
On 31 July 2016, speaking to journalists on his flight home from World Youth Day in Kraków, Pope Francis argued that terrorism grows where people have no hope, and that a global economy which puts "the god of money" at its centre instead of the human person is one of its roots. In the same answer he refused to equate Islam with violence, pointing out that every religion, Catholicism included, has its violent fringe. He did not use the word "capitalism"; headlines that said he called capitalism terrorism were paraphrasing him.
Here is what prompted the remarks, what he actually argued, how they fit into the rest of his papacy, and the main criticisms they drew.
The attack that prompted the question
Five days earlier, on 26 July 2016, two young men stormed a church in Saint-Étienne-du-Rouvray, near Rouen in northern France, during morning Mass. They killed the elderly parish priest, Father Jacques Hamel, and seriously wounded a parishioner before police shot them dead. Both attackers had pledged allegiance to the Islamic State group, which claimed the killing.
The murder of a priest at the altar shocked Europe, which had already suffered a string of attacks that summer, including the lorry attack in Nice on 14 July. On the papal plane, a journalist asked Francis to explain why he avoided describing such attacks as Islamic violence, following his comment a few days before that the world was at war but not a war of religions.
Francis later honoured Hamel as a martyr. He waived the usual five-year waiting period so that the process toward beatification could start, and the diocesan inquiry opened in 2017.
What Pope Francis said
His answer, which lasted several minutes, made three main points.
Religion is not the cause. "I do not think it is right to identify Islam with violence," he said, according to Catholic News Service. He described the Islamic State as a small fundamentalist group that does not represent Muslims as a whole, and said his experience of interfaith dialogue had shown him Muslims who seek peace and encounter.
Every faith has its extremists. To make the point, he turned to his own church. "If I speak of Islamic violence, I also have to speak of Catholic violence," he told reporters, adding that small fundamentalist groups exist in almost every religion. He noted that people can be destroyed by words as well as weapons, a reference to gossip and hatred he often criticised.
Despair feeds terror. Francis argued that terrorism grows when people, especially the young, see no alternative. He asked how many European young people had been left without ideals or work and drifted into drugs, alcohol or recruitment by jihadist groups. The deeper cause, he said, is an economy that serves money rather than people, which he called a basic form of terrorism against all humanity.
A few days earlier, in Kraków, he had made a related argument: the conflicts tearing the Middle East apart were wars over money, resources and power, while religions themselves want peace.
Did he call capitalism terrorism?
Not in those words. The popular headline condensed a longer and more careful argument. Francis criticised an economy centred on profit rather than human dignity, but he did not single out capitalism by name, and he was not saying that economic injustice excuses murder. His claim was about conditions that make young people easier to recruit, not about who is to blame for a specific attack.
That nuance matters, because the quote is often shared as if the pope had declared a whole economic system to be terrorist. Reading the full answer gives a better sense of his view, which combined condemnation of violence with a call to look at its social causes.
A theme running through his papacy
The remarks were consistent with what Francis had said since his election on 13 March 2013. In Evangelii gaudium, the programmatic document he published that November, he warned against an "economy of exclusion" and rejected trickle-down economics. His 2015 encyclical Laudato si' linked environmental damage with the treatment of the poor, and Fratelli tutti in 2020 called for a world built on fraternity and social friendship.
His outreach to Islam followed the same line. In February 2019 he and Ahmed el-Tayeb, the Grand Imam of al-Azhar, signed the Document on Human Fraternity in Abu Dhabi, which condemned the use of religion to justify violence.
Pope Francis died on 21 April 2025 at the Casa Santa Marta in Vatican City, aged 88.
Support and criticism
Supporters saw the comments as a refusal to stigmatise a whole religion at a tense moment, and people who work on preventing radicalisation often note that unemployment, isolation and a lack of purpose can make young people more vulnerable to extremist recruiters.
Critics argued that the pope understated the role of ideology. They pointed out that many people who joined jihadist groups came from comfortable backgrounds, and that the attackers' own statements cited religious motives. Others felt that comparing ordinary criminal violence by Catholics with organised terrorism was not a fair equivalence. Researchers generally agree that radicalisation has no single cause, and that personal grievances, networks, ideology and social conditions all play a part.
Why the remarks still matter
The 2016 answer captured something typical of Francis: a refusal to let fear define a whole community, paired with a demand that rich societies look at the conditions they create. Whether or not you share his economic views, his central warning remains relevant. Treating an entire faith as an enemy plays into extremists' hands, while giving young people work, purpose and belonging takes away some of the ground they recruit from.
Sources: Catholic Sun / Catholic News Service (31 July 2016): It's not right to equate Islam with violence, pope says; Wikipedia: Jacques Hamel; Wikipedia: Pope Francis; Reuters (31 July 2016); The Wall Street Journal (31 July 2016). This topic was first shared here via Collective Evolution.
Related:
COMMENTS