Cause and Effect: Gus Serrano’s Short Film About Consumption

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Cause and Effect: The Consequences of What We Take for Granted is a short film of about five minutes by Gus Serrano, made as a student project at the University of Denver. It follows three people through everyday American routines, buying a new gadget, filling up a car and eating a meat meal, and cuts each scene against found footage of what lies further along the supply chain. If you are looking for the film, it is embedded below; if you want to understand what it is arguing and how much of that argument holds up, read on.

What the film shows

Each of the three stories begins with something ordinary. One character unboxes and enjoys new consumer electronics. Another pulls into a petrol station and fills the tank. A third sits down to a meal of meat. Nothing in these scenes is unusual, and that is the point.

The film then interrupts each routine with archive and documentary clips meant to show the hidden costs: the conditions in which materials are mined and devices discarded, the conflicts and pollution associated with oil, and the treatment of animals in industrial farming. The juxtaposition does the persuading. There is little narration; the viewer is left to connect the comfortable scene with the harsh one.

The Consequences of What We Take for Granted

A remix made for a writing class

According to the filmmakers’ own description, the film was produced for WRIT 1122, a writing course at the University of Denver taught by Professor Matthew Hill. The assignment asked students to “remix” existing media for a cause that mattered to them. Serrano and his collaborators chose three causes at once and combined found footage with their own narrative scenes.

The production was modest: it was shot on a Canon EOS 60D at 50 and 60 frames per second in 720p and edited in Sony Vegas 12. The film was posted on Vimeo and spread widely on social media, often with captions urging everyone to watch and share it.

Seeing it as a remix helps explain both its strength and its weak spot. Remixing is a form of argument by arrangement: placing clip B after scene A tells the viewer that A causes B. That is rhetorically powerful, and it is exactly what the course was teaching. But a sequence of images is not evidence about a particular product, and the found clips come from different places and years.

Reading the three stories against the evidence

The film’s broad claims point at real, documented problems, even if the clips themselves are not traced to specific products.

Electronics

Several metals used in phones and computers, tin, tantalum, tungsten and gold, are known as conflict minerals when they come from eastern Democratic Republic of Congo, where armed groups have profited from mining. A US law passed in 2010, section 1502 of the Dodd-Frank Act, requires companies to report whether their products use these minerals, and an EU regulation adopted in 2017 requires importers to check their supply chains. At the other end of a device’s life, the world generated about 62 million tonnes of electronic waste in 2022, and only around a fifth was formally collected and recycled. Much of the rest is handled informally, sometimes by burning, at sites such as Agbogbloshie in Ghana and Guiyu in China, where studies have found high levels of lead and dioxins.

Petrol

Oil’s costs are familiar: greenhouse gas emissions from burning fuel, spills such as the 2010 Deepwater Horizon disaster in the Gulf of Mexico, and the role oil wealth has played in many conflicts. The film presents these through montage rather than figures, so it is best taken as a prompt to look further than as a measured account.

Meat

Livestock farming is the largest source of greenhouse gases within agriculture. Animal agriculture uses about 83 per cent of the world’s farmland while supplying around 18 per cent of its calories, and most land cleared in the Amazon has gone to cattle pasture. Welfare in intensive farming is a long-running concern too, which is the focus of the film’s most uncomfortable images.

Where the film’s method has limits

The original description of the film claimed its footage was entirely real and showed practices that are legal and rarely prosecuted. We could not verify the source of each clip, and that matters. Found footage can be old, from a different country or show an extreme case rather than a typical one. A responsible viewer can accept the general point, that cheap convenience often has costs paid by someone else, while still asking where a given image came from.

It is also worth noticing what the film leaves out. Mining, energy and farming support millions of livelihoods, and conditions vary enormously between companies and countries. Change is happening in places: due-diligence laws, recycling schemes, cleaner energy and welfare standards. A five-minute remix cannot cover that, and it does not try to.

Why it still works as a conversation starter

The film’s lasting value is the habit of mind it encourages: pausing before a routine purchase to ask where something came from and where it will end up. Teachers have used short films like this to open discussions about media literacy, persuasion and ethics, and it does both jobs at once. You can watch it as a message about consumption and also as an example of how editing shapes meaning.

Practical ways to act on it

  • Keep devices longer. Repairing a phone or laptop, or buying refurbished, cuts both mining demand and e-waste.
  • Recycle electronics properly. Use certified take-back schemes rather than general bins, and wipe your data first.
  • Drive less where you can. Combining trips, car-sharing, public transport and cycling all reduce fuel use.
  • Eat thoughtfully. Eating less meat, or choosing higher-welfare sources, addresses both environmental and animal-welfare concerns.
  • Question what you watch. When a video moves you, look up the facts behind it before sharing.

Sources: film by Gus Serrano, Cause and Effect on Vimeo; Conflict minerals (Wikipedia); Electronic waste (Wikipedia); Environmental impact of meat production (Wikipedia).

Related:

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1
  1. ...but how many tomatoes were slaughtered in the making of this video?

    I am concerned.

    ReplyDelete