First published July 8, 2013.
This article reflects the advocacy view of its 2013 source; factual points are corrected in the notes below.
The tribunal's authority is central to interpreting the verdict
The article describes proceedings organised around an advocacy initiative. A finding from such a forum should not be equated with a conviction by a court exercising recognised criminal jurisdiction. Its evidentiary claims may be examined, but the forum's status, participation of the accused and power to enforce any decision must remain explicit.
Sources and further context: JURIST: Malaysia rights group verdict in symbolic trial
George Bush, Dick Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld, William Haynes, Jay Bybee and John Yoo were found guilty in absentia by a tribunal in Malaysia, for torture and inhumane degrading treatment of people. (Correction: on 11 May 2012 the Kuala Lumpur War Crimes Tribunal, a non-governmental body set up by former Malaysian prime minister Mahathir Mohamad, found eight men guilty of torture: Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Alberto Gonzales, David Addington, William Haynes, Jay Bybee and John Yoo. It has no formal enforcement power and its ruling is not legally enforceable, so this was not a criminal conviction by a court. It was also not the first tribunal of its kind; it was modelled partly on a 1967 people’s tribunal held in Sweden and Denmark.)
Supporters of the tribunal compared its verdict to a 21st-century Nuremberg trial and said more trials would follow. The names of all these guilty, high ranking officials are even going to be entered into the “Commission’s Register of War Criminals” for public record.This tribunal was the initiative of Malaysia’s former prime minister Mahathir Mohamad. The trial went over and received testimony from people like ex-Guantanamo detainees, an Iraqi woman who was tortured in the Abu Ghraib prison, and other people who said they were abused in US custody during the Bush administration. The prosecutors said this was just the beginning and that they would pursue the Obama administration too.
War crimes expert and lawyer Francis Boyle of the University of Illinois was part of the prosecution team. Francis Boyle says he hopes similar trials will be carried out around the world, and that they likely will. Boyle argued that citizens around the world could bring such cases themselves.
As for past attempts at getting George Bush, Boyle says “I’ve tried to get bush indicted three times in Canada with Canadian lawyers, and then in Switzerland, where we scared Bush out of making a speech because he feared prosecution.”
The tribunal also heard testimony from witnesses including Abbas Abid, a 48-year-old engineer from Fallujah, Iraq, who described having his fingernails removed; Ali Shalal, who described electric shocks; and Jameelah, who described being stripped, humiliated and used as a human shield on a helicopter.
The prosecution argued that this treatment was not the work of a few individuals but was directly authorised by every one of the accused. (This was the tribunal prosecution’s case; the defendants did not take part in the tribunal and the finding was not tested in a court with jurisdiction over them.) Emails and other evidence were presented, showing that the leaders coordinated with their military personnel techniques of torture, and that they ordered the inhumane treatment themselves, therefore they are responsible. Supporters compared the case to the Nuremberg trials.
Dick Cheney says in his own biography that he fears being prosecuted as a war criminal, (correction: this is not from Cheney’s memoir; it was the view of Lawrence Wilkerson, former chief of staff to Colin Powell, in a 2011 interview). The tribunal’s prosecutors insisted that members of the Bush administration would face prosecution elsewhere and that the Obama administration would be next. (These were predictions by the tribunal’s prosecution team, not announcements by any court or official prosecutor.)
Source: Intellihub

Supporters of the tribunal compared its verdict to a 21st-century Nuremberg trial and said more trials would follow. The names of all these guilty, high ranking officials are even going to be entered into the “Commission’s Register of War Criminals” for public record.
COMMENTS