First published February 1, 2017.

Do children inherit their intelligence from their mother rather than their father? The short answer is no. Intelligence is shaped by thousands of genetic variants spread across all of our chromosomes, inherited from both parents, together with the environment a child grows up in. The popular claim that "intelligence comes from the mother" grew out of a viral 2016 blog post that stretched a few real findings, mostly from mouse experiments and one study that never measured fathers, far beyond what they show.
Below we look at where the idea came from, what each piece of evidence really says, and what parents can actually do to support a child's thinking.
Where the claim came from
In 2016 a post on the website Psychology Spot argued that a child's IQ is inherited mainly from the mother. It was picked up by newspapers and recycled across social media for years, often with headlines such as "sorry, dads". The post rested on three arguments: genes on the X chromosome, a set of experiments with genetically engineered mice, and a large study of young people that found the mother's IQ predicted the child's.
Each of these contains something true. None of them supports the conclusion. Statistician Thomas Lumley and KQED science writer Barry Starr were among those who checked the sources at the time and found them badly misdescribed.
The X chromosome argument
Women have two X chromosomes and men have one X and one Y. A son therefore gets his only X from his mother, while a daughter gets one X from each parent. The claim says many "intelligence genes" sit on the X, so boys in particular must get their brains from their mothers.
There are two problems. First, even if it were true, it would only apply to sons; daughters receive an X from their father too. Second, modern genetic studies have not found that intelligence genes are concentrated on the X. X-linked genes look prominent mainly because a damaging change in one of them often causes a noticeable intellectual disability in boys, who have no second copy to compensate. That makes them easier to discover. It does not mean they explain ordinary differences in intelligence between people.
The viral post also blended in a separate idea, genomic imprinting, in which some genes are switched on or off depending on which parent they came from. Imprinting is real, but it involves a limited set of genes, a few hundred at most in humans, and it does not work by the X chromosome at all.
What the mouse experiments showed
The mouse evidence goes back to experiments in the 1990s. Researchers created chimeric mouse embryos that contained some cells carrying only maternal genes or only paternal genes, then tracked where those cells ended up. Cells with only maternal genes tended to collect in parts of the brain such as the cortex, while cells with only paternal genes contributed more to deeper structures and to body growth. Mice with more maternal-only cells reportedly had larger heads and smaller bodies; the reverse produced bigger bodies and smaller brains.
These were valuable findings about how imprinted genes shape development. But they come from artificially engineered animals, not normal mice, and they say nothing about how much either parent contributes to differences in human reasoning or IQ. The old claim that "no paternal genes" are found in the human cerebral cortex is simply wrong: every cell in your cortex carries a full set of chromosomes from both parents.
The study that never measured fathers
The third argument is usually described as a Scottish study that followed more than 12,000 young people and found that their IQ was best predicted by their mother's. In reality, the data came from the US National Longitudinal Survey of Youth, analysed in a 2006 paper in the BMJ on breastfeeding and intelligence by researchers including Geoff Der of the University of Glasgow's MRC unit. Fewer than half of the 12,686 participants were included in that analysis.
The study did find that the mother's IQ was the strongest single factor among those it examined. But it did not include the father's IQ at all. A factor that was never measured cannot lose a comparison. Der himself told KQED that the post seemed to be describing his breastfeeding study, and that some of the figures attributed to it could not have come from it.
There is also an obvious environmental explanation. In most families studied at the time, mothers did more of the daily childcare, reading, talking and schooling decisions. A link between a mother's IQ and her child's can reflect the home she creates, not only the genes she passes on.
What genetics really says about intelligence
A 2018 review in Nature Reviews Genetics by Robert Plomin and Sophie von Stumm summarises the current picture:
- Intelligence is partly heritable. Twin studies suggest genetic differences account for about half of the variation in intelligence between people, rising from about 20% in infancy to about 60% in adulthood.
- It is extremely polygenic. Thousands of DNA variants are involved, and the largest single one explains less than 0.05% of the variation. There is no "intelligence gene", and certainly no single chromosome that carries it.
- Both parents contribute. Apart from the X and Y, every chromosome pair has one copy from each parent, so on average a child inherits half of these variants from each.
- Environment matters. The shared family environment has a strong influence in childhood, even though its measurable effect fades after adolescence.
Heritability also describes populations, not individuals. It tells us how much of the variation in a group is linked to genetic differences, not how much of your own intelligence came from your mother or your father.
What helps a child's thinking
Whatever the genetics, the useful part for parents is what they can do. Research consistently links children's cognitive development to good nutrition, enough sleep, a language-rich home and responsive, warm care, especially in the first five years. Some practical ideas:
- Read aloud and talk with your child often, asking open questions rather than just giving instructions.
- Offer play that involves building, drawing, music and pretend games.
- Cook, garden or fix things together, explaining what you are doing and why.
- Share family meals and talk about the day, the news or a book.
- Let children try hard things, make mistakes and try again.
- Explore other cultures, places and languages, even close to home.
Fathers, mothers, grandparents and other carers all contribute here. A dad who reads every night matters as much as any gene. If you have concerns about a child's development, talk to a doctor or your child's health visitor or paediatrician.
Sources: KQED: Sorry moms, your kids' intelligence doesn't come just from you; Thomas Lumley, Stats Chat (University of Auckland); Plomin and von Stumm, The new genetics of intelligence, Nature Reviews Genetics (2018); Wikipedia: Genomic imprinting; original viral post via Psychology Spot and I Heart Intelligence.

They were right! All men ARE dumb.
ReplyDeleteWho would have thought.
Interesting. I definitely learnt my mathematical ability from my father. However, I learnt about compassion from my mother. One is examined, the other is not. My father was educated, my mother was not, but both were clever. I am now training to be a physics teacher, which requires both skills equally.
ReplyDelete