Mark Gungor's Tale of Two Brains: Men, Women and the Nothing Box

Mark Gungor’s routine about men’s and women’s brains is one of the most shared marriage talks online. Its core idea is easy to remember: men keep everything in separate boxes, including a box with nothing in it, while for women everything is connected to everything else. Here is who Gungor is, what the “Tale of Two Brains” actually says, and how it compares with what psychologists have found.

Who is Mark Gungor?

Gungor is the senior pastor of Celebration Church, based in Green Bay, Wisconsin, and head of Laugh Your Way America, the organisation behind his seminar Laugh Your Way to a Better Marriage. In 2014 the Christian Post reported that he was giving the four-part seminar about 30 times a year, drawing on four decades of his own marriage, and that his online talks had been viewed by millions. The same year he was invited to entertain guests at a party during the Cannes Film Festival.

His audience is unusually broad. Besides churches and community events, the seminar has been shown at U.S. Army “Strong Bonds” retreats for military couples, where the humour helps people talk about tensions they might otherwise avoid.

The Tale of Two Brains in brief

“A Tale of Two Brains” is the opening session of the seminar. As summarised in a 2014 U.S. Army report on a couples’ retreat, it runs like this:

• Men’s brains are made of boxes. Work, the car, the kids and the wife each sit in a separate box, and the boxes do not touch. A man opens one, deals with it, closes it and moves on.
• There is a “nothing box”. After a long day, a man may retreat into a box where he is thinking about, quite literally, nothing, which is how he rests.
• Women’s brains are a web. Everything links to everything else, which makes them strong multitaskers and means emotions and memories travel quickly between topics.
• The friction. When a husband withdraws into his nothing box, his wife may read it as indifference. When she connects one issue to five others, he may feel ambushed.

Delivered with Gungor’s timing, it gets big laughs because many couples recognise a scene from their own kitchen.

What research says about male and female minds

The boxes-versus-web picture is a comic exaggeration, and it should be enjoyed as one. Research on psychological differences between the sexes tells a more modest story. In 2005 psychologist Janet Shibley Hyde published the “gender similarities hypothesis” in American Psychologist. Pulling together many meta-analyses, she found that men and women are similar on most psychological measures, and that the differences people expect are often much larger than the ones studies actually find.

In practice, the variation within each sex is wide. Plenty of women love an empty-headed hour in front of the TV, and plenty of men find it hard to switch off. Treating the routine as a scientific map of the brain can turn a funny observation into a stereotype that excuses bad listening.

Why the routine still helps couples

The talk works best not as biology but as a shared language. Couples who have watched it can say “I’m in my nothing box” or “this is all connected for me” and be understood without an argument. Humour lowers defences, which is exactly why marriage educators use it.

A few takeaways hold up whatever your gender:

• People recharge differently. Say what you need, whether it is quiet time or a conversation, instead of expecting your partner to guess.
• When your partner goes silent, ask before assuming it means anger or indifference.
• Some people need to handle one issue at a time; others need to talk through how things connect. Agree on which conversation you are having.
• Laughing at your own habits is easier than defending them.

Watching it with the right expectations

Gungor is a pastor and a comedian, not a neuroscientist, and his material is built on broad generalisations. Taken that way, the Tale of Two Brains is a light, often accurate sketch of how two particular people can misunderstand each other, and a good way to start a conversation at home.

Sources: U.S. Army: Strong Bonds retreat, Feb 2014; The Christian Post, May 2014; Janet Shibley Hyde, Wikipedia; Idealist Revolution (image).

• Men-and-Women Memes: Familiar Stereotypes Played for Laughs