Why We Mature Through Hardship, Not Just Age

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Why We Don’t Mature With Age, We Mature Through Hardship

I want to be wise. And you know how you get wise? By screwing up. — Myra McEntire, young adult novelist

Getting older does not guarantee growing up. Plenty of people reach forty with the emotional habits of a teenager, while some twenty-year-olds handle life with remarkable steadiness. The difference is rarely the number of birthdays. It is usually what a person has been through, and what they did with it. Disappointment, loss, failure and being let down by others are the experiences that tend to build patience, humility and empathy.

That is the argument writer Lauren Martin made in a widely shared Elite Daily essay, built on a list of seven marks of maturity from leadership author Tim Elmore. Here is that idea explained, with what psychology research adds and a few honest caveats.

Age or hardship: what actually makes us mature?

Most of us grew up hearing "you'll understand when you're older". Usually what the speaker meant was something closer to "you'll understand once it has happened to you." Time matters mostly because it gives life more chances to test us.

Age and hardship are tangled together. The longer we live, the more likely we are to face breakups, money worries, illness, grief or our own mistakes. But two people of the same age can come out of similar years very differently. One becomes bitter and guarded; the other becomes kinder and wiser. Maturity seems to depend less on the event than on whether we reflect on it, take responsibility for our part, and let it change how we treat others.

Tim Elmore's seven marks of maturity

Tim Elmore, founder of the nonprofit Growing Leaders, wrote a Psychology Today post on the marks of maturity, aimed mainly at parents, teachers and coaches of young people aged roughly 16 to 24. He argued that many in that group seem advanced intellectually but behind emotionally. His seven marks are that a mature person:

  1. keeps long-term commitments after the excitement fades;
  2. stays steady under both praise and criticism;
  3. has a humble spirit;
  4. makes decisions from character and principle rather than mood;
  5. shows gratitude regularly;
  6. can put other people's needs ahead of their own;
  7. looks for wise counsel before acting.

Elmore framed these as goals adults can help young people grow into. Martin's twist was to ask where each trait really comes from, and her answer, in almost every case, was a painful lesson.

Commitment and a thicker skin

Keeping your word, because you have been let down

Few lessons teach reliability like being stood up. Once you have waited at a restaurant for a friend who never showed, or rearranged your week for plans that were cancelled at the last minute, you understand what flaking costs other people. Many adults become better at following through not because they were lectured, but because they remember how it felt. The practical takeaway: if you said yes, show up, even when the couch is calling.

Staying steady, because flattery has fooled you before

People who have been charmed and then deceived, by a partner, a boss or a "friend," learn to look past smooth words. One painful betrayal can teach that not every compliment is sincere and not every critic is an enemy. Mature people still enjoy praise and still listen to criticism, but neither knocks them off balance, because their sense of worth no longer depends on other people's verdicts.

Humility and character

Humility, because life has knocked you down

Arrogance is easy when nothing has gone wrong yet. A failed business, a public mistake, a health scare or a long stretch of bad luck tends to strip that away. People who have lived through dark periods often become the gentlest guides for others, because they remember being lost. Humility in this sense is not low self-esteem; it is an accurate view of how fragile everyone's fortunes are.

Character, because you did hard things anyway

Character is built from choices made when feelings point the other way: keeping a promise you regret, telling an uncomfortable truth, caring for a sick parent when you are exhausted. Each of those moments adds a layer. Over time, decisions start to come from values rather than from whatever mood you woke up in, which is exactly what Elmore's fourth mark describes.

Gratitude, empathy and wisdom

Gratitude, because you have needed help

It is hard to appreciate a favour you have never needed. People who have had to ask for a loan, a lift, a place to stay or simply a listening ear tend to say thank you more often and mean it more deeply. Having been on the receiving end makes kindness feel less like an obligation and more like a gift.

Empathy, because you have been overlooked

Being treated as an afterthought, whether passed over at work, ignored by a parent or left out by friends, is painful. Many people who have felt that sting become determined never to make others feel the same way. Having stood in uncomfortable shoes makes it easier to imagine how someone else feels, and harder to trample them.

Wisdom, because you remember your mistakes

Some of the hardest lessons come from pain we caused ourselves through naivety, impatience or poor judgement. Mature people can admit that. After a few self-inflicted disasters, they build habits that slow them down: sleeping on big decisions, asking someone they trust, reading the fine print. That pause before acting is often the clearest sign that someone has learned from experience.

What psychology says about growing through hard times

Researchers have a name for this pattern: post-traumatic growth. Psychologists Richard Tedeschi and Lawrence Calhoun of the University of North Carolina at Charlotte introduced the term in the 1990s, along with a questionnaire, the Posttraumatic Growth Inventory, published in 1996. They described growth in five areas: closer relationships, new possibilities, a sense of personal strength, spiritual change and a deeper appreciation of life.

The research comes with important caveats, and they matter for anyone tempted to romanticise suffering:

  • Growth comes from the struggle, not the event. Tedeschi and Calhoun stress that it is the effort to make sense of a new reality, not the trauma itself, that produces change.
  • Growth and distress can coexist. Many people who report growth still carry pain, anxiety or post-traumatic stress.
  • Some reported growth may be partly a coping story. Researchers have questioned how reliable self-reported growth is, and some argue that perceived growth can be partly self-protective.
  • Very severe trauma can overwhelm people rather than strengthen them, especially without support.

Put honestly, the idea comes down to this: hardship does not automatically make anyone wiser, but it gives us material to grow from, if we have the time, reflection and support to work through it.

How to grow from difficulty without seeking it out

Nobody needs to go looking for pain in order to mature. Life supplies enough of it. What helps is how we respond when it arrives:

  • Reflect on purpose. Journaling or talking through a setback with a friend helps turn a raw experience into a lesson.
  • Own your part, without self-punishment. Ask what you could do differently next time, then let the rest go.
  • Lean on people. Asking for help is not weakness; it is often where gratitude and empathy begin.
  • Learn from other people's hardships. Listening carefully to friends, parents and grandparents lets you gain some wisdom without paying the full price yourself.
  • Get support when it is heavy. If a loss or trauma is affecting your sleep, work or relationships for weeks, talk to a doctor or a mental health professional.

Maturity, in the end, is less about how many years you have lived and more about what you let those years teach you.

Sources: original essay by Lauren Martin, Elite Daily; Tim Elmore, "The Marks of Maturity," Psychology Today; Wikipedia: Posttraumatic growth.

COMMENTS