France's Right to Disconnect: What the Law Really Requires

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published November 8, 2016.

France's Right to Disconnect: What the 2017 Law Requires of Employers
Wall Street Journal

France does not make it illegal for a boss to email staff after hours. What it does, since 1 January 2017, is oblige larger employers to agree on how their people can switch off. Firms with 50 or more employees must cover the "right to disconnect" in their yearly negotiations with staff representatives, and if no deal is reached, management has to publish a charter that spells out the rules.

That is less dramatic than the viral headlines of 2016 suggested, but it was still a first: a major economy putting into its labour code the idea that rest time should be protected from phones, inboxes and messaging apps. Here is what the law says, where it came from, what it leaves open and what other countries have done since.

What the law actually says

The right was added by article 55 of the so-called El Khomri law (Law No. 2016-1088 of 8 August 2016), named after the labour minister who carried it, Myriam El Khomri. The provision came into force on 1 January 2017 and sits in the French Labour Code alongside the annual negotiation on equality and quality of working life.

In practice it works in three layers:

  • Negotiate first. In companies with 50 or more staff, the employer must put the right to disconnect on the table in the annual bargaining round with unions or staff representatives.
  • Charter as a fallback. Where talks end without agreement, the employer draws up a charter after consulting staff representatives. It sets out how the right is exercised and usually includes training and awareness for managers and employees on sensible use of digital tools.
  • Room for each workplace. The law deliberately does not fix hours. A hospital, a software firm and a logistics company can each decide what "off" means for them, such as no emails after 8 p.m., no messages at weekends, or automatic replies during holidays.

Smaller businesses are not bound by the negotiation duty. Their employees still have the general protections of French law: maximum working hours, minimum daily and weekly rest, and paid holidays.

Is there a penalty?

This is where early coverage often went wrong. The law itself does not fine a company for sending an email at 10 p.m., and it does not define precisely what disconnection must look like. An employer can be prosecuted, though, for refusing to open the mandatory negotiation at all. That counts as obstructing employee representation, an offence that French law punishes with up to one year in prison and a fine of €3,750.

The new text also built on older case law. As early as 2001, France's highest court ruled that an employee was not obliged to take work files and tools home. In 2004 it added that a worker could not be faulted simply for being unreachable on a mobile phone outside working hours. The 2016 reform turned that line of court decisions into a structured obligation for bigger employers.

Why France acted

The debate grew out of reports on workplace stress and burnout, a word that entered everyday French conversation in the 2010s. Smartphones had made it possible to answer a client at dinner or a manager on a Sunday, and many workers felt that being able to answer had quietly become an expectation to answer.

Benoît Hamon, a Socialist member of parliament and former minister, gave the argument its most quoted line. Speaking about constant stress in an NPR report, he said: "Employees physically leave the office, but they do not leave their work." He went on to compare round-the-clock messaging to an electronic leash.

Supporters saw the measure as health policy as much as labour policy: rest is when the body and mind recover, and the boundaries of rest had become blurry. Critics, including some employers, worried that rigid rules would hurt firms working across time zones, and that staff who prefer flexible hours might lose out. The way the law was written, as a duty to negotiate rather than a blanket ban, was partly an answer to those concerns.

The provision arrived inside a larger and highly contested reform. The El Khomri law loosened rules on working time and redundancies and sparked months of strikes and street protests in 2016. The disconnection clause was one of its least controversial parts.

France's leave rules in context

Stories about the law often added that French workers enjoy generous time off, sometimes with exaggerations. The official figures are these:

  • Paid holidays: employees earn 2.5 working days of paid leave for each month worked, which adds up to 30 working days, or five weeks, a year.
  • Maternity leave: 16 weeks for a first or second child, six before the birth and ten after. It is not automatically on full salary. Social security pays a daily allowance with a cap, which stood at €104.02 a day in 2026, unless a collective agreement tops it up.

So "30 days off and 16 weeks of fully paid family leave" was close on holidays and misleading on pay.

How other countries followed

France's example spread, usually in a softer or adapted form:

  • Italy wrote a right to disconnect into its 2017 rules on "agile" (remote and flexible) work.
  • Slovakia added a right to stay away from work equipment during rest periods in March 2021.
  • Ontario, Canada has required employers with 25 or more staff to have a written disconnecting-from-work policy since its 2021 Working for Workers Act, without dictating its content.
  • Australia passed a right for employees to ignore unreasonable after-hours contact in February 2024, with disputes going to the Fair Work Commission.
  • Slovenia introduced a similar right to be unavailable during rest and leave in November 2024.

Some large companies moved before any law. Volkswagen stopped forwarding server emails to some employees' phones in the evening in 2011, and Daimler let staff have holiday emails deleted automatically from 2014.

What workers and managers can take from it

Even outside France, the ideas behind the law are practical:

  • Write the expectations down. Most after-hours stress comes from uncertainty. A short team rule such as "evening messages can wait until morning unless marked urgent" removes the guesswork.
  • Use delayed sending. Managers who like working late can schedule emails to arrive at 8 a.m. The work gets done without pulling anyone else online.
  • Define a real emergency. Agree in advance what justifies a phone call at night, and who is on call. Everyone else can then switch off with a clear conscience.
  • Protect holidays. Out-of-office replies that name a colleague to contact, and mailbox pauses during leave, make time off actually restful.

If constant work contact is affecting your sleep or health, talk to a doctor, and raise it with HR or staff representatives where you can. For a different approach to the same problem, read about what Microsoft Japan's four-day-week trial measured in 2019.

Sources: Wikipedia: Right to disconnect; Benton Institute, reposting NPR: French law giving workers "the right to disconnect" goes into effect (January 2017); Service-Public.fr: Paid leave in the private sector; Service-Public.fr: Maternity leave of a private-sector employee. Story first reported by True Activist.

COMMENTS