Rio 2016 Olympics Photo: Favelas, Fireworks and a $13 Billion Bill

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
This One Photo of the Olympics Sums Up Everything Wrong With Society

Fireworks over the Maracanã during the opening ceremony of the Rio 2016 Olympics, seen from a hillside neighbourhood nearby, where residents watched the show from alleys and rooftops.

The picture is simple: a few people standing in a dark, rough street on a hillside, looking across the valley at a stadium exploding with light. It was taken on the night of 5 August 2016, when Rio de Janeiro opened the first Olympic Games ever held in South America. Inside the Maracanã, about 60,000 spectators and a global television audience estimated at three billion watched a spectacular ceremony. Outside, in the favelas that climb the hills around the stadium, many people watched it from a distance because they could not afford to be there.

That contrast is why the image travelled so far online. To many viewers it captured, in a single frame, the gap between a costly global show and the daily lives of the people living next door to it. The details behind the photo, from the final bill for the Games to what happened to the venues afterwards, show that the feeling it provoked was not just sentiment.

What the photo shows, and where it was taken

The Maracanã sits in the north of Rio, below Mangueira, one of roughly a thousand favelas in the city. Mangueira is home to around 40,000 people and, like many informal hillside communities, has long struggled with poverty and gang violence. On opening night, residents gathered on roofs and balconies, shared beer and snacks with neighbours, and filmed the fireworks on their phones.

Reporters who spent the evening there found mixed feelings rather than pure anger. Some people were proud that their city was hosting the world, and enjoyed the show. Others said the event was plainly not meant for them. A 30-year-old doorman who works in wealthy Ipanema summed it up for the Boston Globe: the poor were close in distance, but far away.

Tickets for the opening ceremony cost between about US$63 and US$1,400. At the time, a worker on Brazil’s minimum wage earned roughly US$55 a week, so even the cheapest seat represented more than a week of pay.

How much the Rio 2016 Olympics cost

This One Photo of the Olympics Sums Up Everything Wrong With Society

The Olympic rings lit up during the Rio 2016 ceremonies. Behind the spectacle sat a budget that kept growing long after the flame went out.

Olympic costs are notoriously hard to pin down because organisers, governments and researchers count different things. Three numbers help make sense of Rio:

  • About US$4.6 billion was the Oxford Olympics Study estimate for the sports-related part of the Games: operations plus venues, but not roads, rail or other city infrastructure.
  • Around US$12 billion was the figure widely quoted during the Games once related spending was added in.
  • 43.3 billion reais (about US$13.2 billion) was the total published in 2017 by Brazil’s federal Olympic legacy agency, AGLO. That was roughly 14.5 billion reais more than the 28.8 billion reais planned when Rio won the bid in 2009.

Of that final total, about 7.23 billion reais went on venues, 9.2 billion on operating costs and some 26.7 billion on infrastructure such as a new metro line and the redevelopment of the old port. For comparison, London 2012 cost about £8.92 billion, and the average Summer Games since 1960 has cost about US$5.2 billion in sports-related spending alone.

Brazil in 2016: recession, scandal and a city in debt

The timing could hardly have been worse. When Rio won the bid, Brazil’s economy was booming. By 2016 the country was in its deepest recession since the 1990s. The Petrobras corruption scandal had brought millions of people onto the streets in 2015 and early 2016, and on 12 May 2016 President Dilma Rousseff was suspended pending an impeachment trial. Michel Temer presided over the Games as acting president.

For ordinary people this meant job losses, rising prices and strained public services, while stadiums, a new metro extension and security operations went ahead. Many Brazilians had already protested before the 2014 World Cup, demanding that money go to schools and hospitals instead of sports arenas. The Olympics, two years later, revived the same argument.

Some promised improvements for favelas, such as better transport and utilities, were delayed or cut back as money ran short. That gap between the promise and the delivery is part of what the photo seems to show.

Do the Olympics pay off for host cities?

Supporters of hosting argue that the Games bring tourism, investment and a lasting boost to a city’s image. Most economists who have studied mega-events are sceptical. Research on Olympics and World Cups generally finds little or no measurable long-term gain in jobs or growth, while the costs fall mostly on taxpayers.

Writing for the Mises Institute during the Rio Games, the economist Ryan McMaken argued that Brazil’s spending equalled about 0.72% of the national budget and that the benefits flowed mainly to contractors and well-connected insiders. His conclusion was blunt: wherever the economics of big sporting events has been studied, they have done little for the host economy.

Voters elsewhere have drawn similar conclusions. Norway withdrew its bid for the 2022 Winter Games in 2014, and Boston dropped out of the race for 2024 the following year, both after public opposition over cost.

What happened to Rio’s venues after the Games

The fears about “white elephants” turned out to be well founded. Within months of the closing ceremony, the Maracanã, renovated for the 2014 World Cup at a cost of roughly US$500 million, had been largely abandoned and then vandalised, with thousands of seats ripped out and televisions stolen. The Olympic Park was described in press reports as a ghost town.

The Future Arena, designed to be taken apart and rebuilt as schools, was still standing in November 2017 because there was no money to dismantle it. Even the new metro line, one of the headline legacy projects, did not reach the main Olympic Park. The head of the legacy agency admitted at the time that managing the legacy was not easy.

Not everything was wasted. The waterfront district of Porto Maravilha, with its new tram line and museums, changed a run-down part of the city centre, and some sports facilities found new users. But for many residents of the hills around the Maracanã, the benefits were hard to see.

Reading the photo fairly

When the photo first spread in 2016, it was shared with a strongly worded opinion piece by Vic Bishop of Waking Times, which compared Rio to the dystopia of Hunger Games, where a wealthy capital lives in luxury while the districts around it go without. The comparison is dramatic, but the underlying point holds up: a city in crisis spent billions on a two-week event, and much of that spending left little behind for the people who paid for it.

It is also worth avoiding a few easy myths. Favela residents were not a single angry crowd; many watched with pride as well as frustration. The Olympics did not create Rio’s inequality, which has deep roots in the country’s history. And the Games are not uniquely Brazilian in their excess: Beijing 2008 and Sochi 2014 cost far more.

What the photo does capture is a question every future host city should be asked. Who is the Olympics for, and who pays? Rio’s answer, judged by the final bill and the empty venues, should make the next bid committee think carefully, and give the neighbours of the next stadium a real say.

Sources: Wikipedia: 2016 Summer Olympics; VOA News (AP), 2017: Olympic Rio 2016 price tag rises to $13 billion; Boston Globe (AP), 2016: Rio’s poor watch Olympic opening from rooftops; Ryan McMaken, Mises Wire, 8 August 2016; original opinion piece by Vic Bishop, Waking Times.

Related:

COMMENTS