The Law of Attraction and The Secret: What the Evidence Says

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
What You Are Not Being Told About The Secret & Law Of Attraction

The law of attraction is the belief that your thoughts and feelings draw matching experiences into your life: think positively and good things come; dwell on the negative and bad things follow. It was made famous by Rhonda Byrne's 2006 film and book The Secret, and by Esther and Jerry Hicks's "Abraham" books such as Ask and It Is Given. What fans are rarely told is that there is no scientific evidence for it as a universal law, that its use of quantum physics is mistaken, and that its most helpful parts are ordinary psychology: clear goals, steady effort, and a hopeful but realistic outlook.

This guide explains where the idea came from, how people practise it, what supporters say about why it "sometimes doesn't work", and what research actually shows about positive thinking, so you can keep what is useful and leave the rest.

What the law of attraction claims

In its popular form, the law of attraction says that like attracts like. Every thought carries a kind of energy, and the universe responds by sending you more of whatever you focus on, whether that is money, health, love or trouble. In principle it can be used to bring in specific objects and situations as well as general moods.

The idea is older than The Secret. It grew out of the 19th-century New Thought movement, which began with mesmerist Phineas Quimby's ideas about the mind's power over the body. Writers such as Prentice Mulford and Ralph Waldo Trine extended it to every area of life, and Napoleon Hill's Think and Grow Rich (1937) became one of the best-selling self-help books ever by hinting at a hidden "secret" to success. Byrne's 2006 film repackaged these ideas for a television age, and Oprah Winfrey's interest helped turn it into a global phenomenon.

How people practise it

The methods are simple, which is part of the appeal. Common techniques include:

  • Affirmations: repeating positive statements, often in the present tense, such as "I am healthy and successful".
  • Vision boards: collages of pictures and words representing the life you want.
  • Visualisation: imagining a goal as already achieved, in vivid detail.
  • Watching your language: avoiding self-defeating words and replacing complaints with grateful or hopeful statements.

The theory offered is that repetition plants an image in the subconscious, which then shapes reality. Some people report remarkable results; many others report none. Most books spend little time on why the outcomes vary so widely.

What You Are Not Being Told About The Secret & Law Of Attraction

The "bigger picture" explanation from believers

The 2014 article this page grew from, written by the founder of the website Collective Evolution, offered a spiritual answer to that question. Its argument was that the law of attraction always works, but not always in the way our conscious, ego-driven mind expects. At a deeper "soul" level, each person is on a path of growth, and sometimes the experience we attract is the lesson we need rather than the thing we asked for.

The author gave a personal example. While working briefly in finance, he used attraction techniques to pursue wealth, and several large deals seemed close to closing. All of them fell through. Soon afterwards he left finance and the website became his full-time work. Looking back, he saw the failed deals as necessary: they forced him to rethink his relationship with money and self-worth, and the income he needed eventually arrived by another route.

He drew two further lessons. First, strong attachment to a specific outcome can backfire. Second, half-hearted, doubtful intention achieves little; a clear and confident intention matters.

Many readers find this framing comforting, and there is real wisdom in noticing how setbacks can redirect a life. But it is worth seeing what the framing does: if every result, good or bad, counts as the law "working", then no possible outcome could ever show that it does not. That is a sign of a belief that cannot be tested, not of a law of nature.

What science says

Quantum physics does not support it

Law-of-attraction books often say that "everything is energy" and that quantum physics proves thoughts create reality. That is not what quantum physics shows. In quantum experiments, "observation" means a physical interaction with a measuring device, not a person's hopes. Physicists including Victor Stenger and Nobel laureate Leon Lederman criticised this kind of "quantum mysticism". Psychology professor Peter Strelan, writing in 2024, noted that The Secret had "offended physicists" with its use of their field.

Testimonials are not evidence

Most support for the law comes from personal stories. Those are vulnerable to well-known biases: we remember the hits and forget the misses (confirmation bias), people with dramatic successes are the ones who write books (selection bias), and we connect events that happened close together (illusory correlation).

Positive fantasies can reduce effort

Research by psychologist Gabriele Oettingen at New York University distinguishes between expecting success, based on past experience, and merely fantasising about it. Her studies suggest that vivid positive fantasies alone can lower motivation, because the mind partly experiences the goal as already achieved. She found better results from "mental contrasting": picturing the goal, then honestly picturing the obstacles, then planning how to deal with them. Her WOOP method (Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan) packages this approach.

Belief can carry risks

A 2023 study by Lucas Dixon and colleagues found that people who strongly believe in "manifesting" rated themselves as more successful but were also more drawn to risky financial choices, a pattern linked to a greater risk of bankruptcy. Critics have also pointed out a darker side: if thoughts create reality, people with illness, depression or misfortune can be made to feel they brought it on themselves. That is neither fair nor true.

What genuinely helps

Strip away the cosmic claims and some elements of law-of-attraction practice line up with solid psychology:

  • Clarity: writing down what you want makes it easier to plan and to notice opportunities.
  • Optimism grounded in action: hopeful people tend to persist longer, which improves results.
  • Gratitude: noticing what is going well is linked to better mood for many people.
  • Less attachment: holding goals with some flexibility helps you adapt when plans change, which echoes the lesson in the personal story above.

A practical approach is to use the inspiring part, imagining what you want, and then add the steps the law of attraction usually leaves out: identify the main obstacle, decide what you will do when you meet it, and take the first concrete action today.

Meditation and quick-fix programmes

Trouble with Meditation?

The original article ended with an advertisement for a meditation audio product that promised to meditate "for you" using special brainwave sounds. Such products are widely marketed, but claims about them go far beyond the evidence, and we do not endorse any particular programme.

Meditation itself has been studied extensively. The US National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health reports that mindfulness approaches may help with anxiety, depression, sleep quality and coping with pain for some people, but notes that much of the research is preliminary and results vary between practices. Meditation is generally low-risk, though a minority of people have unpleasant experiences. It should never replace medical care, so talk to a doctor about any health concern. Free guided practices and simple breathing exercises are a reasonable way to start.

The takeaway

The law of attraction endures because it offers hope and a sense of control, and because thinking about what you want genuinely is the first step towards getting it. But your thoughts do not broadcast to the universe, and difficult events are not proof that you thought wrongly. Use the optimism, keep your feet on the ground, plan for the obstacles, and be gentle with yourself and others when life does not go to plan.

Sources: Wikipedia: Law of attraction (New Thought); PsyPost / The Conversation: Peter Strelan on The Secret (February 2024); Wikipedia: Gabriele Oettingen; NCCIH: Meditation and Mindfulness. Personal account from an earlier article published by Collective Evolution (2014).

Related:

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1
  1. I must say that the views are strong and I have experienced the same quite often, yet I have never believed in the law of attraction. I mean to say that this is not our ability to attract, I would put it as the ability to understand, A little bit like foreseeing. Destiny,fate or is everything written? I don't know, but may be we do not understand the ability of our brain, which can perceive and process almost everything, so what we expect or what we truly wish to happen is rather just an outcome of a thought process that occurs in our brains, and yes due to our egos we fail to understand because we can not see that the choice was made on the basis of our abilities and our needs and not upon our greed!

    ReplyDelete