Chaplin's Final Speech in The Great Dictator: Meaning and History

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Chaplin’s Closing Speech From The Great Dictator (1940)

The closing speech of The Great Dictator (1940) is a few minutes of Charlie Chaplin speaking straight to the camera, out of character, pleading for kindness, democracy and human solidarity against hatred, greed and blind obedience. In the story, a humble Jewish barber has been mistaken for the dictator Adenoid Hynkel and is pushed onto a stage to address the nation. Instead of a victory speech he delivers an appeal to ordinary people and soldiers everywhere. It became one of the most quoted moments in film history.

You can watch the scene below. After it you will find what the speech actually argues, why Chaplin made the film, how audiences reacted then and now, and a few myths that have grown around it.

What happens in the scene

Chaplin plays two roles in the film: Hynkel, ruler of the fictional country Tomainia and an unmistakable parody of Adolf Hitler, and a Jewish barber who returns home after many years of memory loss following the First World War to find his ghetto terrorised by stormtroopers. The two men look identical. Near the end, Hynkel is mistakenly arrested while the barber, dressed in a uniform, is taken for the dictator.

Standing before a vast rally and a bank of microphones after Tomainia’s invasion of a neighbouring country, the barber hesitates, then begins to speak. The camera moves in, the comedy drops away, and for the rest of the scene the audience is watching Chaplin himself. The speech ends with a direct message to Hannah, the young woman from the ghetto played by Paulette Goddard, who hears it on the radio far away and lifts her face towards the sunrise.

What the speech says, in plain words

The address moves through a clear argument. It opens with a refusal of power itself:

“I’m sorry, but I don’t want to be an emperor. That’s not my business.”

From there Chaplin makes several points that are worth reading slowly:

  • People are naturally inclined to help each other. The speaker wants to help everyone, whatever their religion or race, and insists that cruelty is learned rather than innate.
  • Technology has outpaced wisdom. Speed, machines and abundance have arrived, yet people feel more isolated and many still go without. Inventions such as radio and aircraft should bring humanity together, not make it easier to wage war.
  • Dictators are temporary. Hatred and the men who exploit it will pass, and the power they seized will return to the people.
  • Soldiers should refuse to serve tyranny. He urges them not to hand themselves over to leaders who treat them as disposable.
  • Democracy and science should serve happiness. The speech closes by calling for a world of reason, fair work, security in old age and freedom from national barriers, greed and intolerance.
Charlie Chaplin, one of the most important speeches in recorded history

Two lines capture the heart of it. On modern life Chaplin says:

“We think too much and feel too little. More than machinery, we need humanity.”

And to the soldiers he declares:

“You are not machines, you are not cattle, you are men!”

The speech also borrows from the Gospel of Luke (17:21), which says the kingdom of God is within you. Chaplin widens it deliberately: not within one man or one group, but within everyone.

Why Chaplin made the film

By the late 1930s Chaplin was the last major Hollywood filmmaker still making essentially silent comedies. The Great Dictator was his first true sound film, and he wrote, directed, produced and starred in it. According to Wikipedia’s detailed history of the film, shooting began in September 1939, only days after the Second World War broke out, and lasted almost six months on a budget of about $2.2 million.

The project was risky. The United States was not yet at war, and Britain’s government under Neville Chamberlain, then pursuing appeasement, announced it would ban the film. By the time it reached London in 1941, Britain was fighting Germany and the ban was forgotten. The film was banned in much of Europe and several Latin American countries.

It premiered in New York on 15 October 1940 and became Chaplin’s most commercially successful film. It received five Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture, Best Actor for Chaplin and Best Supporting Actor for Jack Oakie, who played Benzino Napaloni, a parody of Mussolini.

How the speech was received

Reviewers praised the film as a whole, and Bosley Crowther of The New York Times called it a superb accomplishment by a great artist. The ending divided opinion more. Some critics at the time felt the sudden switch from slapstick to sermon broke the spell of the comedy; others argued that the abrupt change was exactly the point, since there was nothing funny left to say about what was happening in Europe.

Chaplin clearly stood by it. On 21 January 1941 he read the closing speech at a gala celebrating President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s third inauguration. Decades later the words found a new audience online and in music: the speech has been sampled in more than 40 songs, and bands such as U2 and Coldplay have used it in live shows.

In 1997 the US Library of Congress added The Great Dictator to the National Film Registry as culturally, historically or aesthetically significant. Roger Ebert later included it in his list of Great Movies.

Myths and questions around the speech

Is it “the greatest speech ever made”?

That label comes from viral videos rather than from historians. It is a scripted film monologue, written and performed by an actor, not a political address. That does not make it less moving, but it is fairer to call it one of the most famous speeches in cinema.

Did Hitler see the film?

Nobody knows for certain. Biographer Jeffrey Vance cited a German refugee who said Hitler watched it twice, alone, and a 2002 documentary, The Tramp and the Dictator, reported an eyewitness account that he saw it. Albert Speer, Hitler’s architect, denied that he ever did. If he watched it, his reaction was not recorded.

Did Chaplin know about the Holocaust?

Not its full scale. In his 1964 autobiography Chaplin wrote that had he known the true horrors of the Nazi concentration camps, he could not have made the film or treated the Nazis’ murderous madness as comedy. The ghetto scenes show persecution, but the extermination camps came later and were not yet understood in the West.

Why it still lands today

Part of the speech’s power comes from timing: a world-famous comedian, in 1940, using his first real spoken lines on screen to warn against fascism while much of the world still hoped to avoid it. Part of it is universality. The targets are not named nations but habits of mind: treating people as tools, letting technology replace compassion, obeying leaders who promise everything and deliver cruelty.

If you want to get more from it, watch the full film rather than the clip alone. The speech hits harder after you have seen the barber’s gentle, clumsy life in the ghetto and Hynkel’s absurd ballet with a globe. Then read the speech again and notice how little of it is about one dictator and how much is about the choices ordinary people make every day.

Sources: Wikipedia: The Great Dictator. Film, script and speech by Charles Chaplin (United Artists, 1940); quotations are short excerpts from the closing speech.

Related:

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 3
  1. Chaplin is among Tesla, Einstein, Newton, Ghandi, Mandela and so on - among the world's most important people, among the people of my admiration.

    ReplyDelete