Did a Pesticide, Not Zika, Cause Brazil's Microcephaly Cases?

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Zika, Pesticides And Birth Defects: The 2016 Claim And What Science Found
A boy in north-eastern Brazil holds his baby brother, born with microcephaly during the 2015–16 outbreak. Photo credited in our original post to the New York Times.

Did a mosquito larvicide in Brazil's drinking water cause the wave of babies born with small heads in 2015 and 2016, rather than the Zika virus? No. The idea spread fast in early 2016, and this site repeated it at the time, but the evidence that followed pointed firmly the other way. In April 2016 scientists at the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention concluded that Zika infection during pregnancy causes microcephaly and other serious brain defects, and Brazil's own health authorities found no link with the larvicide, pyriproxyfen.

Below is how the pesticide theory began, why some early numbers seemed to support it, what pyriproxyfen actually is, and how researchers established the role of Zika.

Where the pesticide theory came from

In late 2015 doctors in north-eastern Brazil, especially in the state of Pernambuco, noticed far more newborns with microcephaly than usual. More than 3,500 suspected cases were reported between October 2015 and January 2016. Zika, a mosquito-borne virus new to the Americas, had been spreading in the same region since early 2015, and attention quickly turned to it. The New York Times reported the alarm on the last day of 2015.

On 3 February 2016 an Argentine group of physicians, Médicos de Pueblos Fumigados (Physicians in Crop-Sprayed Towns), published a report proposing another culprit. Since 2014 Brazil had been adding pyriproxyfen to some water supplies to stop Aedes mosquito larvae from maturing. The group argued that the timing and the region matched the rise in birth defects. A Brazilian public health association, Abrasco, issued a statement critical of chemical mosquito control, which many readers took as support for the theory.

The story then gained a corporate angle. Pyriproxyfen sold to Brazil under the brand name SumiLarv is made by Sumitomo Chemical, a Japanese company that had a business partnership with Monsanto. Shared by celebrities and activist sites, including the one this article was first taken from, the claim reached millions of people within days.

What the authorities and experts said

The response was quick. On 13 February 2016 Brazil's Ministry of Health said there were no epidemiological studies showing any association between pyriproxyfen and microcephaly. It pointed out that some places with microcephaly cases had never used the larvicide, and that the Zika link rested on finding the virus in babies' blood, tissue and amniotic fluid.

Pernambuco's own health department made the same point in sharper terms. Recife, the city with the most reported cases, did not use pyriproxyfen in its water at all. That lack of overlap is hard to square with a chemical cause.

Several other facts weakened the theory:

  • The Argentine group's coordinator acknowledged that it had done no laboratory or epidemiological research of its own.
  • Abrasco later said its statement had been misread and that it had never claimed pesticides cause microcephaly.
  • Monsanto does not make or sell pyriproxyfen and does not own Sumitomo Chemical; the two were partners, nothing more.
  • Toxicologists noted that pyriproxyfen had been used for years elsewhere, including in farming and in pet products in the United States, without any similar cluster of birth defects.

One Brazilian state, Rio Grande do Sul, suspended the larvicide as a precaution, but the national health minister dismissed the claim as a rumour without basis.

Why the early numbers looked shaky

Our original piece leaned on statistics that did look odd in early 2016. They are worth revisiting, because each has an explanation.

Only two cases in the first study. One of the first papers, by A. S. Oliveira Melo and colleagues, described Zika in the amniotic fluid of two pregnancies. That was an early case report, not the whole evidence base. Over the following months many more studies found the virus in fetal brain tissue, placentas and the spinal fluid of affected babies.

Few confirmed infections among microcephaly cases. The New York Times reported in February 2016 that only 17 of 404 confirmed microcephaly cases had tested positive for Zika. Zika stays in the blood for only a short time, and reliable antibody tests were scarce in 2015, so most mothers infected months earlier could no longer be confirmed. Brazil was also over-reporting at first, counting many babies who were simply small.

Colombia's low numbers. In mid-2016 Colombia had diagnosed Zika in thousands of pregnant women but reported few affected babies. The risk is concentrated in infections early in pregnancy, and many of those women were infected later or had not yet given birth. Colombia reported its first Zika-linked microcephaly cases in April 2016, and more followed.

Symptoms that look like pesticide poisoning. Rash, red eyes, headache and joint pain are common to many illnesses, including dengue and chikungunya. Overlapping symptoms say nothing about cause.

What pyriproxyfen is and how toxic it is

Pyriproxyfen is an insect growth regulator. It mimics a hormone that insects need to control their development, so larvae fail to become adults. Mammals do not use that hormone system, which is one reason toxicologists considered a link with human birth defects implausible.

The chemical passed the World Health Organization's pesticide evaluation scheme for use in drinking water, and the US Environmental Protection Agency has registered it since 2001. In the US it is best known in flea treatments for pets, sometimes sold as Nylar. Its acute toxicity to people is low. At very high doses in animal tests it affected the liver and could cause mild anaemia, and it is harmful to aquatic insects and some other water life, which is a fair environmental concern. Animal studies did not show the kind of brain defects seen in Brazil, even at doses far above anything a person drinking treated water could receive. The body absorbs little of it and breaks it down quickly.

How scientists showed that Zika causes microcephaly

On 13 April 2016 CDC scientists published a review in the New England Journal of Medicine. They weighed the accumulating studies against established criteria for judging whether an infection causes birth defects, and concluded that it does. No single paper settled it; the pattern did. The virus was found in the brains of affected fetuses, the defects matched the timing of infection, and the outbreak in French Polynesia in 2013–14 showed a similar rise once researchers went back and looked.

CDC director Tom Frieden called the finding a turning point, saying: "It is now clear that the virus causes microcephaly." The World Health Organization had declared Zika a public health emergency of international concern on 1 February 2016 and ended that emergency in November 2016, while stressing that the virus remained a long-term problem.

Congenital Zika syndrome today

Zika, Pesticides And Birth Defects: The 2016 Claim And What Science Found
Microcephaly means a baby's head is much smaller than expected for its age, usually because the brain has not developed normally.

Microcephaly turned out to be only the most visible part of a wider pattern, now called congenital Zika syndrome. Affected children can also have scarring at the back of the eye, stiff joints, seizures, hearing and vision problems, feeding difficulties and delayed development. Not every infection in pregnancy harms the baby. One model based on French Polynesia estimated the risk of microcephaly after first-trimester infection at about 1%, while a study in Rio de Janeiro found broader problems in a much larger share of babies whose mothers were infected. The risk is real, uneven, and highest early in pregnancy.

Zika, Pesticides And Birth Defects: The 2016 Claim And What Science Found
Common Zika symptoms: fever, rash, headache, red eyes and joint or muscle pain. Many people have no symptoms at all.

Most adults who catch Zika have mild symptoms or none. For anyone pregnant or planning a pregnancy who has travelled to, or lives in, an area with Zika, the sensible step is to talk to a doctor about testing and protection from mosquito bites.

What this episode teaches about health scares

The pesticide theory was attractive because it fit a familiar story: a powerful chemical company, a government programme, and early data that seemed thin. Distrust of agrochemicals is not unreasonable in itself, and the environmental effects of pesticides deserve scrutiny. But a good explanation has to fit all the evidence, including the city that never used the chemical and the virus found in babies' brains.

A few habits help with the next scare:

  • Check whether the people making a claim have collected any data of their own.
  • Look for evidence that would contradict the claim, such as cases where the suspected cause was absent.
  • Treat early statistics in a new outbreak as provisional; testing and reporting take months to settle.
  • Follow up. Many viral stories from 2016 were answered within weeks, but the answers spread far less widely.

Sources: CDC: Zika virus causes microcephaly (13 April 2016); Rasmussen et al., New England Journal of Medicine; Snopes: Zika, microcephaly and pesticides; Wikipedia: Pyriproxyfen; Wikipedia: Zika fever; Wikipedia: 2015–16 Zika virus epidemic; original 2016 article: True Activist.

COMMENTS