Originally published 2016-12-19.

Can meditation help people with mental illness? The short, honest answer is that it can help some people with some conditions, especially anxiety, depression and stress, but it is not a cure and it does not replace treatment. Juan Santoyo, a Brown University student whose work drew attention in 2014, was one of many young researchers trying to understand how meditation changes the mind, using brain scans and careful analysis of what meditators say they experience.
This article looks at who Santoyo is, what his research actually found, what a brain area called the posterior cingulate cortex has to do with it, and what the wider evidence says about meditation and mental health.
Who is Juan Santoyo?
Santoyo's family emigrated from Colombia when he was a child, and he grew up in Cambridge and Somerville, Massachusetts. According to a 2014 profile by Brown University, seeing homeless people with untreated mental illness in those neighbourhoods sparked his interest in mental health. At Brown he studied neuroscience together with contemplative studies, an unusual combination that looks at practices such as meditation from both scientific and first-person angles. He meditated regularly himself and led a student mindfulness group.
In April 2014, while still an undergraduate, he and his collaborators presented work at the 12th Annual International Scientific Conference of the Center for Mindfulness at the University of Massachusetts Medical School, one of the main gatherings in the field.
The study: watching the brain while meditating
The research most often linked to Santoyo is a 2013 paper in Frontiers in Human Neuroscience titled "Effortless awareness". It was led by Kathleen Garrison of Yale, with Judson Brewer as senior author, and Santoyo was the second author.
The team worked with ten experienced meditators, who had practised for an average of more than 10,000 hours. While each person lay in an fMRI scanner and meditated, they could see a live graph of activity in their posterior cingulate cortex (PCC). After each short run, they described what their experience had been like.
The researchers then compared these descriptions with the brain data. A clear pattern emerged:
- When meditators reported concentration, simply observing sensations, and a sense of "effortless doing", PCC activity tended to drop.
- When they reported being distracted, interpreting their experience or straining to meditate, PCC activity tended to rise.
Some participants learned to move the graph up or down on purpose within about ten one-minute sessions. In the Brown profile, Santoyo described the value of studying experience and brain signals together, saying the two could be seen "co-determining one another."
Why the posterior cingulate cortex matters
The PCC sits towards the back of the brain along its midline. It is a central hub of the default mode network, a set of regions that becomes active when attention turns inward: daydreaming, remembering, planning and thinking about yourself. It quietens when you focus on a demanding outside task.
This is relevant to mental health because getting stuck in self-focused thought, or rumination, is a feature of depression and anxiety. Studies have found unusual activity in this network in treatment-resistant depression, and reduced PCC metabolism is an early sign of Alzheimer's disease. If meditation helps people notice and step out of these loops, it might explain part of its benefit. That remains a hypothesis rather than a proven mechanism.
Turning inner experience into data
A key part of Santoyo's contribution was methodological. Instead of just asking meditators to rate their experience on a scale, the team used grounded theory, a way of systematically coding people's own words into categories and then turning those categories into testable ideas. In another project described by Brown, Santoyo analysed the journals of students who had been randomly assigned to focus on breathing at the nose or at the belly; two independent coders found that the groups described noticeably different kinds of experience.
His mentor Catherine Kerr summed up the goal as finding "better mechanisms for generating testable hypotheses." In other words, this was early, exploratory science designed to sharpen future questions, not proof that meditation treats illness.
What the study did not show
Some popular articles claimed this work offered strong proof that meditation could vanquish even severe disorders such as schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. That goes far beyond the evidence:
- The study had ten participants, all experienced meditators, and no patients.
- It measured brain activity and self-reports, not symptoms or clinical outcomes.
- The authors themselves noted that meditators' training may shape how they describe their experience, and that a single coder did the first round of analysis.
The scale of the problem these articles pointed to is real. The US National Institute of Mental Health estimates that about 2.8 percent of American adults have bipolar disorder in a given year, and many people with serious mental illness go without treatment. But the answer to that gap is better access to care, with meditation possibly playing a supporting role.
What wider research says about meditation and mental health
The US National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) summarises the evidence like this:
- A 2018 analysis of 142 groups of participants, more than 12,000 people in total, found mindfulness approaches worked better than no treatment for anxiety and depression and roughly as well as established treatments such as cognitive behavioural therapy and antidepressants.
- Other reviews found mixed results, often from small or low-quality studies, and few studies follow people for long.
- Meditation is generally low-risk, but not risk-free. A 2020 review found that about 8 percent of participants reported a negative effect, most often increased anxiety or low mood.
Evidence for psychotic disorders is much thinner, and people with a history of psychosis or severe trauma should only start intensive meditation with guidance from their care team.
If you want to try meditation
Start small: five to ten minutes a day of sitting quietly and paying attention to your breath, gently returning when your mind wanders. Noticing the wandering is the practice, not a failure. Apps, community classes and structured programmes such as mindfulness-based stress reduction can help, and it is worth asking about a teacher's training.
Meditation should sit alongside, not instead of, professional help. If you are struggling with your mental health, talk to a doctor. Santoyo's own experience, as described by Brown, was that regular practice helped him feel more engaged with his studies and better at handling difficult situations, a modest, believable benefit that many practitioners recognise.
Sources: Brown University news profile of Juan Santoyo (2014); Garrison et al., "Effortless awareness", Frontiers in Human Neuroscience (2013); Wikipedia: Posterior cingulate cortex; NCCIH: Meditation and mindfulness, effectiveness and safety; NIMH: Bipolar disorder statistics; featured image via Neuroconscience; story first circulated by The Mind Unleashed.

Thanks to the author for the article! Very pleased!color switch
ReplyDelete