Dostoevsky's The Dream of a Ridiculous Man: Plot, Meaning and Message

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
The Day Dostoyevsky Discovered the Meaning of Life in a Dream
Fyodor Dostoevsky, painted by Vasily Perov around 1872

Fyodor Dostoevsky never claimed that he personally found the meaning of life in a dream. The dream belongs to a character: the nameless narrator of The Dream of a Ridiculous Man, a short story Dostoevsky published in 1877. That narrator, a lonely man in St. Petersburg who has decided to shoot himself, falls asleep in his chair, dreams of his own death and of a second, innocent Earth, and wakes up certain that everything worth knowing fits into one old rule: love other people as you love yourself.

The story is only a few dozen pages long, yet scholars treat it as a compact map of Dostoevsky's thinking. Below is what happens in it, where it came from, the part of the plot that popular summaries usually leave out, and why readers still return to it.

Where the story first appeared

From 1873 until his death in 1881, Dostoevsky wrote A Writer's Diary, a running mix of essays, sketches, political commentary and fiction. It began as a column in the journal The Citizen and later became a monthly he published himself. The Dream of a Ridiculous Man came out in one of those self-published issues in 1877, a few years before The Brothers Karamazov (1879–1880). Early English translations sometimes called it "The Dream of a Queer Fellow".

By then Dostoevsky was in his mid-fifties and famous. He had also lived through things his narrator only imagines. In December 1849, as a member of the Petrashevsky Circle, he was marched before a firing squad, only for a last-minute order from the tsar to commute the sentence. Four years of hard labour in a prison camp at Omsk followed. Questions about death, guilt and whether life has any purpose were not abstract for him.

The narrator's opening mood also echoes Notes from Underground (1864), the short novel often described as an early classic of existentialist writing. Both feature an isolated, bitter, highly self-aware man talking directly to the reader. The difference is the ending: the Underground Man stays stuck, while the Ridiculous Man is transformed.

The girl, the revolver and an unexpected feeling of pity

The story opens on a dark, wet night. The narrator explains that people have laughed at him all his life, and that he has slowly come to a conclusion that frightens even him: nothing in the world matters. Months earlier he bought a revolver, and it has been waiting in a drawer ever since. Looking up at a single star breaking through the clouds, he decides that tonight is the night.

Then a small girl, perhaps eight years old, poorly dressed and terrified, runs up and tugs at his sleeve, begging him to help her mother. He shouts at her and walks off to the shabby room he rents next to a drunken retired captain.

Sitting with the gun in front of him, he finds that he cannot stop thinking about her. If nothing matters, why does he feel pity and shame? A man about to vanish should feel nothing at all. This contradiction annoys him so much that he postpones his death to work it out. In a quiet way the child has already saved him, simply by making him feel something he could not explain. He sinks into his armchair, still arguing with himself, and falls asleep.

The dream: a shot, a coffin and a journey through space

The narrator stops to make a point about dreams themselves: how they can be vivid in some details while skipping blithely over time and space. "It seems that dreams are the work not of mind but of desire, not of the head but of the heart," he says, a line many readers remember long after the plot.

In the dream he picks up the revolver and shoots himself, not in the head as he had planned but in the heart. There is no pain, only darkness. He is carried away in a coffin and buried. He lies in the damp earth, expecting nothing, until drops of water begin to fall through the lid onto his closed eye, one every minute. Indignation rises in him, and with his whole being he calls out to whoever is responsible for this order of things, refusing to be humiliated even in death.

The grave opens. A dark, silent figure lifts him out and carries him through deep space, and eventually he sees a sun that seems to be an exact twin of ours.

“And it is so simple… You will instantly find how to live.”
Lord Rosse's 1845 drawing of the spiral Whirlpool Galaxy (M51), the first "nebula" shown to have a spiral shape. Some writers have suggested it influenced Van Gogh's The Starry Night.

The other Earth, and the part most summaries leave out

Around that second sun turns a second Earth. He lands on a Greek-looking island where people live in complete harmony with each other and with nature. They have no science in our sense, yet they seem to understand the trees and the stars. They love without jealousy and die without fear. Simply seeing their faces fills him with joy.

Many retellings of the story stop here, which makes it sound like a gentle vision of heaven. But Dostoevsky goes further, and it is the most important turn in the book. The narrator corrupts them. It begins with a single lie that he teaches them, almost as a game. Lying brings sensuality, then jealousy, then cruelty. The people split into groups, invent pride and shame, fight wars, and build science and laws to replace the feelings they have lost. They come to prefer knowledge about happiness to happiness itself. When the narrator, horrified, begs them to punish him, even to crucify him, they laugh at him and treat him as a madman.

This twist is what gives the ending its weight. The narrator is not just a visitor who glimpsed paradise. He watched paradise fall, and knows he was the cause.

Waking up: one rule for living

He wakes at dawn in the same armchair, the revolver untouched on the table. He pushes it away. What he feels is not relief but something stronger: a desire to live, and to tell everyone what he saw.

He knows people will mock him again. Of course it was only a dream, they will say. He does not care. What convinced him was not an argument but the experience of seeing people who were good and happy, and he concludes that this is possible on our Earth too. "I will not, I cannot believe that evil is the normal condition of men," he insists.

The rule he takes away is ancient and very plain. In one widely quoted translation, the key is to "love others as one loves oneself, that is the main thing, that is all". If everyone wanted it, he says, paradise could be arranged at once. His first practical step is a small one: in the final lines, he has found the little girl he turned away, and he means to keep going.

What critics see in it

The literary theorist Mikhail Bakhtin, in Problems of Dostoevsky's Poetics, treated the story as a modern example of Menippean satire, an ancient genre that mixes fantasy, philosophy and comedy. He considered it a near-complete collection of Dostoevsky's central themes in miniature:

  • The wise fool. The narrator is ridiculous in everyone's eyes, yet he is the one who has seen the truth.
  • Indifference and its danger. The belief that "nothing matters" leads directly to the revolver and to rudeness towards a frightened child.
  • Moral freedom without God. The narrator's reasoning before sleep echoes the famous idea, later voiced in The Brothers Karamazov, that without God or immortality everything would be permitted.
  • The dream as revelation. The story suggests that ordinary waking life may be no more real than a dream.
  • Paradise as a choice. The ideal world is not a distant afterlife but something people could build now.

Readers also notice how the story answers Dostoevsky's own critics. A thinker often labelled as gloomy here argues that despair is a mistake of the head, and that the heart knows better.

Common misreadings

  • "Dostoevsky had this dream himself." There is no evidence of that. It is fiction, though clearly close to his convictions.
  • "It is a story about heaven." Not really. The paradise is another Earth, and the central drama is how easily it is ruined.
  • "It was his very last story." It is one of his last short pieces, but he went on to finish The Brothers Karamazov and to give his celebrated Pushkin speech in June 1880.
  • "The message is to escape into dreams." The opposite: the narrator wakes up and turns towards real people, starting with a child he once ignored.

Because the story deals with suicide, it is worth saying plainly: if you are having thoughts like the narrator's, please talk to a doctor or someone you trust, or contact a local crisis line today.

How to read or watch it

The story is short enough to read in an hour. English versions include David Magarshack's translation in The Best Stories of Fyodor Dostoevsky, and Kenneth Lantz's translation of A Writer's Diary published by Northwestern University Press. It has also been adapted for the screen: Aleksandr Petrov made a hand-painted animated film of it in 1992, and the BBC produced a short television version, The Dream, starring Jeremy Irons.

Read it slowly, and pay attention to the moment the narrator corrupts the island. That is where the story stops being a comforting fable and becomes a mirror. The narrator's conclusion is that we already know how to live; what we lack is the will to do it, beginning with the person standing in front of us.

Sources: Wikipedia: The Dream of a Ridiculous Man; Wikipedia: Fyodor Dostoevsky; Wikipedia: Whirlpool Galaxy. With credit to Maria Popova's original 2014 essay on the story, Brain Pickings (now The Marginalian).

More from the archive:

COMMENTS