A Grandfather's Letter to a Daughter Who Disowned Her Gay Son

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2014-08-08.

A Viral Family Letter About Acceptance

In October 2013 a short handwritten-style letter swept across Facebook. In it, a grandfather tells his daughter, Christine, that he is ashamed of her, not of her son Chad, after she threw the teenager out of her home for being gay. The grandfather says he is cutting ties with her because he now has a grandson to raise, and that she can call him if she ever has a change of heart. The letter is signed simply "Dad".

Where the letter came from

The letter was first posted on 1 October 2013 by FCKH8, a clothing company known for pro-LGBT slogans and campaigns. Within two days it had collected more than 10,000 likes, and outlets including PinkNews, The Blaze and later Upworthy wrote about it. According to Upworthy, an FCKH8 representative said Chad had passed the letter on, that the family lived in Michigan and that Chad was 16.

Is the letter real?

That question has never been fully answered. PinkNews noted at the time that the post was unverified, while FCKH8 insisted it was genuine and said it had asked the family whether they would speak publicly. They declined, reportedly because Chad had not yet come out beyond his family, and their identities have never been made public. Because the letter was shared by a company that sells campaign merchandise, some readers treated it with caution.

The fair conclusion is that the letter is a widely shared, unconfirmed story. Its names cannot be checked, and it should not be read as reporting about identifiable people. What made it travel, though, was not the detail but the message: a parent choosing a child over a prejudice.

The real problem behind the story

Whatever the truth of this particular family, the situation it describes is common. Researchers have long found that LGBT young people are over-represented among homeless youth; estimates in different studies range from about 11 to 40 percent. Studies point to family conflict, hostility and rejection as the main reason, with many teenagers either told to leave or running away after coming out.

Family reactions also matter for health. A 2009 study in the journal Pediatrics, led by Caitlin Ryan of the Family Acceptance Project at San Francisco State University, found that lesbian, gay and bisexual young adults who had faced high levels of family rejection as teenagers were around eight times more likely to report a suicide attempt, and nearly six times more likely to report high levels of depression, than peers whose families had shown little or no rejection. Later work from the same project found that accepting behaviour was linked to better self-esteem and general health.

What acceptance looks like day to day

A dramatic letter is easy to share, but support is mostly made of small, ordinary choices. For parents and relatives who are struggling, researchers and youth charities suggest a few practical steps:

  • Keep the door open. Make it clear the young person still has a home and a place at family events.
  • Listen before reacting. A coming-out conversation is usually the result of months or years of worry.
  • Respect privacy. Let them decide who else is told, and when.
  • Stand up for them. Challenge slurs or jokes from relatives, at school or in church.
  • Get support for yourself. Groups such as PFLAG exist for parents who need time and help to adjust.

Even families who find the news hard can reduce harm by avoiding the most damaging reactions, such as insults, threats or forcing a young person out of home.

Why grandparents matter

The letter struck a chord partly because it came from an older relative. Grandparents are often assumed to be less accepting, yet many step in as carers when a parent cannot cope, and their support can carry special weight inside a family. Whether or not "Dad" and Chad exist exactly as described, the image of a grandfather taking in his grandson is a reminder that any adult in a young person's life can be the one who makes them feel safe.

If you are a young person who has been thrown out or feels unsafe at home, contact a local youth helpline or LGBT youth service; in the United States, The Trevor Project offers 24-hour support.

Sources: PinkNews (3 Oct 2013); Upworthy; Wikipedia: Homelessness among LGBTQ youth in the United States. Image via The Meta Picture and True Activist.

COMMENTS