
Some psychology experiments have become famous because they seem to reveal uncomfortable truths about us: that we obey authority too readily, miss obvious changes in front of our eyes, rewrite our own opinions to feel consistent, and find happiness mostly through other people. Five studies in particular are often used to make these points: the Stanford Prison Experiment, the “door” study on change blindness, Milgram’s obedience experiments, the Harvard Grant Study and Festinger’s research on cognitive dissonance.
Each one does teach something real, but several are more complicated than the popular versions suggest. Below is what each study did, what it found, and how far its lessons can be trusted.
The Stanford Prison Experiment (1971)
In August 1971 the psychologist Philip Zimbardo turned a basement corridor of Stanford University’s psychology building into a mock prison. Seventy-five young men answered a newspaper advert offering $15 a day; 24 were selected after screening for good physical and mental health. They were randomly assigned to be guards or prisoners, with nine of each taking part at a time and the rest held in reserve. The study was planned to last two weeks.
It was stopped on the sixth day. Guards had become increasingly harsh and humiliating towards prisoners, and several prisoners showed signs of distress. A visiting psychologist, Christina Maslach, challenged Zimbardo about what she saw, and that confrontation helped bring the study to an end. For decades the experiment was taught as proof that ordinary people quickly become cruel when placed in a powerful role.
The catch: later investigations have seriously weakened that interpretation. Recordings show the warden urging a guard to be tougher, and the French researcher Thibault Le Texier, who studied the archives, argued in 2018 and 2019 that the guards were steered towards hostile behaviour. Critics have also pointed out that participants may simply have acted out what they thought the researchers wanted. When Alex Haslam and Stephen Reicher ran a partial recreation for the BBC in 2002, guards did not drift into brutality in the same way. The safer lesson is that situations, leadership and expectations all shape behaviour, not that cruelty switches on automatically.
The door study and change blindness (1998)
Daniel Simons and Daniel Levin set up a simple test on a university campus. A researcher holding a map stopped a pedestrian to ask for directions. Partway through the conversation, two men carrying a large wooden door walked between them. Behind the door, the first researcher swapped places with a second person who looked and sounded different, and who then carried on the conversation.
Only about half of the pedestrians noticed they were now talking to someone else. In a follow-up, the researchers found that people were more likely to miss the switch when the person asking was from a different social group, for example someone dressed as a construction worker approaching students.
This is called change blindness: we notice much less of the world than we think, because the brain keeps the overall meaning of a scene and fills in the details. Related studies have found that most people confidently predict they would spot changes in film clips, while only a small share actually do. The practical point is humbling. Your sense of having “seen everything” is not proof that you did, which matters for eyewitness memory, driving and any task where attention is divided.
Milgram’s obedience experiments (1961–1962)
Stanley Milgram began his experiments at Yale University in August 1961, a few months after the trial of the Nazi organiser Adolf Eichmann opened in Jerusalem. He wanted to know how far ordinary people would go when an authority figure told them to harm someone.
Volunteers were told they were taking part in a study on learning. Acting as “teacher”, each one was asked to give electric shocks of rising strength to a “learner” in the next room whenever he made a mistake. The learner was an actor and no real shocks were given, but the volunteers believed they were. When they hesitated, the experimenter responded with calm, scripted prompts to continue. In the best-known version, 26 of 40 participants, or 65 per cent, went all the way to the switch marked 450 volts, and every one of them reached 300 volts.
The catch: obedience changed a great deal with the setting. When the learner sat in the same room, it fell to 40 per cent; when instructions came by telephone, to about 21 per cent. The writer Gina Perry found in the archives that many participants doubted the set-up was real, and Haslam and Reicher have argued that people continued because they identified with the scientific goal, not out of blind obedience. A partial replication by Jerry Burger in 2009, stopping at a lower voltage for ethical reasons, still found rates similar to Milgram’s.
The Harvard Grant Study (1938 to today)
Begun in 1938, the Grant Study followed 268 men who had studied at Harvard, mostly from the classes of 1942 to 1944, for the rest of their lives. They were assessed about every two years through questionnaires, interviews and medical information. A parallel study followed 456 young men from poor neighbourhoods in Boston. Among the Harvard participants was a future president, John F. Kennedy. The psychiatrist George Vaillant led the research for more than three decades, and it continues today under Robert Waldinger as part of the Harvard Study of Adult Development.
The strongest finding is about relationships. Men with warm close relationships tended to be healthier and happier as they aged; those who were most satisfied in their relationships at 50 were, on average, the healthiest at 80. Alcohol misuse emerged as a leading cause of divorce and, with smoking, of early illness and death. Vaillant is widely quoted as summing up the results with the idea that happiness is love, and accounts of the study often describe cases of men who struggled badly when young but built good lives through connection later on.
The catch: the original sample was entirely male, white and American, so the findings needed confirming in other groups, which later research has broadly done for the importance of social connection.
Cognitive dissonance: the $1 experiment (1959)
In 1957 Leon Festinger proposed that people feel uncomfortable when their beliefs and actions clash, and are motivated to reduce that discomfort, often by changing a belief. Two years later he and James Carlsmith tested it. Students spent an hour on deliberately boring tasks such as turning pegs a quarter turn, then were asked to tell the next participant that the work had been interesting. Some were paid $1 for this, others $20, and a control group was not asked to say anything.
Afterwards, those paid only $1 rated the tasks as more enjoyable than those paid $20. The explanation: $20 was enough to justify the white lie, but $1 was not, so the low-paid group eased the conflict by deciding the task was not so bad after all.
Dissonance is a feeling of tension, not an inability to cope with mixed thoughts. Daryl Bem later offered an alternative explanation, self-perception theory, which says we infer our attitudes from our own behaviour much as an observer would. Both ideas still have support, and the effect helps explain everyday habits such as defending a purchase we regret or talking ourselves into a choice we have already made.
What these studies really tell us
Together, the five studies make a reasonable case that we are less independent, less observant and less consistent than we like to believe, and that relationships matter more to well-being than achievements or money. They also show how science corrects itself. Some famous conclusions have been softened as researchers reopened archives, ran replications and asked whether participants were acting, doubting or trying to help the experimenter.
A few practical habits follow from this:
- Question instructions that feel wrong, even from someone in charge, and notice how much easier that is when others around you object too.
- Do not trust a confident memory as proof that you noticed everything, especially when you were busy or distracted.
- Watch for self-justification after a decision. Ask whether you still believe something, or just want to feel consistent.
- Invest in people. Of all the findings here, the value of close relationships is the most consistently supported.
Sources: Wikipedia: Stanford prison experiment | ScienceAlert / The Conversation: The famous 1971 prison experiment wasn’t what most of us thought (January 2025) | Simons & Levin (1998), Failure to detect changes to people during a real-world interaction, Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 5(4) | APA Monitor: change blindness research (October 2006) | Wikipedia: Milgram experiment | Wikipedia: Grant Study | Wikipedia: Cognitive dissonance | Learning Mind: original list. Header art by Cameron Gray.
Related:- 5 Psychological Experiments That Show Humanity’s Dark Side
- Szondi Test With Pictures That Will Reveal Your Deepest Hidden Self
- Psychoanalyze Yourself Test
- The Experiment: Separating a Circulating Story From Research
- A Paris Video Contrasts Responses to Two Outfits
- What Can You Learn From a Banana? An Illustrated Prompt
- A Chimpanzee Task Video and the Interpretation of Its Outcome
- A Monkey Reward Experiment and the Response to Unequal Outcomes
- 20 Psychological Life Hacks that Will Help You Gain the Advantage in Social Situations
- Why It’s Important To Understand Your Dark Side
- ActionAid Hellas’s Staged Racist Incident and the Bystanders’ Responses

Watch the movie "The Experiment" based on the Stanford Prison experiment.
ReplyDeleteI appreciate that you gave me a movie name.
Deleteit is merely awesome!
ReplyDelete