
Photo: Jay Weinstein, from So I Asked Them To Smile.
A stern face tells you very little about the person behind it. That is the whole idea behind So I Asked Them To Smile, a long-running portrait series by photographer Jay Weinstein. He photographs strangers, mostly on the streets and in the villages of India, twice: first with a neutral or serious expression, then a moment later with a smile. Nothing else changes. Same light, same background, same clothes, same person.
Seen side by side, the pairs are startling. A man who looks forbidding in the first frame looks like a favourite uncle in the second. A wary child becomes a mischievous one. The series is a simple, honest test of how quickly we judge people from their faces, and how often that first judgement is wrong.
Weinstein deliberately leaves out names, jobs, religion and life stories. What follows are 29 of his pairs, with a note on where each was taken and what to look for, followed by what psychology research says about smiles and snap judgements.
How a stranger in Bikaner started the project
The series began in December 2013, on a photography trip to Bikaner, a desert city in Rajasthan. Near the busy railway station, Weinstein noticed a man with a fierce, unsmiling expression. He wanted the portrait but felt too intimidated to ask, so he photographed other people instead.
Then the man called over and asked to be photographed too. Weinstein raised the camera and asked him to smile. The change was immediate: the face softened, the eyes lit up, even the man's posture relaxed. Weinstein later wrote that the stranger was "transformed", and he decided on the spot that this transformation would be his next project.
Over the following years he repeated the experiment with people he met while travelling, keeping the method strict: one frame without a smile, one with. The project was first widely shared through his Facebook page and a feature on Bored Panda, and the pairs have circulated online ever since.
Portraits 1 to 10: from Vrindavan to Bagru
#1 Vrindavan, Uttar Pradesh

An elderly man with a long white beard and bright tilak marks on his forehead, a common sign of Vaishnava devotion in Vrindavan. The town, on the Yamuna in Mathura district, is believed to be where Krishna spent his childhood, and it draws holy men and pilgrims all year. Unsmiling, he looks severe; smiling, the lines around his eyes tell a different story.
#2 Hampi, Karnataka

A young woman photographed in black and white at Hampi, the ruined capital of the Vijayanagara Empire on the Tungabhadra River and a UNESCO World Heritage Site since 1986. Her neutral expression reads as guarded, almost defiant. The second frame shows how much of that impression came from a single held breath.
#3 Juhu, Mumbai

A man in a white turban and scarf, framed against a plain sky in the beachside neighbourhood of Juhu in western Mumbai. Thick moustache, steady gaze: many viewers would call him intimidating. His grin in the second shot is so wide it changes the shape of his whole face.
#4 Tyrna Village, Meghalaya

A small child in a red jumper stands against a rough stone wall in Tyrna, a Khasi village in the hills of Meghalaya in north-east India. Children often look solemn in front of a stranger's camera. The smile in the lower frame is pure mischief.
#5 Vrindavan, Uttar Pradesh

A bearded man with a white cloth over his shoulder, photographed in open ground near Vrindavan. His dreadlocked hair and weathered skin give the first frame a hard edge. The second frame brings out warmth that was there all along, just not showing.
#6 Kakhsar Village, Gujarat

A young man in a green checked shirt and purple scarf, photographed in a doorway in a village in Gujarat. His first look is tired and watchful. His smile reveals a much younger, lighter personality, the kind of shift the whole series is built on.
#7 Bandra, Mumbai

A bearded man in a white skullcap on a busy street in Bandra, one of Mumbai's oldest and most mixed suburbs. Viewers sometimes project stereotypes onto faces like this one. The second frame is a quiet answer: a broad, open smile that anyone would return.
#8 Danda Village Jetty, Mumbai

A boy in a striped shirt at the jetty of Danda, a fishing village tucked into Mumbai's Khar area. The unsmiling shot shows wide, serious eyes. The smiling one shows a child who clearly found the whole thing funny.
#9 Bagru Village, Rajasthan

An older man in a white turban and glasses in Bagru, near Jaipur, a town famous for hand block printing with natural dyes, a craft kept alive by the Chhipa community. Unsmiling, he looks stern and formal. Smiling, he looks like he is about to tell you a story.
#10 Kakhsar Village, Gujarat

A woman balances stacked metal water pots on her head, standing in front of green fields in Gujarat. Carrying water this way is still part of daily work in many rural areas. Her calm first look and her bright second one show strength and humour in the same person.
Portraits 11 to 20: temples, hills and the sea
#11 Vrindavan, Uttar Pradesh

A young boy in a checked shirt near railway tracks in Vrindavan. In the second frame he covers his mouth with his hand, too shy or too amused to show the smile fully. It is one of the most human moments in the series, because the smile wins anyway.
#12 Latikynsew Village, Meghalaya

A man in a striped beanie with sunglasses pushed up on his head, standing in front of large satellite dishes in a village in Meghalaya. His neutral face is hard to read. The smile turns him into someone you would happily ask for directions.
#13 Jagannath Puri, Odisha

A curly-haired man in front of painted guardian lions at a shrine in Puri, the coastal city famous for the Jagannath Temple and its annual chariot festival. His intense stare in the first frame is softened completely in the second. The colourful backdrop makes the change even easier to see.
#14 Vrindavan, Uttar Pradesh

An elderly man in glasses and a printed shawl, shot in black and white in Vrindavan. Without a smile, the deep lines on his face look like worry. With one, the same lines read as decades of laughter.
#15 Khonoma, Nagaland

A small boy in front of a traditional wooden house in Khonoma, an Angami Naga village near Kohima. Khonoma banned hunting in 1998 after a mass killing of rare Blyth's tragopans and was named India's first "green village" in 2005. The boy's gap-toothed grin is one of the happiest in the collection.
#16 Ral Village, Uttar Pradesh

A young man in a neat white shirt with a red tilak on his forehead, standing in front of a bright blue wall. His first look is serious, almost formal, like an ID photo. His smile makes him look years younger and far more approachable.
#17 Outside St. Xavier's College, Mumbai

A worker in a dust-covered cap and checked scarf, photographed outside St. Xavier's College in south Mumbai. The dust suggests a long day of physical work. His unsmiling face looks exhausted; his smile looks like the end of a shift.
#18 Kakhsar Village, Gujarat

A man wrapped from head to shoulders in a bright magenta checked blanket, against a whitewashed brick wall. Half his face is hidden, so the eyes do most of the work. Even so, the difference between the two frames is unmistakable.
#19 Jagannath Puri, Odisha

A woman in a red and white sari with a bindi, photographed against an ochre wall in Puri. Her raised eyebrows in the first frame look sceptical. In the second, the same face looks friendly and slightly amused.
#20 Danda Village Jetty, Mumbai

A fisherman stands in front of a beached wooden boat at Danda at dusk. Boats like this one are a working part of Mumbai's coast, not a postcard. His smile in the lower frame makes the whole scene feel warmer.
Portraits 21 to 29: Mumbai, Pune and the Braj country
#21 Juhu Beach, Mumbai

A boy fresh out of the waves at Juhu Beach, wet hair and a hard stare. Juhu is one of Mumbai's busiest beaches, especially on weekend evenings. A second later he is grinning ear to ear, and the tough-kid act is gone.
#22 Pune, Maharashtra

A worker in a yellow hard hat and orange safety vest, photographed against a blue wall in Pune. His first expression is all business. His smile, eyes crinkled almost shut, is one of the most joyful in the series.
#23 Barsana, Uttar Pradesh

A man lying back on a woven cot, his forehead covered in yellow sandalwood paste, in Barsana. The town in Mathura district is revered as the birthplace of Radha, Krishna's consort. He barely moves between the two frames, yet a small smile changes the mood completely.
#24 Tyrna Village, Meghalaya

A teenager with a spiked haircut and a checked scarf pulled over his nose and mouth, in black and white. With most of his face covered, you can only judge him by his eyes. The smile still comes through, which shows how much the eyes carry.
#25 Vrindavan, Uttar Pradesh

An older woman in a yellow headscarf and nose ring, photographed outdoors near Vrindavan. Vrindavan is home to thousands of widows, many living in poverty, though nothing in the photo tells us her story. Her smile is wide and unguarded.
#26 Kohima, Nagaland

A woman with a fringe and small gold earrings, photographed in Kohima, capital of Nagaland. The city is known for the 1944 Battle of Kohima and for the Hornbill Festival every December. Her first expression is reserved; her smile is warm and sudden.
#27 Vrindavan, Uttar Pradesh

A man with an orange turban, aviator sunglasses, a full white beard and prayer beads. In the first frame he looks like a character from an action film. In the second, a slight smile turns him into a dignified grandfather.
#28 Vrindavan, Uttar Pradesh

A young worker in a pink checked headscarf among flowering plants near Vrindavan. Flowers are big business in pilgrimage towns, where garlands are offered at temples every day. Her shy smile is the gentlest in the collection.
#29 Juhu Beach, Mumbai

A young man in glasses in front of a weathered metal wall at Juhu. His neutral face looks almost suspicious; his smile looks like someone who just heard a good joke. It is a fitting final pair: the smallest change in expression, the biggest change in impression.
What research says about faces and first impressions
Psychologists have studied this effect for decades. Experiments on face perception suggest that people form an impression of a stranger in about a tenth of a second, and that judgements of trustworthiness and attractiveness come fastest. Looking longer mostly makes us more confident, not necessarily more accurate.
Studies also find that faces showing negative emotion produce more negative impressions than neutral ones, and that people lean heavily on appearance even when given information that contradicts it. A neutral face, especially one that is tired, sun-worn or unfamiliar, is easily misread as hostile.
Smiles have their own science. In the nineteenth century the French neurologist Guillaume Duchenne showed that a genuine smile engages not only the muscle that lifts the corners of the mouth (the zygomatic major) but also the muscle around the eyes (the orbicularis oculi), creating crow's feet. Many of the pairs above show exactly that: the eyes change as much as the mouth.
There are caveats. How smiling is read varies by culture, and research shows that in some settings smiling people are judged as less intelligent or less trustworthy. A smile is a signal, not proof of character. But the series makes the more important point well: an unsmiling face is not evidence of a bad person.
What to take from these portraits
Every person in these photos is the same person in both frames. The only thing that changed was a muscle movement, and our reaction to them. That is worth remembering the next time a stranger on a train, a new colleague or a shopkeeper looks unfriendly. They may be tired, concentrating, shy or simply resting their face.
The practical lesson is small but real: hold the first judgement loosely, and give people a second frame. Often all it takes is a greeting, or a smile of your own.
Sources: Photographs by Jay Weinstein, So I Asked Them To Smile (Facebook); Bored Panda feature on the project; Wikipedia: First impression (psychology); Wikipedia: Duchenne smile; Vrindavan, Hampi, Bagru, Khonoma, Barsana and Kohima (Wikipedia).

Wow! Great! I love #21!!!
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely wonderful.
ReplyDeleteawesome
ReplyDeletePower of the visual is lost by putting the portrait side by side. Instead, i suggest having a 'reveal' feature which actually allows the reader to make a first impression, which can then be stripped away by the second portrait.
ReplyDeleteawesomeeeeeeeeee
ReplyDeletePart of me feels like this is a half-measure. But how do you dismantle orientalism? strong effort.
ReplyDeletebeautiful
ReplyDelete