Originally published 2018-03-18.
In late September 2015, an anonymous post appeared in the Missed Connections section of Boston Craigslist under the heading "I met you in the rain on the last day of 1972". Written by a man describing himself as an elderly Vietnam veteran, it told how a brief encounter with a stranger on New Year's Eve 1972 stopped him from ending his life. Within days it had been shared around the world. The writer was never identified, and journalists soon raised doubts about whether the story was literally true. It still resonates, because of what it says about guilt, chance and the lasting effect of one kind conversation.

Content note: this story describes suicidal thoughts. If you are struggling, support is listed at the end of this article.
The story the ad told
The writer said he had returned from bombing missions over Hanoi only a week earlier, at the end of the American air campaign of December 1972. He described himself as overwhelmed by shame for the people who must have died beneath his bombs, discharged with honours he felt he did not deserve, and drinking alone in a bare apartment in Boston's Back Bay. That morning, he wrote, he had decided that he would take his own life when he got home.
Instead he walked for hours through the city: past the Fenway, Symphony Hall and Trinity Church, across the Common and Beacon Hill, through the North End and down to the waterfront. When the rain turned into a downpour, he kept walking while everyone else ran for cover.
On his way back he noticed a young woman sheltering under the balcony of the Old State House. She was in a teal ball gown, soaked, freckled and clearly upset. He asked if she was all right and offered to buy her coffee. She grabbed his hand and ran with him to Neisner's, a five-and-dime lunch counter nearby.
Over pie and coffee they talked like old friends. She told him she was engaged to a wealthy man she did not love and was meant to be at his family's New Year's party. He did not mention the war, but felt she sensed his inner turmoil without pitying him. When he returned from the restroom, having resolved that he wanted to live and to see where the evening might lead, she was gone. No note, no number.
Why he wrote it 42 years later
The writer said he went back to Neisner's every day for a year without seeing her again. The mystery of her disappearance, he explained, slowly replaced his urge to die with a need to know what had happened. Decades later, after telling the story for the first time to a friend from the Veterans of Foreign Wars, he was persuaded by that friend's daughter to try Craigslist.
The ad did not ask the woman to get in touch. It was a thank-you. He described the life that followed: marriage to a woman he loved, raising a son, travelling and, eventually, forgiving himself. He also wrote about grief, having lost both his wife and his son in recent years, and about still smelling the smoke over Hanoi on bad days. Rainy days, he said, became a gift that brought her back to mind. His conclusion was that "our connection wasn't missed at all", and he ended by telling her that "you're with me still."
Is the 1972 Craigslist story true?
Nobody knows, and the honest answer is that it is probably at least partly fiction. Some of the details do check out. Boston magazine found weather records showing it did rain in Boston on New Year's Eve 1972, and Neisner's did have a store at Washington and Bromfield streets; the chain filed for bankruptcy in December 1977. The places on his walk are real and roughly follow a plausible route.
Other details raised eyebrows. A commenter on the local news site Universal Hub pointed out that the name "Downtown Crossing" was not in use until about six years later, although a writer looking back could easily use the modern name. The military blogger Thomas Wictor argued that the description of the B-52 missions did not match how those crews and aircraft operated. Boston magazine's own verdict was that the ad was most likely not real, while noting that few readers seemed to mind.
So the fairest way to read it is as a moving piece of writing, possibly drawn from real experience, possibly invented, rather than as verified testimony from a named veteran.
The history behind the backstory
The bombing the writer refers to was Operation Linebacker II, the US air campaign against North Vietnam from 18 to 29 December 1972, often called the "Christmas bombings". President Richard Nixon ordered it to push Hanoi back to peace talks. Over eleven days, with a pause at Christmas, B-52 bombers flew 741 sorties against targets around Hanoi and Haiphong. Fifteen B-52s were officially recorded as shot down, and dozens of American airmen were killed, captured or missing. North Vietnamese sources reported around 1,600 civilian deaths.
Days later, on 30 December, Nixon halted the bombing north of the 20th parallel, and the Paris Peace Accords were signed on 27 January 1973. Historians still debate how much the bombing changed the outcome. For many who took part, as for the writer of the ad, the moral weight of those missions lasted far longer than the campaign itself. Veterans' struggles with guilt and what is now often called moral injury are well documented, which is one reason the story felt believable to so many readers.
Why the story touched so many readers
Part of the appeal is the old-fashioned romance: a ball gown in the rain, a lunch counter, a woman who vanishes. But the deeper pull is the idea that an ordinary act, sitting with a stranger and listening without judgement, can change the direction of someone's life without either person realising it at the time. Neither of them, in the story, knew the other's full situation. She was having her own bad night.
It is also a story about self-forgiveness. The writer does not claim the war was erased or that grief disappeared. He describes a life that held both joy and pain, and gratitude for having stayed to live it.
When someone is in crisis
A stranger's kindness can matter enormously, but real-life recovery from suicidal feelings usually needs more than one conversation. The US National Institute of Mental Health suggests five simple steps if you are worried about someone: ask them directly whether they are thinking about suicide, be there and listen without judgement, help keep them safe by reducing access to dangerous items, help them connect with ongoing support, and follow up afterwards. Asking directly does not put the idea in someone's head.
If you or someone you know is struggling, please reach out to someone you trust or to a professional. In the United States you can call or text 988 to reach the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline; elsewhere, contact your local emergency number or a national helpline. Talking to a doctor is also a good first step.
Sources: Boston Magazine, 5 October 2015: The Boston of that heartbreaking Craigslist "Missed Connections" ad, in pictures; Wikipedia: Operation Linebacker II; NIMH: 5 Action Steps to Help Someone Having Thoughts of Suicide. Original text: an anonymous Boston Craigslist Missed Connections post (2015), shared via Sunny Skyz and Idealist Revolution.

never forget those magical moments... and for all of us... we may be angels, unaware....
ReplyDeleteThat a message for you when you're on the edge of killin your self. It was a sign that stop you from doing what you we're thinkin that day and time. Well what can I say much. It's a good story.
ReplyDeleteWhy you think that she was a human? In Jewish and Muslim culture there is a being called Hizir and he has several stories that he travels with Moses. This being is mostly male but he can take any shape of a living being. He can be a dog, a woman, a child and he only appears in emergency situations. In your case considering suicide. He saves you and as he appears he suddenly disappears. Several of us have numerous strange encounters with him which are very hard to explain by logic.
ReplyDeleteit happen to me....when you think everything is lost....boom magic happen
ReplyDeletelife is beautifully cruel and sweet...you chose the ingredient do make it taste better!!!!