
Marriage and family therapist Jed Diamond describes long-term love as a journey through five stages: falling in love, becoming a couple, disillusionment, real and lasting love, and finally using the strength of the partnership to help others. His central claim is simple. Many couples break up in the third stage because they assume the bad feelings mean they chose the wrong person, when in his view that stage is where the deeper relationship actually begins.
Diamond, founder of the MenAlive website, has worked with couples for decades and wrote about these stages from his own experience: two earlier marriages that ended, and a later marriage to his wife Carlin that, by the time he first published this model, had lasted more than thirty-five years. He develops the idea at length in his book The Enlightened Marriage: The 5 Transformative Stages of Relationships and Why the Best Is Still to Come. Below is a summary of each stage, what relationship research says about it, and what couples can do when they reach the hard part.
Stage 1: Falling in love
The first stage is the one everyone recognises: you cannot stop thinking about the other person, everything they do seems charming, and the future looks certain. Diamond describes it as nature's way of pairing people up. Brain chemistry plays a real part. Studies by anthropologist Helen Fisher and others found that early romantic love activates the brain's reward system, the same dopamine-driven circuits involved in craving and motivation.
The other ingredient is projection. In this phase we tend to see a partner as the answer to old disappointments, the person who will finally give us what earlier relationships, or our childhood, did not. Because the feelings are so strong, it is hard to notice we are doing it.
George Bernard Shaw made fun of this in the preface to his 1908 play Getting Married, describing newlyweds as being "under the influence of the most violent, most insane, most delusive, and most transient of passions." His joke is that couples are asked to promise lifelong commitment at the very moment their judgement is least reliable.
Stage 2: Becoming a couple
As the first rush settles, the relationship becomes a shared life. Couples build routines, a home and often a family. The feelings shift from excitement toward comfort: warmth, trust, the sense of being looked after. Diamond notes that sex may become less frantic but more satisfying, and that many people believe this is the final destination.
Researchers sometimes describe this as the move from passionate to companionate love. Psychologist Elaine Hatfield, who studied both for decades, found that intense passion usually fades over the first years while companionship can grow. Nothing has gone wrong when this happens. The risk is assuming the calm will last forever without any effort, which leaves couples unprepared for what comes next.
Stage 3: Disillusionment, where many couples stop
At some point, slowly or suddenly, the relationship starts to feel bad. Small habits become irritating. One or both partners feel unappreciated, trapped or lonely. Some people pour themselves into work or children; others withdraw, argue more, or quietly start imagining a different life. Couples may stay together but live side by side without real closeness.
Diamond writes that this is exactly where his first two marriages ended, and that he and Carlin came close to separating too. Both developed heart rhythm problems during this period, and he faced depression and sexual difficulties. He uses that history to make his main argument: this stage feels like the end, but it is really the point where the illusions of stage one burn away and two real people finally meet.
Relationship research supports part of this picture. Studies of marital satisfaction commonly find a decline over the early years of marriage, and the Gottman Institute, drawing on decades of observing couples, reports that most recurring conflicts between partners are never fully solved. Couples who last tend to learn to live with these "perpetual problems" and discuss them with humour and respect, rather than hoping they will vanish. Disillusionment, in other words, is common, not a sign that you picked wrongly.
That said, not every unhappy relationship should be saved. Diamond's model assumes two people who are both willing to work on things. Where there is violence, control or fear, the priority is safety, not patience.
Stage 4: Creating real, lasting love
Diamond believes the way through stage three is to look at what is really driving the pain. For him and Carlin, the answers lay in their childhoods. His father suffered from depression and attempted suicide when Jed was five; Carlin's father was violent, and her mother left to protect herself and her daughter. Both carried those experiences into their marriage.
He connects this to the Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) research. The original CDC–Kaiser Permanente study surveyed more than 17,000 adults in Southern California between 1995 and 1997. Almost two-thirds reported at least one adverse experience in childhood, and the more experiences people reported, the higher their risk of later physical and mental health problems. The study shows a strong link across large groups rather than proving cause in any one person's life, but it helped Diamond see his own adult depression in a new light.
Once he and Carlin understood each other's old wounds, he writes, they began to treat each other as allies instead of opponents. A partner's sharp reaction stopped looking like cruelty and started looking like an old hurt being touched. That shift, being seen and accepted as you actually are, is what he calls real, lasting love.
Practical ways couples work through stage three
- Name the stage. Simply knowing disillusionment is common can lower the panic and the urge to escape.
- Talk about patterns, not just incidents. Ask what a recurring fight is really about, and whether it echoes something from earlier in life.
- Keep small positive moments going. Appreciation, affection and shared jokes make difficult conversations easier.
- Get outside help early. A couples therapist can spot patterns that are invisible from inside. If stress is affecting sleep, mood or physical health, talk to a doctor.
Stage 5: Using the power of two to change the world
The last stage looks outward. Diamond argues that a couple who have learned to cross their own differences have something to offer a divided world. If two people who love each other can find peace, he suggests, that experience can feed into work for their community, whatever form it takes.
For Diamond and Carlin, that meant focusing on men and women at midlife, the period when many long marriages come under strain. For other couples it might mean volunteering together, mentoring younger couples, fostering, or simply raising children who have seen conflict handled well. The idea is that a stable partnership is not only a private comfort but a base for contributing to others.
How useful is the five-stage model?
Like most stage models, this one is a map, not a law. Real relationships loop back and forth, and some couples never experience a dramatic crisis. It is also one therapist's framework, built largely on clinical and personal experience rather than controlled studies. Its strength is the reframe it offers: the hard middle of a long relationship is normal, and it can be a turning point rather than an ending.
If you recognise yourself in stage three, the most practical takeaway is not to make a permanent decision on the basis of a temporary low. Look honestly at what is going on, ask for help, and give the relationship a fair chance to move into the next stage, or, if it truly cannot, end it with more understanding of yourself than when it began.
Sources: Jed Diamond, "The 5 Stages of Love: Why Too Many Stop at Stage 3," MenAlive; Jed Diamond, "The 5 Stages of Love: A Hero's Journey for Men, Women, and Humanity," MenAlive; CDC, About Adverse Childhood Experiences; George Bernard Shaw, Getting Married (1908), Project Gutenberg; earlier republished via Ideaspots.
Related:
- Twenty-Six Small Gestures Couples Describe as Love
- A Zen Pencils Comic About Love and Letting Go
- Adrienne Hedger's Comic About Falling Asleep on the Couch
- Nidhi Chanani's Illustrations of Everyday Love
- Ten Romantic Sketches by Zac Retz
- Puuung's Illustrations of Love in Everyday Moments
- An Animated Comedy About Meeting Your Crush
- The Pain Of Being In Love With Someone You Can Never Be With
- As I Began to Love Myself: A Poem With Uncertain Attribution
- What Albert Einstein Taught Us About Love
- Brain Scans Show The Real Impact Love Has On A Child’s Brain
- Self-Kindness in Practice: Small Choices Worth Considering
- Research Mapping Human Emotions Shows Strong Mind Body Connection
- The Effect Of Positive Emotions On Our Health
- Social Science Says Lasting Relationships Come Down To 2 Basic Traits
- 18 Signs That You're In A Happy Relationship
- Twenty Reflections on Building Meaningful Relationships
- Signs That Your Relationship Can Last
- Before a Relationship: Making Room for Your Own Life
- 5 Signs You’re in a Toxic or Draining Relationship
- 9 Good Signs That You’re In The Right Relationship
- Relationship Lessons From a Personal Experience of Partnership
- 10 Toxic Relationships Mentally Strong People Avoid
- 10 Signs You Have Found Your Soulmate
For another romantic opinion piece to compare with this perspective, read A Reflection on Love That Supports Change.

COMMENTS