Robert Reich's 2-Minute Video on How Policy Keeps the Poor Poor

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

In this short marker-board video, economist Robert Reich argues that a series of policy choices in the United States were making life harder for low-wage workers and the poor, and that these choices were driven by politics rather than economic necessity. The clip, shared by MoveOn.org in early 2014, sketches his case in about two minutes, using little more than a flip chart and a pen.

Below is a guide to who Reich is, what the video lists, the real policy debates of 2014 behind each point, and how to weigh a short argument like this one.

Who is Robert Reich?

Robert Reich is an American economist, author and commentator. He worked in the administrations of Presidents Gerald Ford and Jimmy Carter; in 1977 Carter appointed him director of the policy planning staff at the Federal Trade Commission. He served as Secretary of Labor under Bill Clinton from January 1993 to January 1997, a period in which he implemented the Family and Medical Leave Act and pushed for a higher minimum wage.

From 2006 he taught at the University of California, Berkeley's Goldman School of Public Policy, where his undergraduate course "Wealth and Poverty" was popular, retiring as professor emeritus in 2023. He is also known to a wider audience through the 2013 documentary Inequality for All, which won a special jury award at the Sundance Film Festival, and through books such as Aftershock and Saving Capitalism.

What the video lists

Robert Reich’s Short Video Argument About Wealth and Economic Policy

The flip chart in the video shows a numbered list of seven items, each illustrated with a quick sketch: no increase in the minimum wage, no emergency unemployment benefits, no Medicaid, cuts to food stamps, no more education or job training, no jobs programme, and busting unions. Reich presents them together as one pattern that keeps people on low incomes from getting ahead.

On 2 March 2014 Reich also posted a video titled "The war on the working class" on his blog, and the argument here follows the same theme. Whether you agree with his conclusion or not, each item refers to a real policy fight at the time.

The facts behind the points

Minimum wage

The federal minimum wage has been $7.25 an hour since 24 July 2009. In 2014 the Minimum Wage Fairness Act proposed raising it to $10.10 over two years; it was debated in the Senate in April 2014 and did not pass. The Congressional Budget Office estimated that a $10.10 minimum would lift about 900,000 people above the poverty line, but could also cost around 500,000 jobs, with a wide range of uncertainty. That trade-off is the centre of the debate, and the video presents only one side of it.

Emergency unemployment benefits

The Emergency Unemployment Compensation programme, created in June 2008 during the financial crisis, extended jobless benefits beyond the usual state limit. It expired on 1 January 2014 when Congress passed no further extension, which is the situation the video refers to.

Food stamps

The Agricultural Act of 2014, signed on 7 February 2014, cut about $8 billion from the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP, often called food stamps) over ten years, mainly by tightening a rule linking heating assistance to benefit levels. The New York Times estimated that around 850,000 households would lose about $90 a month.

Medicaid

The Affordable Care Act planned to expand Medicaid to more low-income adults. In June 2012 the Supreme Court ruled in NFIB v. Sebelius that states could decline the expansion without losing their existing Medicaid funding, which made the expansion optional for each state.

Training, jobs and unions

The remaining items, cuts to education and job training, the absence of a large jobs programme and the decline of unions, are broader arguments about long-term policy. They are harder to tie to a single law, and economists disagree about how much each one explains rising inequality.

How to watch a two-minute argument

Short explainers are useful because they make a complex claim easy to follow. They also leave things out. A few questions help when watching this or any similar video:

  • Separate facts from interpretation. That the minimum wage stayed at $7.25 is a fact; that this is part of a deliberate "war" on the poor is Reich's interpretation.
  • Look for the trade-offs. The CBO figures above show both benefits and possible costs of a higher minimum wage. A fair assessment weighs both.
  • Check the date. The video reflects the political situation of early 2014. Some policies have changed since then, so look up the current position before drawing conclusions.
  • Hear the other side. Critics argue that some of these programmes discourage work or cost more than they deliver. Comparing both views gives a fuller picture than either alone.

Reich's own framing is clear: much of economic policy, in his view, is a contest between people with money and people without it, dressed up in complicated language. Whatever you conclude, the video is a compact example of how he makes that case.

Sources: video by Robert Reich, shared by MoveOn.org via True Activist; Wikipedia: Robert Reich; Robert Reich: The war on the working class; Wikipedia: Minimum wage in the United States; Wikipedia: Emergency Unemployment Compensation; Wikipedia: Agricultural Act of 2014; Wikipedia: NFIB v. Sebelius.

Related:

COMMENTS