
Is Hell exothermic or endothermic? If you have seen this question online, it was almost certainly attached to a famous story: a chemistry professor sets it as a bonus exam question, and one student answers with a mock-scientific proof that ends in a cheeky punchline and earns a top grade. It is a great joke. It is not, as far as anyone can show, a real exam.
The fact-checking site Snopes traces the familiar version to email chains and the rec.humor newsgroup in 1997. Different copies name different universities, including Washington and Arizona, and none comes with a real professor, date or exam paper. The idea of calculating the temperature of Heaven and Hell is also much older than the internet. Below is how the joke works, why the "science" in it is wonky, and the surprisingly long history behind it.
How the student's "proof" goes
In the circulating story, most of the class tries to answer with Boyle's law. One student instead reasons from the number of souls. The argument runs roughly like this:
- Assume souls have mass and, once they arrive in Hell, they never leave.
- Many religions say that people outside their faith go to Hell. Since nobody belongs to every religion, the student concludes, practically every soul ends up there, and with births and deaths continuing, the number grows rapidly.
- For temperature and pressure to stay the same, Hell's volume would have to grow as fast as its population.
- So there are two possibilities. If Hell expands more slowly than souls arrive, pressure and temperature rise "until all Hell breaks loose." If it expands faster, it cools until it freezes over.
- The decider is a personal anecdote: a classmate once said it would be a "cold day in Hell" before she would sleep with him, and, he claims, she just did. Therefore Hell has frozen over, and the punchline follows.
The full text appears in the image below, as it was commonly shared. This copy credits the University of Arizona, which shows how freely the setting shifted between versions.

The widely shared text of the "Hell exam" answer, ending with the claim of an A+ and the "Engineers" meme of Giorgio Tsoukalos from the TV series Ancient Aliens. No university has confirmed the exam or the grade.
Is the story true?
There is no evidence that it is. Snopes describes the 1997 version as humour rather than a genuine account and notes that it would be an odd question for a real chemistry professor to set. The tell-tale signs of a classic internet legend are all there: an unnamed professor, a university that changes depending on who shares it, and a perfect punchline that "earned an A+."
That does not make it any less funny. It simply belongs in the same family as other campus legends, such as the student who solves an "unsolvable" problem left on the board, rather than in the record of real exams.
The real chemistry: exothermic, endothermic and Boyle's law
The joke borrows real terms, so it is worth knowing what they mean.
- Exothermic processes release heat into their surroundings. Burning wood is the classic example.
- Endothermic processes absorb heat, which is why the surroundings often feel cooler. Melting ice is a familiar case.
- Boyle's law, published by Robert Boyle in 1662, says that for a fixed amount of gas at a constant temperature, pressure and volume are inversely proportional: halve the volume and the pressure doubles.
Here is the catch. Boyle's law only applies when temperature does not change, so it cannot tell you whether something heats up or cools down. Older retellings of this story described Boyle's law as "gas cools when it expands and heats when compressed," which is a different idea; that behaviour is better described by the ideal gas law and the thermodynamics of expansion. The student's proof also treats souls as a gas with mass, which is exactly where the comedy lives.
There is a neat twist hidden in the punchline. Freezing is itself an exothermic process: water gives off heat as it turns to ice. So a Hell that is busy freezing over would, in a strictly chemical sense, be exothermic after all.
Heaven, Hell and temperature: a joke older than email
Scientists have been playing with this idea for about a century. According to Snopes, physicist Paul Darwin Foote wrote a tongue-in-cheek piece in the 1920s called "The Temperature of Heaven and Hell," using Biblical descriptions to argue that Heaven is the hotter of the two. Versions of that calculation were reprinted in Clifton Fadiman's anthology The Mathematical Magpie (1962), and a 1972 parody in the journal Applied Optics repeated the conclusion that Heaven is hotter than Hell.
In 1979 a rebuttal in The Journal of Irreproducible Results, a magazine of science satire, argued the opposite. The student exam answer of the 1990s is a descendant of this playful tradition, updated with gas laws and a romantic punchline.
Why science jokes like this spread
Jokes like the Hell exam travel well because they reward a little knowledge. You need to recognise words like "exothermic" and "Boyle's law" to enjoy the setup, which makes readers feel clever, and then the ending pulls the rug out from under the science entirely.
They also flatter a familiar fantasy: the student who outwits the system and is rewarded for it. That is why the claimed A+ appears in almost every version. A useful habit, whenever a story ends with a perfect grade or a speechless professor, is to ask who the professor was, when it happened and whether anyone involved has ever confirmed it. With this one, nobody has. Enjoy it as a joke, and keep the real definitions handy for your next chemistry test.
Sources: Snopes: Hell endothermic or exothermic?; Boyle's law (Wikipedia); Endothermic process (Wikipedia).
Related:
- Here Are 25 Kids That Gave Absolutely Brilliant Answers On Their Tests. These Are Hysterically Genius.
- This 14-Year-Old Boy Just Wrote The Most Important Poem Of The 21st Century
- 16 Children & Their Bedrooms From Around the World…
- It will take just 1 minute to read this and change your thinking.
- The Three Filters: A Story Attributed to Socrates
- John Lennon’s Imagine in Comic Form
- A Short Comic About Love and Everyday Care

Prove hell exists. .-.
ReplyDeleteYou aint proving nutn
If your comment was to make fun of religion allow me to show you the hole in your comment...ahem...prove that we just disappear after death. cant do that either can you? fact is you can no more prove the atheist view on death anymore than religion can prove theirs. we'll all find out one day though and by then it wont matter who was wrong or right, so why should it now?
DeleteSaying, "I don't know" is an acceptable, logical answer. Making stuff up to threaten other people with, is not. THAT is why it matters.
DeleteNicolas: Well at first sadly or luckly religion can prove nothing because you just must have to believe. Just simple population control and abuse of spirital world what is related to no religion.
DeleteI'm not saying religion in history was right. believe me i've studied history quite well and know full well the atrocities religious believers committed in the name of their god however the belief in an after life transcends believing in god or allah or some other"divine being". I am simply saying that while blind believe in a religion can neither prove or disprove the existence of an after life neither can atheists prove that there is none. its a simple fact that we will only find out when we inevitably die. who knows for all we know heaven could be a real place and we all go there when we die and our personal heaven is based on what we believe. if we believe that we just disappear then that's what happens in our personal heaven, those who believe in an afterlife get the afterlife of their choosing. and Gabriel, it only matters because you wish to change another's view. this is a sign of ignorance, instead of just accepting the fact that you cannot control what people choose to believe and just let them live their life the way they choose you choose to berate them for believing in what you believe is an imaginary god, of course that's assuming that is what you do if you do not then i apologize.also as far as my statement is concerned saying "I don't know" is a logical answer since it is physically impossible for us to know and return with that knowledge however even though it is a logical answer it still gives and answer either way and that answer is that you cant prove it. again you can no more prove the atheist view any more than believers can prove theirs. Netspider, actually population control was not a part of holy roman empire doctrines or even as far as today is concerned. originally the church used its power to establish control in general, not control of the population but control of the populace. it used their authority to do what many today would consider to be illegal even by modern christians. the bible at the time was written in latin and just about everyone aside from the clerics and the pope could read and write latin everyone else spoke and read italian and some didnt read at all. this lead many clerics who would preach the "word of god" to actually preach of what the church wanted everyone to believe. its wasn't until the King James version came around and the bible was translated from botched latin to even more botched olde english. this is when the church started loosing control. the church today is only still around due to the followers that still believe. with inquisitions gone they no longer have the ability to use fear to control the masses, they no longer can falsely accuse a man of heresy and burn him in front of everyone and claim that satan destroys lives. those things happened yes however they are not a representation of the church today. the church today is a fragmented shadow of its former self, the only thing keeping itself together is the beliefs that the church once pushed however for these people that is their way, we have no right to control another into believing anything. Once we start trying to control others and change their beliefs we are no better than the church. its their right to choose what they wish to believe in and that must be repsected, and that goes for christians as well the bible even says that mankind is free to believe in what we want so christians have no right berating us either. we need to learn tolerance on both sides.
Deleteholy shit i didn't realize how much i wrote until i posted it.
DeleteLOL, yes, that was quite the wall of text! I agree with what you said, in principle, but history has shown, clearly, that most religions don't follow that. At one point in time, people naively thought Apollo dragged the sun across the sky or that Zeus was responsible for lightning during a storm. Science eventually proved otherwise. Believing in an afterlife is just another example of mankind's want/need/desire to understand the unknowable. You are correct, we don't know with any degree of certainty what happens after we die. That's where it should end. Making things up is intellectually dishonest. And while it's fine to let others believe what they want to believe is all well and good, again, that's not what most religions do. They want to push those beliefs on others. And history has shown this happen time and time again. Sorry, but that is not acceptable and we shouldn't turn a blind eye to it or we will be doomed to repeat our past mistakes. It's time to put away those childish things.
DeleteI agree making things up is intellectually dishonest however the reason behind it lies more along the lines of psychology and not actual science. like you said they make things up to understand the unknown. even today the unknown is still out there. even you agree that we cant know what happens after death and that fear drives people to do irrational things. the belief that there is an afterlife is mankind's desire to still remain even after death. even you gotta admit that the though of living through life only to just have our bodies rot in the ground in the end is a little disheartening.and i agree that most religion do wish to push their beliefs on other and i agree that is wrong however the things I've seen atheists do to christians are no better, each tries to force their beliefs onto the other and that needs to stop.
DeleteThere are no postulates in science, science by definition is just what we can OBSERVE from our god given 5 senses that is taken for granted. So by definition, God is outside the realm of science. Someone who can be observed by these 5 senses which defines how we interact in this world could not have created these senses.
ReplyDeleteBut from the FACTS that we know about this life:
We are here involuntarily.
We cannot stop ourselves from dying.
We have a uniform life of about 70 years in which we observe the world using the same 5 senses, where there is a uniform concept of right and wrong.
My conclusion from these facts:
The purpose of an involuntary uniform lifetime where there is a uniform concept of right and wrong is to be judged.
Well there are religions that does not say 'its my way or hell'. There are religions that says 'hell' is not some permanent resident status and that a soul would transform into the next life after a while. And there are religions that is a tad more than apollo dragging the sun and some of its amazing scientific leaps and discoveries long before we found it out again in the modern world baffles us. Also there were attrocities and violence before religions and there will be violence even if there isnt any religion. One is barking at the wrong tree if one thinks 'religion' is the root of all evil or if atheism will solve everything. We would still fight, we would still have violence and superstitions. The root lies in us. The trait in human beings to be divisive, cause violence etc. Religion or atheism is just an excuse and an ignorant reason to hang on to/ blame. Lines like 'the all powerful god forbids you to believe in anything but this book' isnt helping either! I agree. But there are others that doesnt say such things. But trust me, we would still fight even without those lines, even with a better book or without a book!
ReplyDeleteno matter soul is exothermic or endothermic ,let us take a deep understanding on soul.soul can neither be created nor be destroyed by humans. it has no mass neither it occupied space so it is not a matter.so number of population of soul cannot effect the rate of reaction.so hell is freezing or burning no matter but it is a place that gives pain so it is compare to fire., because fire is dangerous thing to mankind, it has also merit things but it depends on our proper use.
ReplyDeleteI don't think the student meant anything for or against religion.
ReplyDeleteHe just theorized an answer with his accumulated knowledge and the condition of where his mind was.
I thought it was brilliant and funny and I'm sure that's the way he meant it!