Paris Car-Free Days: What Happened to Air Pollution and Noise

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2016-05-30.

Paris Car-Free Days: Understanding the Reported Pollution Change

Paris held its first big car-free day on Sunday 27 September 2015, closing about 30% of the city to private cars and motorbikes. The regional air-quality agency, Airparif, measured nitrogen dioxide levels roughly 20% to 40% lower inside the closed zone than on a comparable Sunday earlier that month, and the noise-monitoring body Bruitparif reported that sound levels in the centre fell by about half. Encouraged, Mayor Anne Hidalgo floated the idea of car-free days “perhaps even once a month”, and from 2016 the city began closing parts of central Paris to traffic on a regular monthly basis.

The headline often repeated afterwards, that every car-free day cuts Paris air pollution by 40%, needs some unpacking. Here is what was actually measured, how the scheme developed, and what car-free days can and cannot do for a city’s air.

The first “Paris sans voiture” day

The 2015 event, called Paris sans voiture (“Paris without cars”), backed by Hidalgo, was a way to show residents what their streets could feel like without traffic. Private petrol and diesel vehicles were barred from the central zone, roughly from late morning to early evening (11 am to 6 pm is the timetable widely reported). Buses, taxis and emergency vehicles were still allowed, and elsewhere in the city lower speed limits applied.

The mayor had wanted the whole city to take part, but the police prefecture, which controls traffic regulation in Paris, limited the closure to around 30% of the city’s area. Even so, the effect on the streets was striking. Cyclists, walkers, skaters and families filled avenues that are usually jammed, and impromptu football games and yoga sessions sprang up on the asphalt.

Paris Car-Free Days: Understanding the Reported Pollution Change

Paris Car-Free Days: Understanding the Reported Pollution Change

What the measurements showed

Airparif compared readings from 27 September with those from Sunday 6 September, a day with similar weather. Its press release reported:

  • Average nitrogen dioxide (NO2) reductions of roughly 20% to 40% at monitoring stations inside the closed zone.
  • A fall of about 30% on the Champs-Élysées and about 20% at Place de l’Opéra.
  • Little or no change at some stations outside the zone.
  • Higher NO2 peaks on parts of the Boulevard Périphérique, the ring road, in the afternoon, which Airparif linked to traffic diverted around the closed area.

Bruitparif, which monitors noise across the Paris region, reported that sound levels in central areas dropped by around half, a change people noticed immediately: birdsong and conversations replaced the usual roar of engines.

Two points are worth keeping in mind. First, the 40% figure is the top of a range measured at particular stations on one day, not a citywide or guaranteed result. Second, NO2 comes mainly from road traffic, so it responds quickly when cars disappear. Fine particles (PM2.5) have many other sources, including heating, industry, agriculture and pollution blown in from elsewhere, and they do not fall as sharply.

Why Paris was looking for solutions

Paris had been struggling with severe smog episodes. In March 2014, and again in March 2015, spring pollution spikes led authorities to introduce emergency measures, including free public transport and alternate-day driving based on number plates. Photos of the Eiffel Tower fading into a brown haze circulated around the world.

Paris Car-Free Days: Understanding the Reported Pollution Change

During the March 2014 episode, some real-time monitoring indices reportedly ranked Paris briefly among the most polluted major cities on the planet. Claims that it was simply “the most polluted city in the world” overstate the case, since cities in South and East Asia regularly record far higher levels, but the episodes made air quality a political priority.

A common claim at the time was that French drivers face no emissions checks. That is not accurate. France’s mandatory roadworthiness inspection, the contrôle technique, has been required since 1992: cars are first tested after four years and then every two years, and the test includes a pollution check. The real issue in Paris was the sheer volume of traffic and the high share of diesel vehicles, which emit more nitrogen oxides.

From one day to a monthly habit

After the 2015 success, the city expanded the idea in two ways:

  • The annual car-free day continued. Paris kept holding a large Journée sans voiture each autumn, and later editions reportedly extended the closure much further across the city.
  • Paris Respire (“Paris breathes”). From May 2016, the Champs-Élysées and the historic central districts (the 1st to 4th arrondissements) began closing to motor traffic on the first Sunday of every month. Other neighbourhoods, including the Seine riverbanks, the Marais, Canal Saint-Martin and Montmartre, close on Sundays and public holidays. Buses, taxis and deliveries may enter at no more than 20 km/h, while walkers and cyclists have the streets to themselves, typically from 10 am to 6 pm.

Rules and timetables change over time, so anyone planning a visit should check the City of Paris website for the current programme.

The bigger picture: car-free days around the world

Paris did not invent the idea. Denmark and Switzerland held car-free Sundays during the 1973–74 oil crisis, and Tel Aviv has gone largely car-free on Yom Kippur since 1935. In the 1990s campaigners promoted car-free days as a way to rethink urban transport, and France’s own En ville, sans ma voiture? programme began in 1998 with 34 cities. Since 2000, 22 September has been marked as World Car-Free Day, now part of the European Commission’s European Mobility Week.

The lesson from these experiments is consistent. A single day without cars is too short to change long-term pollution averages, but it shows residents what is possible and builds support for permanent changes. Paris went on to pedestrianise the right bank of the Seine, add hundreds of kilometres of cycle lanes and restrict the oldest, most polluting vehicles.

Myths and facts about car-free days

Myth: “Each car-free day cuts pollution by 40%.” The 2015 measurements showed falls of up to about 40% in nitrogen dioxide at some central stations, with smaller drops elsewhere and some increases on diversion routes.

Myth: “Car-free days solve air pollution.” They give a short break and a powerful demonstration. Lasting improvement depends on everyday measures such as cleaner vehicles, better public transport and safe cycling routes.

Fact: the benefits go beyond air. Quieter streets, more space for walking and play, and fewer road dangers are what many residents remember most.

Would your city benefit from a monthly day without cars? The Paris experience suggests the first one is the hardest to organise, and the easiest to love.

Sources: Airparif press release on 27 September 2015; road.cc on the first Paris car-free day; Wikipedia: Paris Respire; Wikipedia: Car-free day; Wikipedia: Vehicle inspection; story first reported by Brianna Acuesta for True Activist.

COMMENTS