Is a Messy Desk a Sign of Creativity? What the Research Says

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2016-04-02.

Is a Messy Desk a Sign of Creativity? What the Research Says

"If a cluttered desk is a sign of a cluttered mind, of what, then, is an empty desk a sign?" The quip is often attributed to Albert Einstein, but there is no evidence he said it.

Can a messy desk be a sign of creativity? Research suggests a modest yes, with an important twist. In a well-known set of experiments at the University of Minnesota, people working in a messy room came up with more creative ideas than people in a tidy one. But the same research found that tidy rooms nudged people towards generosity and healthier choices. Mess is not a measure of intelligence, and tidiness is not a sign of a dull mind. Different surroundings seem to encourage different kinds of thinking.

The Minnesota messy-room experiments

The study most often quoted in this debate was led by psychologist Kathleen Vohs of the University of Minnesota's Carlson School of Management and published in the journal Psychological Science in 2013. Her team set up two rooms: one neat, the other strewn with papers and books.

  • Creativity. Asked to think up new uses for ping-pong balls, people in both rooms produced about the same number of ideas. Independent judges, however, rated the ideas from the messy room as significantly more creative.
  • Generosity and self-control. In another experiment, 82% of people in the tidy room donated to charity, against 47% in the messy room. Offered a snack on the way out, 67% of the tidy-room group chose an apple over a chocolate bar, compared with 20% of the messy-room group.
  • Novelty. In a third experiment, people choosing a health add-on for a smoothie more often picked the option labelled "classic" in a neat room, and the one labelled "new" in a messy room.

Vohs's interpretation was that orderly settings encourage people to follow convention and do the expected "right" thing, while disorderly ones free them to break with tradition. Neither is better in every situation.

What the research does not show

It is tempting to read these findings as proof that messy people are smarter. They are not. The experiments placed randomly chosen volunteers in a room for a short time; they did not compare the intelligence of naturally messy and naturally tidy people. The groups were also fairly small, from a few dozen to under 200 participants per experiment, and psychology has learned in recent years that striking single studies do not always replicate.

So the fair conclusion is narrow: a disordered environment may, for a while, help some people think less conventionally. It says nothing about IQ, and nothing about whether living in chaos is good for you in the long run.

What creative people are really like

Psychologist Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi, best known for his work on "flow", interviewed scores of highly creative people for his research. In a 1996 article for Psychology Today, he argued that what sets them apart is complexity: they combine traits that usually pull in opposite directions.

He described creative people as both playful and disciplined, both imaginative and grounded in reality, both proud and humble, and able to switch between energy and rest. He also noted that beyond a certain level, a higher IQ does not seem to predict greater creativity. Read this way, a messy desk might sit comfortably alongside a very orderly approach to the work itself.

Crowded cities, crowded minds

A popular argument links mental clutter to the way cities generate ideas. Writer Eric Barker, in a piece for Time, drew on Steven Johnson's book Where Good Ideas Come From: The Natural History Of Innovation to suggest that a busy, cross-connected mind works like a big city, where more people and more chance encounters produce more breakthroughs.

The city part has real research behind it. Studies by physicist Geoffrey West, Luís Bettencourt and colleagues found that measures of invention, such as patents, tend to grow faster than population: a city ten times bigger produces more than ten times as many patents. Johnson's figures, in which a city ten times larger is 17 times more innovative, appear to draw on this line of work. Statisticians have since debated how such scaling should be measured, and the jump from cities to individual brains is a metaphor rather than a finding.

Johnson's practical advice is more useful than the metaphor. He suggests keeping several projects or hobbies going at once, because ideas from one field often solve problems in another. That kind of productive overlap can look untidy from the outside.

A note on a discredited source

Older articles on this topic often cite Jonah Lehrer's 2012 book Imagine: How Creativity Works, which argued that debate and criticism stimulate ideas. Readers should treat it with caution. In July 2012 its publisher, Houghton Mifflin, recalled the book after Lehrer admitted inventing quotes attributed to Bob Dylan, and further problems with quotations were later reported. The idea that constructive disagreement helps groups think is supported elsewhere, but this book is not a reliable source for it.

When clutter helps, and when it hurts

Clutter is not always harmless. Other research has linked chronically cluttered homes with higher stress and with difficulty concentrating, and a desk on which nothing can be found costs time. Severe, distressing accumulation of possessions can be a sign of hoarding disorder, which is a health condition rather than a personality quirk; anyone worried about that should talk to a doctor.

Some practical ways to get the benefits of both worlds:

  • Match the space to the task. Keep a looser, idea-rich space for brainstorming and a clear one for focused or routine work.
  • Tidy what you need to find. Bills, documents and tools you use daily deserve a fixed place, even if inspiration piles are allowed to grow.
  • Respect shared spaces. Your creative mess may be someone else's stress, so agree on rules for kitchens, offices and common rooms.
  • Notice your own pattern. If a cleared desk calms you and helps you start, that matters more than any study average.

The bottom line

If your workspace is a jumble of notes, sketches and books, you are in good company, and there is some evidence it may help you think in fresh ways. Vohs herself observed of the reaction to her work: "I think it makes people feel vindicated." Just remember that the same studies found benefits in order too. The best environment is the one that suits what you are trying to do today.

Sources: APA Monitor on Psychology, October 2013 (Kathleen Vohs); Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi, Psychology Today; Quote Investigator: the cluttered desk quip; Wikipedia: Urban scaling; Wikipedia: Imagine: How Creativity Works.

COMMENTS