Fukuoka’s 2016 Sinkhole Repair: Why the Timeline Matters

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Fukuoka’s 2016 Sinkhole Repair: Why the Timeline Matters
A giant sinkhole (R), measuring around 30 metres (98 feet) wide and 15 metres deep, which appeared in a five-lane street in the middle of the Japanese city of Fukuoka on November 8, 2016 and of the same section of road (L) after repairs were made on November 15. © JiJi Press / AFP

A massive sinkhole opened in a five-lane street in Fukuoka, Japan, on November 8, 2016. The report describes about two days of intensive repair work, while the road reopened on November 15, roughly a week after the collapse.

The 30-meter (98ft) gaping hole was created on November 8 when excavation on an underground train tunnel in the center of Fukuoka caused the roadway to suddenly collapse.

Nobody was injured when the sinkhole swallowed up heaps of tarmac and pavement. However, the incident did cause major disruption, for which construction company, the Taisei Corporation, and the city mayor both apologized.

However, after some 48 hours of emergency pipe repair and road resurfacing, the affected area was reportedly reopened to traffic at 5 a.m. Tuesday, report Japan’s NHK.


The lightening-quick road recovery comes after Taisei CEO Tamaki Tanaka promised a swift response earlier this week.

The 30-meter wide and 15-meter deep hole left nearby businesses inaccessible, stranded vehicles at a multi-storey car park and caused a series of power outages.


Images from the scene show the fruits of the incredibly swift repair operation, with the road showing no signs of the earlier disaster.

Fukuoka’s 2016 Sinkhole Repair: Why the Timeline Matters
A photo of a giant sinkhole (L) measuring around 30 metres (98 feet) wide and 15 metres deep, which appeared in a five-lane street in the middle of the Japanese city of Fukuoka on November 8, 2016 and of the same section of road (R) after repairs were made on November 15. © Jiji Press / AFP

Source: RT

Forty-eight hours was not the whole closure

The sinkhole opened early on November 8, 2016, near Hakata Station, where work was under way to extend a subway line along a 1.4-kilometre route. Reports differ on how long the filling itself took: some described about two days of intensive work, while CNN reported that crews working around the clock had filled the hole with a mixture of sand and cement by November 12. About 7,000 cubic metres of soil containing cement went into the hole, and traffic restrictions were lifted at 5 a.m. on Tuesday, November 15, one week after the collapse, once utilities had been restored and safety checks completed. The headline’s two-day figure therefore describes the most intensive phase, not the whole time from the appearance of the hole to ordinary traffic returning. Keeping the phases separate makes it possible to appreciate a fast operation without compressing the chronology. The headline's two-day claim should therefore not be read as the entire time from the appearance of the hole to ordinary traffic returning.

The visible surface is only part of the repair

Mayor Soichiro Takashima said the refilled ground was about 30 times stronger than before, and local engineers suspected the area’s largely sandy soil had contributed to the collapse. The weeks that followed showed why a finished-looking surface is not the end of the story. In late November part of the repaired road, about 30 square metres, sank by roughly 7 centimetres; officials closed it overnight for about four hours and reopened it after judging it safe, saying some settling had been expected as the fill compressed. A before-and-after image gives a clear sense of the change at street level, but it cannot show the ground investigation and checks that decide when a road is ready for use. Those questions do not detract from the work shown. They help readers understand why a road that looks finished and a road that has been judged ready for use are related but distinct stages of recovery. The source itself mentions utility disruption, inaccessible businesses and the nearby construction project. A fuller engineering account would explain the ground investigation, the material used to fill the void and the checks required before reopening.

COMMENTS