Originally published 2016-10-03.

Blaise Pascal (1623–1662), mathematician, physicist and philosopher. Portrait via Wikimedia Commons.
Blaise Pascal's advice for changing someone's mind fits in two sentences. First, find the angle from which the other person is looking at the question, admit what is true from that angle, and only then show what it misses. Second, let them reach the counter-argument themselves, because people trust conclusions they discover more than conclusions handed to them. Pascal wrote this in the 1650s, and modern psychology, from motivational interviewing to research on how corrections land, broadly supports both halves.
Below is what Pascal actually said, where it comes from, why it works, where it has limits, and how to use it in a real disagreement without turning it into a manipulation trick.
Who Pascal was and where the advice comes from
Pascal was born in Clermont-Ferrand in 1623 and died in Paris in 1662, aged 39. In that short life he built one of the first mechanical calculators (the Pascaline, at 19), carried out influential experiments on air pressure and the vacuum, and in letters with Pierre de Fermat helped lay the foundations of probability theory. The SI unit of pressure carries his name.
The persuasion advice comes from the Pensées ("Thoughts"), a collection of notes Pascal was gathering for a defence of Christianity that he never finished. Friends and family published the fragments in 1670, eight years after his death. Because the order was never settled, different editions number the fragments differently, which is why quotations from the book often appear without a fragment number. The Pensées is also the source of Pascal's Wager, the famous argument that betting on God's existence is the rational choice under uncertainty.
The passage resurfaced for modern readers through Maria Popova's 2015 essay on Brain Pickings (now The Marginalian), and a year later Quartz framed it as a philosopher's trick that psychologists had confirmed.
Pascal's two rules, in plain words
1. Acknowledge the true side first
Pascal's starting point is that people rarely hold a view that is wrong from every direction. They usually look at a matter from one side, and from that side their view is accurate. If you begin by conceding that accuracy, you change the nature of the conversation. The other person is no longer being told they were mistaken; they are being shown that they had not yet seen the whole picture. Pascal's observation was that no one is offended at not seeing everything
, while almost everyone resists being told they are simply wrong.
2. Let them find the reason themselves
His second note is even shorter. In a widely quoted English translation it reads: People are generally better persuaded by the reasons which they have themselves discovered than by those which have come into the mind of others.
A conclusion you reach yourself feels like your own property. A conclusion someone else gives you can feel like a defeat.
What psychologists say about why it works
Pascal was not running experiments, but several lines of later research point in the same direction.
- Lowering defences. Quartz quoted Arthur Markman, a psychology professor at the University of Texas at Austin, who argued that opening with what someone gets right reduces the urge to dig in, and gives them a reason to cooperate rather than fight. When a person feels attacked, the conversation becomes about protecting their position and their pride.
- Ownership of ideas. Markman also pointed out that accepting another person's idea means implicitly treating them as the authority, which many people dislike. Reaching the same idea yourself avoids that cost.
- Motivational interviewing. Clinical psychologists William Miller and Stephen Rollnick developed this counselling method in the 1980s and 1990s, first with problem drinkers. Its central rule is that the counsellor avoids arguing for change and instead draws out the person's own reasons, called "change talk". It has been tested in more than 200 randomised trials, with positive though not uniform results.
- Self-persuasion. Social psychologists have long reported that arguments people generate for themselves tend to stick better than arguments presented to them, an idea closely tied to Pascal's second rule.
A popular myth: the backfire effect
Around the same time Pascal's advice was going viral, another idea was spreading: that correcting people makes them believe false claims even more strongly, the so-called backfire effect. It is often used to argue that there is no point in disagreeing at all.
The evidence has not held up well. Large replication efforts since the original studies have mostly failed to find the effect, and a 2020 review described backfire effects as very rare in practice. Brendan Nyhan, one of the researchers whose early work popularised the idea, has since written that persistent misinformation is better explained by other factors. In short, corrections usually move people a little in the right direction. Pascal's method is about making that movement easier, not about avoiding a mythical explosion.
How to use Pascal's method in a real conversation
- Listen until you can state their view fairly. If you cannot summarise it in a way they would accept, you are not ready to disagree.
- Name the part that is genuinely right. Be specific: "You're right that the new schedule saves time for the morning team." Vague praise sounds like a set-up.
- Point to the side they have not looked at. Frame it as an addition, not a demolition: "What it doesn't account for is the evening shift."
- Ask rather than tell. Questions such as "What do you think happens to people who start at 6?" invite them to find the gap themselves.
- Leave room to save face. Changing a view takes time. People often update their position days later, when nobody is watching.
It also helps to accept that the method works both ways. If you take Pascal seriously, you must be ready to discover that the side you were looking at was the incomplete one.
Limits and fair warnings
Pascal's approach is a way of communicating, not a guarantee. Some disagreements are about values rather than facts, and no amount of acknowledgement will make them disappear. Some claims, such as false statements about public health or history, have no "true side" worth conceding beyond the concern behind them. In those cases the honest move is to acknowledge the worry, not the falsehood.
There is also a line between persuasion and manipulation. Acknowledging someone's point only as a tactic, without meaning it, tends to be noticed and erodes trust. The method works best when it is sincere: you really look for what the other person sees, and you really let them think.
Pascal is remembered as a mathematician, physicist and religious thinker. This short passage suggests he also understood something lasting about human pride: we do not mind learning more, but we hate being told we were wrong.
Sources: Maria Popova, The Marginalian (formerly Brain Pickings): Blaise Pascal on the art of persuasion; Olivia Goldhill, Quartz (2016); Wikipedia: Blaise Pascal; Wikipedia: Pensées; Wikipedia: Motivational interviewing; Wikipedia: Backfire effect; Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Pascal's Wager.

COMMENTS