
Soviet soldiers raise the Victory Banner over the Reichstag, Berlin, May 1945. Photo: Yevgeny Khaldei / RIA Novosti.
Most people in France, Germany and Britain do not see the Soviet Union as the main liberator of Europe in the Second World War. In a 2015 survey of just over 3,000 adults in those three countries, 43% named the US Army as the force that played the main role, while only 13% chose the Soviet Red Army. Historians would answer the same question very differently, because the war against Nazi Germany was decided above all on the Eastern Front, with American and British power essential in the West, at sea and in the air.
Below is what the poll asked, how the answers split by country, why public memory and military history drifted apart, and which facts about 1945 are often told wrongly.
What the 2015 poll found
The survey was run by the British polling firm ICM Research between 20 March and 9 April 2015, a few weeks before the 70th anniversary of Victory in Europe. It was commissioned by Sputnik, the Russian state-owned news agency, and its results were published by Russian state media. That background matters: the question was framed in a way that invited a single winner, and the people paying for it had an obvious interest in showing that Western publics underrate the Soviet contribution.
Still, the numbers themselves are striking. Respondents were asked which army played the main role in liberating Europe from Nazism:
- France: more than 61% named the Americans, and just 8% the Soviets.
- Germany: more than half named the Americans, and 13% the Soviets.
- Britain: close to half picked British forces, ahead of either the US or the USSR.
Across all three countries, the US came first with 43% and the Red Army scored 13%. The British answer is a good reminder that every nation tends to remember the war from its own front line.
Why the Eastern Front decided the war
From the German invasion of the Soviet Union on 22 June 1941 until the surrender in May 1945, most of the German army was fighting in the east. Axis forces there numbered roughly 3.7 to 3.9 million men in each year from 1941 to 1943, and the Soviet front-line strength grew past six million by 1943. Historian Geoffrey Roberts has estimated that more than 80% of all combat in the Second World War took place on this front.
The human cost reflects that. The Second World War killed somewhere between 60 and 85 million people, depending on how deaths from famine and disease are counted. The official Russian figure for Soviet losses is about 26.6 million, usually rounded to 27 million, of whom about 8.7 million were military dead. Around 30 million of all the war's deaths happened on the Eastern Front alone. No other Allied nation came close to these losses.
Russian state media in 2015 also counted the countries freed: by its tally, the Red Army liberated all or part of 16 present-day European states, Western Allied forces nine, and six more were freed jointly. Such counts depend on how borders are drawn, so they are best read as a rough picture rather than an exact score.
What the United States and Britain contributed
None of this makes the Western Allies minor players. Britain fought from September 1939, held out alone in 1940 and waged the long war at sea. The United States, after staying formally neutral under a series of Neutrality Acts passed between 1935 and 1939, became the arsenal of the coalition. Under the Lend-Lease Act, signed by Franklin D. Roosevelt on 11 March 1941, about $50 billion of supplies were shipped to Allied nations, around $11.3 billion of it to the Soviet Union: trucks, food, fuel, radios and aircraft that helped keep the Red Army moving.
The strategic bombing campaign, the Normandy landings in June 1944 and the advance through France, Belgium and the Netherlands tied down German forces that would otherwise have gone east. Western Europe's own experience of liberation came from American, British, Canadian, French and Polish soldiers, which helps explain why French and German respondents answered as they did.
One quotation often used in this debate needs care. Two days after Germany invaded the Soviet Union, Harry S. Truman told the New York Times that if Germany was winning, America ought to help Russia, and if Russia was winning, it ought to help Germany, adding “that way let them kill as many as possible”. Truman was then a senator from Missouri, not president, and the same remark went on to say he did not want to see Hitler win. It was the view of one senator in 1941, not US policy, and it has long been quoted selectively in Soviet and Russian propaganda.
Berlin, the Elbe and Auschwitz: the dates that matter
The final Soviet offensive on Berlin began on 16 April 1945. By 24 April the city was encircled, and Soviet troops broke into its inner defences the next day. On 25 April, a US patrol of the 69th Infantry Division met Soviet troops on the Elbe near Strehla and Torgau, the moment now remembered as Elbe Day; some retellings give a later date, but 25 April is the documented first contact. The Reichstag was entered on 30 April, and General Weidling surrendered the Berlin garrison on 2 May. Soviet losses in that battle alone were about 81,000 dead or missing.
American troops took over their occupation sector in south-west Berlin in early July 1945, under the zone agreements between the Allies.
Earlier that year, on 27 January 1945, Soviet troops reached Auschwitz. The 322nd Rifle Division arrived at the camp, and the 60th Army of the 1st Ukrainian Front freed the Monowitz sub-camp. About 7,000 prisoners had been left behind by the SS, who had marched most inmates west days before.
The 2015 dispute over who freed Auschwitz
The poll appeared during a bitter row about memory. In January 2015, Polish foreign minister Grzegorz Schetyna said on Polish radio that Auschwitz had been liberated by the 1st Ukrainian Front and Ukrainian soldiers. Russian foreign minister Sergey Lavrov answered that the Red Army that opened the camp included Russians, Ukrainians, Chechens, Tatars, Georgians and many other nationalities, and called the remarks “sacrilegious and cynical”.
The facts behind both claims are simple. The 1st Ukrainian Front was a Soviet army group named after the territory it had fought through, not a Ukrainian national army. Its soldiers came from across the Soviet Union, and many of them were indeed Ukrainians. The argument was less about history than about how the war is used in politics today, a pattern that has only sharpened since 2015.
Why public memory differs from history
A few forces shape how people answer a question like this one:
- Where the soldiers came from. French and Dutch towns were freed by Americans, Britons and Canadians, and local memorials reflect that.
- The Cold War. For four decades the Soviet Union was the West's rival, and its wartime role was played down in Western schools and films while the Soviet side played down Lend-Lease.
- Popular culture. Hollywood has told the story of D-Day many times; the battles of Moscow, Stalingrad and Kursk are far less familiar to Western audiences.
- The occupation that followed. For Poles, Czechs, Hungarians and the Baltic peoples, the Soviet victory also brought decades of imposed rule, which makes the word "liberation" contested.
A fair summary is that the Soviet Union did the largest share of the fighting and dying against Germany, while the United States and Britain supplied industrial power, sea and air dominance and the Western front, and the war could not have been won in 1945 without all of them. A poll asking for one main liberator will always flatten that picture.
Sources: poll figures as reported by Sputnik and RT (2015); Wikipedia: Eastern Front (World War II); Wikipedia: World War II casualties; Wikipedia: World War II casualties of the Soviet Union; Wikipedia: Lend-Lease; Wikipedia: Battle of Berlin; Wikipedia: Elbe Day; Wikipedia: Liberation of Auschwitz; Wikipedia: Harry S. Truman. Banner photo by Yevgeny Khaldei.
Related:- The Human Losses Of The Second World War In An Animated Video
- Germany owes more than €279bn WWII reparations to Greece - more than Greece's debt to EU
- The Real Reason America Used Nuclear Weapons Against Japan. It Was Not To End the War Or Save Lives.
- Stunning Time Lapse Map Video Shows 1000 Years Of Europe's History In 3 Minutes
- Syrian Girl "Surrenders" In Front Of The Camera Mistaking It For A Gun!
- World's refugee population hits all-time high of 60mn, half of them children – UN
- Save the Children’s 2014 Second-a-Day Syria Campaign
- Her War: Women vs. ISIS (RT Documentary)
- Christians, Turkmen, Shiites and Yazidis Are Facing Real Genocide By ISIS
- ISIS thugs take a hammer to civilisation: Priceless 3,000-year-old artworks smashed to pieces in minutes as militants destroy Mosul museum
- Turkish couple drops wedding banquet to feed 4,000 Syrian refugees
- Genocide Recognition and the Pursuit of Justice
- A Picture Is Worth A Thousand Words: The First Genocide Of The 20th Century
- A Dictator Death-Toll Infographic: Why the Methods Matter
- When You Kill Ten Million Africans You Aren’t Called ‘Hitler’
- Watch What The Spanish People Did For Greece!
- Banksy Just Released This 2-Minute Film About Gaza, The Dream Holiday Destination For 2015
- Over 50 Israeli Soldiers Refuse to Fight and Call on Other Conscripts to Resist Military Orders
- 9 Graphics to Help You Understand What Life Is Really Like in Gaza
- This Brilliant Animation Provides A Brief History Of The Bloody Israel/Palestine Conflict
- Twenty Archive Photographs and the Context Behind Their Captions
- Twenty-Nine Social Satire Illustrations by Paweł Kuczyński
- 30 Of The Most Powerful Images Ever
- 35 Moments Of Violence That Brought Out Incredible Human Compassion
- The 63 Most Powerful Photos Ever Taken That Perfectly Capture The Human Experience
- Historical Photo Collection: People, Places and Caption Corrections
- Ultimate Collection Of Rare Historical Photos. A Big Piece Of History (200 Pictures)
- Vasili Arkhipov: The Decision That Helped Avert Nuclear War

COMMENTS