First published October 30, 2016.

Does spending time around nature make people kinder? A set of experiments from the University of California, Berkeley suggests that it is not just nature but beautiful nature that nudges people towards generosity, trust and helping. In four studies published in 2014, people who looked at more beautiful natural scenes, or sat near more attractive plants, behaved somewhat more generously than people exposed to less striking nature.
The findings are interesting and fit a wider body of research on the benefits of green space. They do not prove that a walk in the park turns anyone into a better person, and it helps to know exactly what was tested.
The study in brief
The paper, "An occasion for unselfing: Beautiful nature leads to prosociality", appeared in the Journal of Environmental Psychology (volume 37, pages 61–72). Its authors were Jia Wei Zhang, Paul Piff, Ravi Iyer, Spassena Koleva and Dacher Keltner, the Berkeley psychologist known for his work on awe and positive emotions.
"Prosocial" is the researchers' term for behaviour that benefits others: sharing, trusting, helping and cooperating. The team asked whether the beauty of a natural setting, not merely its presence, makes such behaviour more likely.
How the four experiments worked
Study 1: noticing natural beauty
Around 850 American volunteers filled in questionnaires online. Those who said they more readily noticed and were moved by natural beauty also scored higher on agreeableness, empathy and the habit of seeing things from another person's perspective. This was a correlation, so it cannot show which came first.
Study 2: beautiful images and generosity
Some 128 online participants watched a one-minute slideshow of ten nature photos. Half saw images that independent raters had judged especially beautiful; the rest saw less beautiful nature scenes. Afterwards they played the Dictator Game, splitting ten points between themselves and an anonymous partner. People who had viewed the more beautiful scenes gave away more.
Study 3: beautiful images and trust
A further 112 participants saw a similar slideshow and then played the Trust Game. Any points they passed to a partner were tripled, and the partner could choose whether to send some back. Sending more is a measure of trust. Again, the "beautiful nature" group handed over more points.
Study 4: plants in the room and helping
Forty-five university students completed a mood questionnaire at a table with either more or less attractive plants. Afterwards they were invited to fold paper cranes for people affected by the earthquake in Japan. Students sitting near the more beautiful plants folded significantly more cranes.
Why beauty might make people more generous
In the image studies, the more beautiful scenes also produced more positive emotions, and those emotions were linked with greater generosity and trust. The authors suggest that beautiful nature may draw attention away from the self, an experience the novelist and philosopher Iris Murdoch called "unselfing", which is where the paper's title comes from.
The effects were strongest for people who are naturally sensitive to natural beauty. In other words, someone who barely notices a sunset may get less out of it than someone who stops to look.
This fits with Keltner's broader research on awe, the feeling of being in the presence of something vast that shifts your sense of scale. Awe and admiration of beauty both seem to make personal concerns feel a little smaller and other people a little more important.
What the research does not show
- Small and specific samples. Studies 2 to 4 involved a few dozen to around a hundred people each, drawn from an online work platform and one university.
- Laboratory tasks. Points in an economic game and paper cranes are useful measures, but they are not the same as real-world kindness over months or years.
- Short-term effects. The studies measured behaviour minutes after exposure, not lasting changes in character.
- Beauty is mixed up with features. The more beautiful images tended to have more water, open space and colour variety, so it is hard to say exactly what drove the effect.
- Did people notice the plants? In Study 4, the researchers did not check whether students actually looked at them.
Early coverage claimed that Berkeley had "proven" that nature makes people more trusting and selfless. That overstates it. These are promising findings that need larger, longer and more varied studies.
Common myths about nature and kindness
"Any green space automatically makes you nicer"
The study's point was that beauty mattered more than simply being green. A scruffy verge may not have the same effect as a lake view.
"People without access to nature are less generous"
Nothing in this research supports judging individuals or neighbourhoods that way. Access to green space is unequal, and generosity has many sources.
"You need a wilderness trip to benefit"
Study 4 used potted plants. Even modest touches of natural beauty in everyday spaces were enough to produce a measurable difference in that experiment.
Bringing beautiful nature into everyday life
- Notice, don't just pass through. Since the effect was stronger for people who pay attention to natural beauty, pausing to look at trees, birds or the sky may matter as much as being outside.
- Choose the scenic route. A walk past water or mature trees is a small daily upgrade.
- Add plants to shared spaces. Offices, classrooms and waiting rooms can all benefit from well-kept greenery.
- Use images when you can't get outside. Even pictures of beautiful landscapes shifted behaviour in the lab.
- Look after local green spaces. Parks and street trees benefit everyone who passes by.
The takeaway is gentle rather than dramatic: taking a moment to appreciate something beautiful in the natural world may lift your mood and make you a little more open-handed towards others.
Sources: Zhang, Piff, Iyer, Koleva & Keltner (2014), An occasion for unselfing: Beautiful nature leads to prosociality (abstract); Journal of Environmental Psychology 37:61–72; NAAEE eePRO research summary; original story via Higher Perspectives.

COMMENTS