural link between affective understanding and interpersonal attraction."

It had two parts:

  • Experiment 1 was purely behavioural. Forty volunteers (21 women and 19 men) took part.
  • Experiment 2 repeated the task inside an fMRI scanner. Fifty-two people (28 women and 24 men) were included in the analysis.

In both, participants watched short videos of six women, each of whom was genuinely experiencing fear or sadness. After every clip, the viewer said which emotion they thought they had seen and rated how sure they were.

Attraction was measured before and after the videos in two ways. One was a simple behavioural task: participants pressed a button to bring each woman's photo to what felt like a comfortable distance for conversation, a measure of how much they wanted to approach her. The other was a questionnaire asking how much they would like to meet her and how close they could imagine becoming.

What the researchers found

Viewers identified the right emotion in about three out of four trials, and their confidence tended to match their accuracy. The key result was about change: after watching the videos, a viewer's attraction to a particular woman rose when they had felt sure they understood her emotions. This held even after the researchers accounted for how attractive or expressive each woman was in general.

In other words, the effect was personal. The same woman might become more appealing to one viewer and not to another, depending on how well that specific pair "clicked" emotionally.

The brain scans pointed in the same direction. Activity linked to confidence in the ventral striatum and medial orbitofrontal cortex, two core parts of the brain's reward circuitry, predicted how much a viewer's attraction changed. The researchers also compared the brain patterns of viewers watching an emotion with patterns from their own experience of that emotion. Where those matched in the anterior insula, a region involved in feeling emotions, viewers were more confident, although this match did not by itself predict attraction.

Anders summed up the idea in an interview at the time: understanding and attraction "seem to depend on both the sender's brain and the perceiver's brain, and on how well they match." The authors suggest the reward system may signal how well another person's emotional behaviour fits our own internal "vocabulary".

What the study does not show

Headlines at the time claimed psychologists had found "the single most important thing" that makes people attractive. The study is more modest than that:

  • It was about approach, not romance. "Attraction" here meant wanting to get closer to or meet someone, which includes friendship and simple liking.
  • Only women were observed. All six people in the videos were female, and they were seen in fear and sadness only, not joy, anger or flirtation.
  • It was short and artificial. Viewers watched brief clips in a lab, not people they would actually meet.
  • It shows association, not cause. The authors themselves note that the design cannot prove that understanding causes attraction.
  • It did not compare against looks. The study controlled for general attractiveness rather than pitting appearance against understanding, so it cannot say one matters "more" than the other.

How it fits with other research on attraction

The result sits comfortably with a larger body of relationship science. Psychologists studying couples have long described "perceived partner responsiveness": the sense that a partner understands, values and cares for you. It is one of the most consistent predictors of satisfaction and closeness in long-term relationships.

Other well-studied factors include familiarity (we tend to warm to people we see often), similarity in values and attitudes, and, yes, physical attractiveness, which carries a lot of weight in first impressions and speed-dating settings. A reasonable reading of all this is that looks may help open the door, while feeling understood is a big part of what makes people want to stay in the room.

Putting it into practice

If being readable and being understood both draw people closer, a few habits follow naturally:

  • Let your feelings show. People cannot connect with emotions you hide. You do not need to overshare, but a natural, honest expression makes you easier to know.
  • Listen for the feeling, not just the facts. When someone tells you about their day, notice whether they sound worried, proud or tired.
  • Check instead of assuming. A simple "That sounds stressful, is it?" lets the other person confirm or correct you, and either way they feel seen.
  • Do not fake it. Pretending to understand tends to backfire; genuine curiosity works better than clever lines.
  • Remember it works both ways. In the study, the attraction depended on the match between two people. Not clicking with someone is not a personal failure; it may simply be a poor fit.

Common myths about attraction

"There is one secret to being attractive." No single factor explains it. Appearance, personality, similarity, timing and emotional understanding all play a part, and their weight differs from person to person.

"Science has proven looks do not matter." It has not. Studies of first impressions show appearance matters a great deal at the start; what this research adds is that other qualities can change how attractive someone becomes once we get to know them.

"Chemistry is pure mystery." Part of it may be quite ordinary: the reward of understanding someone and sensing that they understand you. That is something people can build through attention and honest conversation.

The picture at the top of this page puts it neatly from the other side: someone can lose their appeal once you learn how they think. The reverse is just as true, and this study offers one small scientific reason why.

Sources: Anders S, de Jong R, Beck C, Haynes J-D, Ethofer T. A neural link between affective understanding and interpersonal attraction. PNAS 113(16), 2016 (DOI); quote as reported by Power of Positivity; topic first covered by Unisoul Theory.

COMMENTS