Switzerland's Basic Income Vote: The 2,500-Franc Proposal Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

No, Switzerland does not pay every adult a basic income. In 2013 and 2014 campaigners gathered enough signatures to force a national vote on an unconditional basic income, and their campaign suggested 2,500 Swiss francs a month for every adult and 625 francs for every child. When the Swiss finally voted on 5 June 2016, 76.9 percent said no, and every one of the 26 cantons rejected it.

Switzerland’s Basic Income Initiative: The 2014 Proposal and the 2016 Vote

Even so, the Swiss campaign became one of the best-known moments in the history of the basic income idea. It was the first time an entire country voted on it. Here is what was proposed, why it attracted so much attention, why voters turned it down, and what other experiments have taught us since.

What the Swiss initiative proposed

Switzerland lets citizens put almost any constitutional change to a national referendum if they collect 100,000 valid signatures. A group led by Daniel Straub and Enno Schmidt used that route to propose an unconditional basic income: a regular payment to every resident, whether they worked or not, with no means test.

The wording of the initiative itself did not fix a sum. It asked the state to provide an income that would allow the whole population a dignified life and to take part in public life, leaving the amount and the funding to Parliament. The figures that made headlines, 2,500 francs for adults and 625 for children, came from the campaign. The adult figure was a little above the maximum state old-age pension and close to what is considered the Swiss poverty line.

Straub described the spirit of the idea as a society that says to each newborn, "Welcome, you will be cared for", and then asks what they want to do with their life.

The coins in front of Parliament

When the campaigners handed in their signatures in Bern in October 2013, they staged one of the most photographed protests in recent Swiss politics. A truck tipped about eight million five-rappen coins, one for every person then living in Switzerland, onto the square in front of the Federal Palace, and supporters spread them out with shovels and brooms. The picture above shows that day.

Numbers that circulated at the time need care. One widely shared claim said the measure would make it illegal to pay anyone less than 2,500 francs. That was a mix-up. A separate initiative proposed a national minimum wage of 22 francs an hour, roughly 4,000 francs a month; Swiss voters rejected it in May 2014, with only 23.7 percent in favour. A basic income is a payment from the state, not a wage floor that employers must meet.

The arguments for and against

What supporters argued

  • A single payment could replace many separate, means-tested benefits and cut administration.
  • A secure floor would reduce financial stress and let people choose training, care work, volunteering or creative work.
  • It could cushion workers against job losses from automation.
  • Employers offering unpleasant jobs might have to raise pay or improve conditions.
  • People might take more risks, such as starting a business, if failure did not mean poverty.

What critics argued

  • The cost would be enormous, and critics doubted it could be funded at a meaningful level without large tax rises or cuts elsewhere.
  • Some people might work less, shrinking the tax base that pays for the scheme.
  • Giving the same amount to everyone, including the wealthy, struck many as unfair.
  • A generous, unconditional payment could attract migration and push up prices and rents.
  • Business leaders warned that a heavy new tax burden could make Switzerland less attractive to companies.

The Swiss government and Parliament recommended a no vote, mainly over cost and the effect on the economy. Many voters also seemed to see the referendum as a question of principle rather than a detailed plan, since the sum and the funding had never been fixed.

The result of the June 2016 vote

On 5 June 2016 the initiative won 23.1 percent support and was rejected by 76.9 percent, with all cantons against. The strongest support came from parts of the cities of Geneva and Zurich and one commune in western Switzerland; Geneva's Pâquis district was the standout, with more than half of voters in favour.

Campaigners presented the result as a start rather than an end, pointing out that nearly a quarter of voters had backed an idea that had barely been discussed a few years earlier. Switzerland has not introduced a national basic income since.

What other basic income experiments show

Because a national scheme is so costly, most evidence comes from pilots and partial programmes:

  • Finland ran a two-year government trial from January 2017 with 2,000 unemployed participants who received a monthly payment regardless of whether they found work. The government declined to extend it in 2018.
  • Kenya hosts a long-running GiveDirectly project, planned to last 12 years and reaching more than 20,000 people.
  • Alaska pays nearly every resident a yearly dividend from oil revenues, typically around 1,600 dollars. It is too small to live on, but research links it to lower poverty among some rural communities.

Results on employment are mixed. Some pilots found almost no effect on work; a 2024 US study found a small drop in labour market participation, and reviews suggest larger programmes may reduce work more than small ones. The debate the Swiss vote helped start is still very much open.

Why the Swiss case still matters

Switzerland was an unusual test because it is rich, has low unemployment and a strong welfare system already. If a basic income could not win there, supporters had to admit that cost and fairness worries run deep. If you read claims that "Switzerland pays everyone a salary", you now know the real story: a bold proposal, a memorable protest, and a clear no at the ballot box.

Sources: Swissinfo: Vote of June 5, 2016 on an unconditional basic income; Wikipedia: Universal basic income; Wikipedia: Economy of Switzerland. First reported by Exposing The Truth.

Related:

COMMENTS