The Caribbean's Rossby Whistle: A Sea That Hums Too Low to Hear

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2016-08-05.

The “Rossby Whistle”: Caribbean Sea Hums a Note Detected From Space

The Caribbean Sea "whistles". That is the short version of a 2016 discovery by oceanographers at the University of Liverpool, who found that water in the Caribbean basin sloshes in and out on a regular cycle of about 120 days. The cycle behaves like a note played on an enormous wind instrument, far too slow and too low for any ear to hear, yet strong enough to show up in satellite measurements of Earth's gravity. The researchers named it the Rossby whistle.

Here is what the whistle actually is, how scientists detected it, why the "sound" is really a metaphor, and why it matters for people living along the coasts of Colombia and Venezuela.

What the scientists found

The team, led by sea-level scientist Professor Chris Hughes with co-authors Joanne Williams, Angela Hibbert, Carmen Boening and James Oram, published their results in Geophysical Research Letters in June 2016. They had not set out to look for anything musical. They were studying how pressure on the sea floor and sea level change across the Caribbean, because the region is a key link in the North Atlantic's circulation.

Ocean computer models for the period from 1958 to 2013 kept showing a strong, regular pressure oscillation across the whole basin. Hughes later told reporters that the region stood out like a sore thumb in the data because it did not behave like the rest of the ocean.

To check that the pattern was real and not a quirk of the models, the team compared it with three independent kinds of measurement:

  • pressure sensors on the sea floor,
  • tide gauges on Caribbean coasts, and
  • satellite measurements of tiny changes in Earth's gravity field, which rise and fall as large masses of water move around.

All three showed the same rhythm. The oscillation was genuine.

What is a Rossby wave?

The whistle is built on a special kind of ocean wave called a Rossby wave. These are not the waves you see breaking on a beach. They are huge, slow undulations, hundreds of kilometres long, that exist because the Earth spins and because the strength of that spin effect changes with latitude. In the ocean they travel westward, often taking months or years to cross a basin, and their height at the surface is usually only a few centimetres.

Researchers had already noticed something odd about Rossby waves in the Caribbean. Waves heading west across the basin seemed to vanish at its western edge and then reappear on the eastern side, a behaviour that earlier work had nicknamed a "Rossby wormhole". The 2016 study explained what was going on: the energy is not lost but is carried back eastward along the boundary, so the wave effectively loops around the basin.

How the whistle works

Hughes compared the Caribbean to an ordinary whistle. When you blow into one, the jet of air becomes unstable and sets up a sound wave that fits neatly inside the cavity. Because the whistle is open at one end, some of that vibration escapes and you hear it.

In the Caribbean, the role of the air jet is played by the ocean current flowing through the sea from east to west. That current becomes unstable and excites a Rossby wave whose size fits the basin. Only certain wavelengths reinforce themselves on each round trip, so the basin resonates at one dominant period of roughly 120 days. Because the Caribbean is partly open to the Atlantic, water is pushed in and out with each cycle, and that changing mass is what the gravity satellites detect.

Hughes also suggested that the whistle may draw energy out of the current as it passes through the Caribbean. That current feeds the Caribbean Current, which in turn flows into the Gulf of Mexico and on to the Gulf Stream.

How low is the note? A quick correction

When the story first went viral, several outlets said the tone was an A-flat about 30 octaves below the lowest note on a piano. The basic idea is right, but the number is a little high. A cycle of 120 days corresponds to a frequency of roughly one ten-millionth of a hertz. The lowest key on a standard piano sounds at 27.5 Hz, and dividing one by the other works out to about 28 octaves. Live Science, reporting on the same study, gave the figure as around 28 octaves, which matches the arithmetic.

Either way, nobody will ever hear it directly. Human hearing starts at about 20 Hz. The pitched-up audio clips that circulated in 2016 were made by speeding the signal up billions of times so that the rhythm could be played as an audible tone.

(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)

It is worth stressing that the "sound" is an analogy. You cannot stand on a beach in Aruba and listen to the sea hum. The whistle is a pattern in pressure, sea level and gravity that behaves mathematically like a musical note.

Why the Rossby whistle matters

The practical payoff is about sea level and flooding. According to Hughes, the whistle can change sea level by as much as 10 cm along the coasts of Colombia and Venezuela. That may sound small, but during a storm surge or an unusually high tide a few extra centimetres can decide whether water stays in the harbour or spills into the streets.

Because the cycle is regular, it is also predictable. Knowing where the basin is in its 120-day rhythm could help forecasters judge flood risk on those coasts weeks or months ahead.

The wider question is how the whistle affects the Atlantic as a whole. If it really does tap energy from the current that feeds the Gulf Stream, it may influence how heat is carried north, which shapes the climate of North America and Europe. The authors described this as a topic for further research rather than a settled conclusion.

Common misunderstandings

"A mysterious noise is coming from the sea." There is no mystery noise. The phenomenon is a measured, well-explained oscillation of water mass.

"It can be heard from space." Satellites do not listen. They measure gravity, and the whistle shows up because moving water changes the local gravitational pull very slightly.

"It is a sign that something is going wrong with the ocean." The study analysed decades of data back to 1958. The whistle appears to be a long-standing natural feature of the Caribbean, not a new warning sign.

The Rossby whistle is a lovely example of how a strange line in a model can lead to a real discovery. A puzzling pattern in simulations was checked against instruments on the sea floor, on the coast and in orbit, and turned out to be a basin-sized resonance that had been hiding in plain sight.

Sources: ScienceDaily / University of Liverpool, June 2016; Live Science: Caribbean Sea's curious whistle detected from space; Hughes et al., Geophysical Research Letters, 2016; earlier coverage by Gizmodo and ScienceAlert.

COMMENTS