Cockroach Milk: The Protein Crystals Behind the Superfood Hype

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2016-08-09.

Cockroach milk is real, but it is not a drink and it is not on sale. It is a protein-rich substance that one unusual species, the Pacific beetle cockroach Diploptera punctata, produces to feed its embryos while they develop inside the mother. Once swallowed, the liquid turns into tiny crystals in the embryos' guts. In July 2016 an international team described the structure of those crystals in fine detail, and the researchers' calculations suggested that a crystal stores more than three times the energy of the same mass of dairy milk. That finding launched a wave of "superfood of the future" headlines. The science is fascinating; the superfood part was, and still is, speculation.

Cockroach-Milk Research and the Superfood Headline

A cockroach that gives birth to live young

Most cockroaches lay their eggs in a hard case. Diploptera punctata does something far rarer: it is viviparous, meaning the young develop inside the mother and are born alive. The species is found across a wide area including Australia, India, China, Myanmar, Fiji and Hawaii.

While the embryos grow inside her brood sac, the mother secretes a fluid made of water-soluble proteins, fats and sugars. This is the "milk". It supplies essential amino acids such as lysine, leucine and valine, building blocks the young cannot make for themselves. As the embryos take it in, the proteins pack together into crystals in their midgut, a natural store of food that is gradually digested.

The comparison with mammals is loose but useful. Like mammal mothers, this cockroach invests energy in nourishing her young before and during development, rather than leaving them to fend for themselves from an egg.

What the 2016 study actually found

The study, published in the journal IUCrJ by Sanchari Banerjee, Subramanian Ramaswamy and colleagues, was led from the Institute for Stem Cell Biology and Regenerative Medicine in Bangalore, India, with partners in the United States, Japan, Canada and France. Crystals that form naturally inside a living animal are rare, and they are hard to study, so the team extracted crystals from the embryos and examined them with X-rays at a synchrotron.

They solved the structure at 1.2 ångströms, which is atomic resolution. The crystals are built from milk proteins in the lipocalin family, which the authors called Lili-Mip. Unusually, they are not uniform: the protein chains differ slightly in their amino-acid sequences, carry sugar chains at four sites, and hold fatty acids, probably linoleic or oleic acid, in a pocket inside each protein. In other words, a single crystal packs protein, carbohydrate and fat together in a stable, tightly packed form.

Banerjee described the crystals as being like a complete food, with all the essential amino acids. Ramaswamy, who led the project, called it "time-released food": as the protein is digested, more is released at a steady rate, which is exactly what a growing embryo needs.

Is it really four times as nutritious as cow's milk?

Here the headlines ran ahead of the paper. The study's energy comparison was a calculation about calories per unit of mass, and the authors put it at more than three times the energy of an equivalent amount of dairy milk. Some articles compared it with buffalo milk instead, and others turned it into "four times as nutritious as cow's milk".

Those are not the same claim. Energy density is not the same as nutritional value. A tablespoon of olive oil is far more energy-dense than a glass of milk, but nobody would call it more nutritious overall. Milk also contains calcium, vitamins and water, and a crystal of concentrated protein is closer to a protein powder than to a drink. What the study really shows is that the crystals are a highly concentrated, balanced package of nutrients for a cockroach embryo.

It is also worth being clear about what the research did not do. Nobody tested the crystals as human food. There were no studies of safety, digestibility, allergenic potential or taste. The researchers were interested in the structure of a remarkable natural crystal, and the food angle was a possibility they mentioned in interviews.

From cockroach gut to yeast vat?

Milking cockroaches is not a realistic option. Each embryo holds only a tiny amount of crystal, and harvesting it would be slow and expensive. So the team's idea was different: now that the genes behind the milk proteins were known, they hoped to get yeast to produce the crystals in quantity, much as yeast and bacteria are already used to make insulin, enzymes and some food ingredients.

That idea fits a broader trend often called precision fermentation, in which microbes are engineered to produce specific proteins. Companies now use it to make dairy-identical whey proteins without cows. But turning a natural crystal into a commercial ingredient raises big questions. Could microbes reproduce the same mixture of sugar chains and bound fats? Would the product be safe, and approved by food regulators? Would anyone want to eat something marketed, however indirectly, as cockroach milk? Since 2016 there has been no sign of a product reaching shops.

Who could benefit, and who should be careful

If a concentrated, stable, slow-release protein could ever be made cheaply, the obvious use would be for people who struggle to get enough calories and protein: in food emergencies, for malnourished children, for athletes or for people with high energy needs. Ramaswamy suggested at the time that the crystals were stable enough to become a fantastic protein supplement.

For most people in wealthy countries, the problem is the opposite. Many diets already supply more than enough calories, and an extra energy-dense supplement is not what is missing. Insects in general are also a known source of allergens; cockroach proteins in particular are a common indoor allergy and asthma trigger. Anyone thinking about new protein supplements, insect-based or otherwise, especially with allergies, a medical condition or during pregnancy, should talk to a doctor first.

Myths and facts at a glance

  • Myth: All cockroaches make milk. Fact: This is a special feature of Diploptera punctata, one of very few viviparous cockroaches.
  • Myth: You can buy cockroach milk. Fact: No commercial cockroach-milk product has been approved or marketed as food.
  • Myth: It is four times healthier than cow's milk. Fact: The study estimated it holds more than three times the energy per mass of dairy milk; energy is not the same as overall nutrition.
  • Myth: Scientists recommended people start drinking it. Fact: The research was structural biology; it did not test human consumption.

The real lesson of cockroach milk is how inventive nature can be. A small insect has evolved a way to pack a complete, slow-release meal into a crystal, and scientists were able to map it atom by atom. Whether that ends up on a supermarket shelf is a separate and much longer story.

Sources: Banerjee et al., IUCrJ (2016): Structure of a heterogeneous, glycosylated, lipid-bound, in vivo-grown protein crystal at atomic resolution; Wikipedia: Diploptera punctata; interviews in the Times of India; original article by Science Alert.

COMMENTS