Meghalaya’s Matrilineal Khasi Society and the Men Who Want Change

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2016-02-01.

Meghalaya’s Matrilineal Khasi Society and the Men Who Want Change
Khasi and Jaintia women in Meghalaya. Photo: Subhamoy Bhattacharjee / Al Jazeera

In Meghalaya, a small hill state in northeast India, family names and ancestral property pass down through women rather than men. Among the Khasi, the largest community in the state, children traditionally take their mother's clan name, and the youngest daughter inherits the family home and the duty to care for her parents. This makes the Khasi, along with the neighbouring Jaintia and Garo, one of the best-known matrilineal societies in the world.

It does not make Meghalaya a land ruled by women. Village councils have long been run by men, and only a handful of women sit in the state assembly. A small group of Khasi men has even campaigned to change the system, saying it leaves them without a place of their own. Here is how matriliny works, where power really sits, and why the debate is more balanced than the "woman's world" headlines suggest.

Meghalaya and its matrilineal peoples

Meghalaya means "abode of the clouds" in Sanskrit, a fitting name for a state that includes Cherrapunji (Sohra) and Mawsynram, two of the rainiest places on Earth. It was carved out of Assam in January 1972, and its capital, Shillong, is a lively centre for education, music and fashion in the region.

Roughly three million people live in the state, most of them from three indigenous groups. The Khasi, who number around 1.4 million in India, live mainly in the central and eastern hills. The Jaintia, also called Pnar, are closely related to them. The Garo live in the western hills. All three trace descent through the mother's line, though the details differ. Most Khasi today are Christian, while a significant minority follow the indigenous faith Ka Niam Khasi.

How the Khasi system works in daily life

At the centre of the Khasi family is the khadduh, the youngest daughter. She inherits the ancestral house and property, but the inheritance comes with obligations. She is expected to look after ageing parents, take in unmarried or divorced siblings, and keep the family home open for clan gatherings and rituals. In practice she acts more like a custodian of the clan's property than a private owner.

A few other customs follow from this:

  • Names: children traditionally belong to their mother's clan, or kur, and take its name. Marriage within one's own clan is forbidden.
  • Where couples live: when a man marries the youngest daughter, he usually moves into her family's home. If his wife is not the heiress, the couple often sets up a separate household.
  • Daughters are welcomed: because the line continues through women, the birth of a girl is widely celebrated. Families without daughters have traditionally adopted a girl or named a female relative as heir, according to reports from the region.
  • Simpler marriage and separation: many accounts describe Khasi marriage as relatively informal, with partners chosen freely and separation carrying little stigma for women.

The Garo system works in a similar way. The heiress, called nokna, is usually the youngest daughter, though parents can choose another daughter instead.

Tracing descent through women does not settle every question of power
Khasi women with children in Shillong. Photo: Subhamoy Bhattacharjee / Al Jazeera

Matrilineal is not the same as matriarchal

This is the point most often lost. Matrilineal describes how descent and property are passed on. Matriarchal would mean that women hold political authority. Meghalaya is the first, not the second.

Traditionally the mother's brother, the maternal uncle, carried great weight in family decisions, managing property and settling disputes. Fathers had less formal standing in their children's clan, but they were far from powerless.

Public life has stayed strongly male. The dorbar shnong, the village council that handles local affairs, is led by a headman. Women may attend, but by custom they could not hold executive posts or become headman, and were usually represented by husbands, brothers or uncles. When Al Jazeera reported from Shillong in 2013, only four of the 60 members of the state assembly were women.

Patricia Mukhim, editor of The Shillong Times and a well-known social activist, has argued that many women see politics as a male domain and hesitate to stand. Others point out that women's strong economic role, in trade, markets and household finances, has not automatically translated into political seats.

The men who want change

In 1990 a group of Khasi men founded Syngkhong Rympei Thymmai (SRT), an organisation that wants a larger role for men within the family system, including inheritance through fathers. Its founder, Keith Pariat, told Al Jazeera the group had about 3,000 members, most of whom kept a low profile.

Pariat's complaint, repeated in interviews with several outlets, was that a husband living in his wife's family home can feel like an outsider with no claim on it, while his own sister's household no longer has room for him. In one widely quoted line he said:

“She gives the orders and you become a good-for-nothing servant.” (Keith Pariat, on life in a mother-in-law's house)

Some researchers have described related concerns. A study by Kyansai Warjri on Khasi parent-child relations, as reported by India Today, suggested that boys sometimes receive less attention than girls in education and family investment, which may affect ambition. These are individual studies and opinions, though, not settled findings about all Khasi men.

Tracing descent through women does not settle every question of power
Khasi women selling fruit at a market in Shillong. Photo: Subhamoy Bhattacharjee / Al Jazeera

Why most Khasi defend the system

SRT has remained a minority voice. Mukhim dismissed the group as a "bunch of disgruntled individuals", and many Khasi women say matriliny protects them. Because children belong to the mother's clan, a woman who separates, remarries or has a child outside marriage does not lose her home or her children's identity, a security that women in many patrilineal communities lack.

C. Joshua Thomas of the Indian Council of Social Science Research told Al Jazeera he expected the system to endure, since it is defended by the indigenous religion, the churches and civil society groups alike. Change does happen, but gradually: many families now divide property among several children, and urban couples increasingly live on their own.

Common myths about Meghalaya's “women's world”

Myth: women rule Meghalaya. Women hold family property and enjoy social freedoms that are rare elsewhere in India, but village councils and state politics have long been male-dominated.

Myth: the system is thousands of years old and unchanged. Its exact age is unknown, and it has adapted over time, including through Christian missions, Indian law and urbanisation.

Myth: men have no role. Maternal uncles have traditionally held real authority, and fathers today play a growing part in family decisions.

What the rest of the world can take from it

Meghalaya is a useful reminder that there is more than one way to organise families, property and belonging. It shows that a society can welcome daughters as warmly as sons, protect women after divorce, and still struggle with balance in public life. The debate inside the state is not between oppressed men and powerful women. It is a conversation about how an old system can give every member, son or daughter, a secure place.

Sources: Subir Bhaumik, Meghalaya: Where women call the shots, Al Jazeera (2013); Wikipedia: Khasi people; Wikipedia: Meghalaya. Photos: Subhamoy Bhattacharjee / Al Jazeera.

COMMENTS