Luther Standing Bear on Nature, Silence and Respect: 10 Ideas

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Painted portrait of a Native American man with long braids and dark streaks of face paint under his eyes
A painting by the American artist Kirby Sattler. It is an imagined figure, not a portrait of Luther Standing Bear.

Luther Standing Bear (c. 1868–1939) was an Oglala Lakota chief, teacher, actor and author whose best-known book, Land of the Spotted Eagle (1933), explained Lakota values to readers who had mostly met his people through stereotypes. The ten passages people share most often come from that book. They are about four things: courtesy shown through actions, the value of silence, kinship with animals and land, and the cost of cutting children off from nature.

Below you will find who he was, what each idea actually says in plain words, where the passages come from, and a few common misreadings worth avoiding.

Who was Luther Standing Bear?

He was born in December 1868 at the Spotted Tail Agency in Dakota Territory, with the Lakota name Óta Kté, usually translated as "Plenty Kill". His father was also called Standing Bear, and the family name followed him into English.

In 1879 he was among the very first pupils at the Carlisle Indian Industrial School in Pennsylvania, the government boarding school whose founder, Richard Henry Pratt, set out to strip Native children of their languages and customs. Standing Bear chose the name "Luther" there by pointing at a word on a wall he could not yet read. He became one of the school's model students, yet he later wrote bluntly about what the system took from children like him.

His adult life crossed several worlds. He taught on the Rosebud reservation, toured with Buffalo Bill's Wild West in 1902 and 1903 (and was badly hurt in the show's train accident), and was chosen as a chief of the Oglala Lakota in 1905. He then moved to California, where he worked in Hollywood films and, with the athlete Jim Thorpe, founded the Indian Actors Association to win Native roles for Native performers.

He wrote four books: My People the Sioux (1928), My Indian Boyhood (1931), Land of the Spotted Eagle (1933) and Stories of the Sioux (1934). In 1933 he wrote to President Franklin D. Roosevelt asking that Native history and culture be taught in public schools. He died in February 1939, while working on Cecil B. DeMille's film Union Pacific.

The ten ideas, in plain words

The passages below are summarised in our own words. The book itself is short, readable and still in print, and it is far better than any list of extracts.

1. Courtesy is not flattery

Lakota good manners, as he describes them, had no room for compliments, showy politeness or a stream of pleasant talk. Someone who never stopped speaking was seen as careless of others, and conversations were allowed to begin slowly.

2. Children learned respect through behaviour

Children were taught that politeness was something you did. They did not walk between an elder or guest and the fire, did not interrupt, and did not mock anyone with a disability. When a child slipped, a parent corrected them quietly, on the spot, without a scene.

Painting of a Plains Indian elder pointing skyward as he talks to a man and two children seated in the grass

3. Silence is a form of respect

This is the passage people remember most. Before speaking, a Lakota person often paused, in keeping with the principle that "thought comes before speech." Silence was also the proper response to grief, illness, misfortune and the presence of honoured people. Standing Bear argues that outsiders misread this restraint as coldness and labelled his people stoic or unfeeling, when it was really a form of good manners.

4. The land was never "wild"

The plains, hills and tangled creek banks felt like home, not like a frontier to be tamed. In one of his sharpest lines he writes: "Only to the white man was nature a 'wilderness'". The point is about perspective: a landscape only looks savage to someone who does not know how to live in it.

Mountain lake surrounded by forested slopes under a cloudy sky

5. Kinship with animals was real

He describes a sense of family with the creatures of land, air and water, a working principle rather than a figure of speech. In his telling, some people grew so close to birds and animals that they could understand one another.

6. That kinship made people gentler

Seeing every living thing as related, he says, gave people love, wonder and reverence, and a sense that everything in existence had its own place and equal worth.

7. Sitting on the ground

Elders liked to take off their moccasins and walk barefoot, and to sit or lie directly on the earth. He presents this as a way of thinking and feeling more clearly, and of staying close to other living things.

Painting of a Plains Indian camp gathering, with seated women, a mounted warrior and horses in a meadow

8. The world as a library

Stones, leaves, grass, streams and animals were the books from which a child learned. Learning in this way taught people to feel beauty and to accept harsh weather without complaint, adjusting to it with extra effort instead of fighting it.

9. A heart kept from nature hardens

Old Lakota people, he writes, understood that disrespect for growing things soon turns into disrespect for people. So they made sure children grew up in close contact with the natural world, which they believed softened character.

10. Civilization did not make him better

The most quoted closing line is a personal verdict: "Civilization has been thrust upon me… and it has not added one whit to my love for truth, honesty, and generosity." It is the voice of a man who had been through Carlisle, the Wild West shows and Hollywood, and who knew both worlds well enough to judge.

Where the passages come from

Nearly all of the ten appear in Land of the Spotted Eagle, published by Houghton Mifflin in 1933 and later reissued by the University of Nebraska Press. He wrote it in the early 1930s, after visits back to Lakota country left him shaken by the conditions people were living in. The book is part memoir and part description of everyday Lakota life: childhood, family, religion, government and education. Its final chapters argue directly against policies designed to make Native people over in the image of white Americans.

That context matters. These lines were not written as gentle nature sayings for posters. They were written as a defence of a culture that schools, churches and federal law were actively trying to erase, by a man who had been one of the first children sent through that system.

Common misreadings to avoid

"A Sioux chief" says it all

"Sioux" covers several related peoples, usually grouped as Lakota, Dakota and Nakota. Standing Bear was Oglala, one of the seven Lakota bands. Naming him precisely respects the fact that he was describing his own people, not every Indigenous nation in North America.

The picture shows Standing Bear

The striking painted face at the top of this page is by Kirby Sattler, a contemporary American painter known for imagined Plains portraits. It is often shared alongside these quotes, but it is not a likeness of Standing Bear, who was photographed many times in his lifetime.

Every "Native American proverb" online is genuine

Many lines circulating on social media under the label of Native wisdom have no traceable source at all. Standing Bear's passages are the opposite: they have an author, a date and a book. When you share one, it is worth keeping his name and the title attached.

He rejected the modern world

He did not. He worked in film, wrote in English, lobbied presidents and used modern institutions to defend Lakota life. His criticism was aimed at the idea that one culture should replace another, not at learning or change.

What his words offer readers today

Read slowly, the passages contain practical habits that hold up well. Pause before answering. Let quiet sit at a funeral or a hospital bedside instead of filling it. Teach children manners through what they do, and correct them gently and privately. Give them time outdoors, with soil, water and animals, not only screens and classrooms.

They also ask a harder question: whose idea of "progress" is being used, and what gets lost along the way? Standing Bear answered from experience. If these extracts speak to you, the best next step is the book itself, and then his memoir My People the Sioux, which tells his life from the beginning.

Sources: Luther Standing Bear (Wikipedia); Land of the Spotted Eagle, 1933 (Faded Page edition); Wisdom Pills, original selection of passages; portrait painting: Kirby Sattler.

For additional cultural context that recognizes distinct tribal nations, explore First Americans Museum: Living Stories of 39 Tribal Nations.

Explore the related article: George Orwell Quotes: Language, Power and Attribution.

More from the archive:

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 14
  1. Beautiful words...
    Such refine thoughts...

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi there! Someone in my Myspace group shared this website with us so I came to check it out. I'm definitely loving the information. I'm bookmarking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Superb blog and fantastic style and design

    merry christmas 2018 messages

    ReplyDelete
  3. This post is so help ful for me ....really!! i like it.. thanks for sharing it...

    Caption for holi pictures 2019

    ReplyDelete
  4. I read your post, really, it left me so much impressed with this article, I hope you will have more great articles to share with readers, thank you the post.Great post! Your blog is awesome, thanks so much and keep up the great work!
    ||cute love status in hindi || love status in hindi || Royal Attitude Status In hindi || Attitude Status || Lifequoteses

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete