This is an opinion piece; it reflects the author’s views.
What if much of what you learned at school, in church and from the evening news was wrong? It is a fair question, and asking it is healthy. Textbooks do simplify, institutions do have agendas, and history is often told by the winners. But the honest answer is more interesting than "everything is a lie". Some of what we were taught really was incomplete or slanted. Much of it holds up very well when checked. And a lot of the popular "hidden truths" that claim to replace it turn out to be false themselves.
This piece began life in 2014 as a passionate essay by Gregg Prescott of In5D, arguing that schools, religion, television and government wage a "war on consciousness" to keep people obedient. Below we keep its core questions, test its main examples against the record, and end with a practical toolkit for telling a suppressed truth from an attractive myth.

The real case for questioning what you were taught
The essay's starting point deserves respect. School curricula are written by people, under political and budget pressures, and they leave things out. Generations of pupils were told that Christopher Columbus "discovered" America, although millions of people already lived there and Norse sailors had built a settlement at L'Anse aux Meadows in Newfoundland around the year 1000. A 2021 study of tree rings in wood cut by the Norse pinned their activity there to the year 1021, nearly five centuries before Columbus sailed.
Schools also tend to reward memorising over questioning. The essay's suggestion that we ask children what they would do with their lives if money did not exist is a thoughtful one. It invites them to think about meaning and talent rather than only about salaries, and many educators would agree that creativity and independent thinking are under-taught.
Governments, too, have lied, and some of those lies are documented. In the 1970s the US Senate's Church Committee confirmed that the CIA had cultivated secret relationships with journalists, and Carl Bernstein reported in 1977 that hundreds of American reporters had quietly carried out tasks for the agency. Scepticism about official stories has a solid historical basis.
Claims that did not survive a check
The trouble is that the original essay mixed these fair points with claims that fall apart when you look at the evidence. Four of them are worth correcting in detail, because they still circulate widely.
Prescott Bush was not arrested
The essay said George W. Bush's grandfather was arrested for funding both sides of the Second World War. The record is different. Prescott Bush was one of seven directors of Union Banking Corporation, a small New York bank that handled assets for the German industrialist Fritz Thyssen, an early backer of Hitler who later broke with the Nazis. In October 1942 the US government seized the bank under the Trading with the Enemy Act. Bush was not arrested or charged, and he went on to win a US Senate seat in Connecticut in 1952. The episode raises real questions about business ties to Nazi Germany, but it is not the story the essay told.
Oil is a fossil fuel, not a self-renewing "abiotic" resource
The idea that oil forms deep inside the Earth without living matter, and so constantly replenishes itself, has a long fringe history. Geologists have looked hard for abiotic oil deposits. The scientific evidence overwhelmingly supports a biological origin for the world's petroleum: it formed over millions of years from buried organic material, which is why it is finite.
Stanley Meyer's water-powered car did not work
Stanley Meyer claimed his "water fuel cell" could power a car on water alone. In 1996 an Ohio court heard expert witnesses who found the device was ordinary electrolysis, ruled that Meyer had committed "gross and egregious fraud", and ordered him to repay two investors. A machine that produced more energy from water than it took to split it would break the first and second laws of thermodynamics. Meyer died suddenly at a restaurant in March 1998; the county coroner found a ruptured brain aneurysm, and police found no evidence that he was poisoned.
The Reichstag fire was not used to start a war
The German parliament building burned on 27 February 1933, four weeks after Hitler became chancellor. A young Dutch communist, Marinus van der Lubbe, was arrested inside the building, convicted and executed; Germany formally overturned his conviction in 2008. The fire's real significance is what the Nazis did next: a decree signed the following day suspended most civil liberties and let them arrest thousands of political opponents. Most historians believe van der Lubbe set the fire; a minority, including Benjamin Carter Hett, argue the Nazis were involved. Either way, it was a tool for seizing power at home, not a pretext for war.
Ancient mysteries and "out of place" objects
The essay also leaned on so-called out-of-place artefacts, objects said to prove that humans or advanced cultures existed far earlier than archaeologists accept. Its main example was a bronze coin supposedly drawn up by a well drill near Chillicothe, Illinois, from deposits hundreds of thousands of years old.
No such coin has ever been authenticated, and the story appears to rest on an old, unverified report rather than a documented find. Coins have existed for less than three thousand years. More generally, researchers who investigate these cases find the same explanations again and again: natural formations mistaken for artefacts, objects misdated or misidentified, later items that slipped into older layers, and outright hoaxes such as the Cardiff Giant. Genuine anomalies do exist, such as an eleventh-century Norwegian penny found in Maine, but they tend to have ordinary explanations, in that case trade.
The essay also argued from the Bible, asking how Noah gathered polar bears and penguins, or how Adam and Eve could account for different blood types. Those are fair questions to put to a strictly literal reading of Genesis, and many religious scholars read those chapters symbolically for that reason. They do not, however, show that schools or churches are deliberately hiding a different history. Claims made in the original essay about clergy "admitting" that hell does not exist were not sourced, and we have left them out.
(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)
Television, news and the attention economy
The strongest part of the original argument is about attention. Commercial television and social media are funded by advertising, and advertising works best when viewers feel they are missing something: a better body, a newer phone, a quicker cure. Noticing that is not paranoia. It is a sensible starting point for deciding how much of your evening you want to hand over.
(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)
On government and the press, the essay pointed to a 2014 story claiming the Obama administration was placing government monitors in newsrooms. The real event was more limited. The Federal Communications Commission planned a pilot survey in South Carolina, the Multi-Market Study of Critical Information Needs, that would have asked broadcasters about how they chose stories. After criticism from journalists and from FCC commissioner Ajit Pai, the agency suspended the pilot on 21 February 2014 and dropped the study a week later. Press freedom advocates were right to object, and the objection worked.
The lesson is useful in both directions. Watch for pressure on independent media, and also check whether a dramatic headline matches what actually happened.
(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)
A toolkit for finding what is true
If "question everything" is the right instinct, the next step is learning how to answer the questions. A few habits go a long way:
- Find the primary source. A court ruling, a coroner's report, a dated document or a peer-reviewed paper outranks a blog that summarises another blog.
- Ask what would prove you wrong. A theory that explains every possible outcome, including a total lack of evidence, is not explaining anything.
- Follow the money in every direction. Big companies have interests, but so do websites that sell books, supplements or memberships alongside their "suppressed truths".
- Check quotations. The famous line that insanity means doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results is often attributed to Albert Einstein. Researchers at Quote Investigator traced it to 1980s recovery-group literature and found no evidence that Einstein said it.
- Use fact-checkers, then check them too. Snopes, Lead Stories, AFP Fact Check and others show their sources, which means you can verify their work yourself.
- Be willing to update. Changing your mind when the evidence changes is the opposite of being programmed.
Questioning without falling for new myths
The original essay ended with a call to question everything, including what it said itself. That is the most valuable sentence in it. Real independent thinking means applying the same standard to official stories and to alternative ones. Some things we were taught were incomplete or wrong; Columbus is the classic example. Other things, like the origin of oil and the laws of thermodynamics, have been tested so thoroughly that rejecting them requires much stronger evidence than a viral claim.
Curiosity, reading widely, turning off the television now and then, and spending time on things that help other people are all good advice. Combined with a habit of checking sources, they lead somewhere better than either blind trust or blanket suspicion.
Sources: Original essay by Gregg Prescott, M.S., In5D; Wikipedia: Prescott Bush; Wikipedia: Abiogenic petroleum origin; Wikipedia: Water fuel cell; Wikipedia: Reichstag fire; Wikipedia: Out-of-place artifact; Wikipedia: L'Anse aux Meadows; Wikipedia: Operation Mockingbird and the Church Committee; Harvard Journal of Law & Technology Digest: FCC cancels plan to survey newsrooms; Quote Investigator: Insanity is doing the same thing.
Related:- 300+ Mind Expanding Documentaries
- Possibly The Most Important Video Ever Produced About Our World's Greatest Problems

Nice plug for in5d.. I'll check it out anyway. :)
ReplyDeleteWho cares if it's a plug! We need more people expressing these ideas
DeleteLove reading insightful/researched/common-sense/logical argument against the status-quo! Thank you!
ReplyDeleteYes, thanks Julie for the post will be sharing it for sure
ReplyDelete