Originally published 2016-11-07.

On 27 October 2016, the United Nations General Assembly's First Committee, which deals with disarmament and international security, voted to begin negotiations in 2017 on a treaty banning nuclear weapons. The resolution passed with 123 votes in favour, 38 against and 16 abstentions. It led directly to the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW), adopted in July 2017 and in force since January 2021.
The vote was a turning point for the campaign to outlaw nuclear arms, but it did not ban anything by itself. It opened talks. Understanding the difference between a mandate to negotiate, a treaty text, signature, ratification and entry into force helps explain both why the 2016 vote mattered and why nuclear weapons still exist.
What the committee actually voted for
The resolution, numbered L.41, was put forward by Austria, Brazil, Ireland, Mexico, Nigeria and South Africa, a group of states that had led a series of conferences on the humanitarian consequences of nuclear weapons. It called for a UN conference in 2017 to negotiate "a legally binding instrument to prohibit nuclear weapons, leading towards their total elimination."
A committee vote is only a recommendation. The full General Assembly confirmed the mandate on 23 December 2016 as resolution 71/258, by 113 votes to 35 with 13 abstentions. Negotiating sessions were then held in New York from 27 to 31 March and from 15 June to 7 July 2017.

The UN General Assembly Hall in New York, where the full Assembly confirmed the negotiating mandate in December 2016 and where the treaty talks took place in 2017.
Who voted for and against
Most of the support came from Africa, Latin America and the Caribbean, South-East Asia and the Pacific, with several European states such as Austria and Ireland among the leaders. The opposition was concentrated among nuclear-armed states and their allies.
- Nuclear powers: the United States, Russia, the United Kingdom, France and Israel voted against. China, India and Pakistan abstained.
- North Korea was the only nuclear-armed state to vote yes in the committee, a choice that surprised many observers. It did not take part in the 2017 negotiations.
- Japan, the only country to have suffered nuclear attack, voted against. Tokyo relies on the US "nuclear umbrella" for its security and argued that a ban without the nuclear powers would deepen divisions. Many survivors of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, the hibakusha, strongly criticised that decision.
- NATO members voted no, except the Netherlands, which abstained after its parliament asked the government to take part in talks.
The United States had urged allies to vote against, arguing that a ban would undermine deterrence and the existing Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT). Supporters replied that the NPT's promise of disarmament, made in 1968, remained unfulfilled.
Why campaigners called it historic
Biological weapons, chemical weapons, anti-personnel landmines and cluster munitions had all been banned by international treaties. Nuclear weapons, the most destructive of all, had not. Campaigners argued that a clear legal prohibition would stigmatise them in the same way, even if the states that possess them refused to join at first.
Beatrice Fihn, then executive director of the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons (ICAN), called the vote a "historic moment" and said the treaty would not remove nuclear weapons overnight but would set a powerful new legal standard. Kate Hudson, general secretary of the UK's Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament, made the same comparison with earlier bans on other inhumane weapons.
On the same day, the European Parliament adopted its own resolution backing the negotiations, by 415 votes to 124 with 74 abstentions. It was non-binding, but it showed that support extended well beyond the countries that had drafted the UN text.

Campaigners march in New York behind a "No Nukes" banner. Civil-society groups, including survivors of the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombings, played a central role in pushing for a ban treaty.
The treaty that followed
On 7 July 2017, the negotiating conference adopted the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons by 122 votes to one. The Netherlands, the only NATO member to take part, voted against, and Singapore abstained. The treaty bans developing, testing, producing, possessing, stockpiling, using or threatening to use nuclear weapons, and allowing them to be stationed on a member's territory. It also commits parties to help victims of nuclear use and testing and to clean up contaminated land.
The treaty opened for signature on 20 September 2017. In October that year ICAN was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for its work to draw attention to the humanitarian consequences of nuclear weapons and to achieve a treaty-based prohibition. The TPNW entered into force on 22 January 2021, 90 days after the 50th ratification. By September 2025 it had 95 signatories and 74 states parties, and three meetings of states parties had been held, in Vienna in 2022 and in New York in 2023 and 2025.
What the ban can and cannot do
No nuclear-armed state has joined. After the treaty was adopted, the United States, the United Kingdom and France said they did not intend ever to become party to it, and Russia has also opposed it. A treaty binds only the states that ratify it, so it does not legally oblige the nine nuclear-armed countries to disarm.
Supporters see its value elsewhere. It makes nuclear weapons illegal for a large group of states, gives campaigners a legal standard to point to, and has encouraged some banks and pension funds to stop financing companies involved in nuclear arms. Critics, including most NATO governments, say it ignores security realities and could weaken the NPT. Both treaties continue to exist side by side.

An artist's illustration of a nuclear explosion over a city. The TPNW was built on evidence about the humanitarian effects of such an attack, from blast and fire to radiation and long-term illness.
Fission, fusion and a common myth
People sometimes say that nuclear fission is the destructive kind of nuclear energy and fusion the harmless kind. That is a myth. Fission splits heavy nuclei such as uranium or plutonium into lighter ones; fusion joins light nuclei such as hydrogen isotopes into heavier ones. Both release enormous energy, and both have peaceful and military uses.
The bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in 1945 used fission. Thermonuclear weapons, or hydrogen bombs, use a fission stage to trigger fusion and get much of their energy from it; they are far more powerful, and they make up much of today's arsenals. Fission, meanwhile, powers civilian nuclear reactors around the world.

The Sun, seen here in ultraviolet light, shines because of fusion in its core, where hydrogen nuclei fuse into helium.
Fusion power for electricity remains experimental. Research projects such as the international ITER reactor in France aim to show that controlled fusion can produce more energy than it consumes on a practical scale. If it succeeds, fusion could provide large amounts of low-carbon electricity, but it would not be "free energy": reactors are costly to build and run.
Why the 2016 vote still matters
The October 2016 vote showed that most of the world's governments were ready to declare nuclear weapons illegal, even without the states that own them. The treaty it produced has not removed a single warhead by itself, but it has changed the conversation, giving the non-nuclear majority a legal instrument and a regular forum. Whether that pressure eventually reshapes the policies of nuclear powers is one of the big open questions of international security.
Sources: Wikipedia: Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons; AFP via Yahoo News: UN votes to launch talks on nuclear weapons ban (2016); Wikipedia: Thermonuclear weapon; Wikipedia: Fusion power; Duke Energy: Fission vs. fusion; earlier coverage by The Mind Unleashed.

COMMENTS