Monks Free 600 Pounds of Lobsters off Prince Edward Island

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Monks Purchase Hundreds Of Live Lobsters And Release Them To The Ocean
Jessica Doria-Brown/CBC

On Saturday, 9 July 2016, monks from the Great Enlightenment Buddhist Institute Society in Little Sands, Prince Edward Island, carried eight crates of live lobsters onto a fishing boat and set them free off Wood Islands. The animals, more than 600 pounds (about 270 kg) in all, had been bought from sellers around the Island in the days before. Local fishermen helped choose a release spot where traps were unlikely to catch them again.

The story travelled far beyond Canada that summer, often with a mix of admiration and puzzlement. Below is what actually happened, why Buddhists perform this kind of ritual, and what scientists and conservationists say about freeing animals this way.

What happened at Wood Islands

According to CBC Prince Edward Island, which filmed the event, the monks did not simply tip the crates over the side. They first spent about twenty minutes in prayer and chanting addressed to the Buddha of compassion, and sprinkled blessed water over the lobsters. Only then were the crustaceans lowered into the Northumberland Strait.

The institute is a monastic community on the eastern end of the Island, and its members had gone from market to market buying as many lobsters as they could. The purchase was not cheap: at summer retail prices, 600 pounds of live lobster represents thousands of dollars.


What surprised many outside observers was the reaction on the Island itself. In a province where lobster fishing is a major livelihood, one might expect fishermen to roll their eyes. Instead, CBC reported broad local support, and fishermen offered practical advice about where the animals would have the best chance of staying out of cages.

Why the monks did it

A spokesman identified as Venerable Dan explained that the lobsters were a means, not the whole point. The aim, he said, was to train the mind in kindness toward every living thing. In his telling, the same attitude could mean sparing a worm or a fly, or simply driving more slowly so small animals on the road are not hurt.

He also hoped the crustaceans would end up somewhere "there are no cages waiting for them," a modest wish given how heavily the coast is fished.

Monks Purchase Hundreds Of Live Lobsters And Release Them To The Ocean
Jessica Doria-Brown/CBC

The monks themselves eat a plant-based diet, but Dan was careful to say this was not a recruitment drive. "We respect everyone’s dietary choice, so we’re not doing this to convert everybody to be vegetarians or vegans," he told reporters.

His other argument was one most people can follow without any religious framework: imagine a person you love trapped and waiting for a fate they cannot escape, and ask what you would want someone to do for them. Thinking from the animal’s side, he suggested, makes gentleness come more easily, and no ceremony or Buddhist identity is required to practise it.

Life release: an ancient Buddhist practice

The Wood Islands ceremony belongs to a tradition known in Chinese as fangsheng, usually translated as "life release." Practitioners buy animals destined for slaughter or captivity and return them to the wild, typically with prayers, sometimes dedicated to someone who is ill or has died.

The custom is old. Written records go back to the third century CE, and it may have started as a Taoist or folk practice before Chinese Buddhists adopted it in the fourth or fifth century. From China it spread to Tibet, Japan, Korea and much of Southeast Asia. In Japan a version called Hōjō-e has been performed since 676. All three major branches of Buddhism practise it in some form, and the total number of animals released each year is estimated in the hundreds of millions.

Do lobsters feel pain?

The question behind the gesture is whether a lobster has any experience worth caring about. Science has moved noticeably on this point. Experiments led by Robert Elwood at Queen’s University Belfast found that crabs and prawns behave in ways that are hard to explain as pure reflex: shore crabs given a mild shock learned to abandon a preferred shelter, and hermit crabs traded the quality of their shell against avoiding shocks. Painkilling and anaesthetic drugs reduced prawns’ rubbing of an irritated antenna.

Not everyone agrees. A 2005 Norwegian report judged it unlikely that lobsters feel pain, and some philosophers place the line at octopuses and squid. Still, the evidence was strong enough for the United Kingdom to name decapod crustaceans, the group that includes lobsters and crabs, as sentient beings in the Animal Welfare (Sentience) Act 2022.

When animal release goes wrong

Conservationists are often uneasy about life release, and with reason. Animals bought for freeing are sometimes captured specifically to be sold to devotees, or let go in places where they cannot survive. Non-native species released into rivers and lakes have harmed local wildlife; red-eared slider turtles freed in China and Japan, for example, compete with native turtles. In 2015 two people in England were fined more than £28,000 after releasing hundreds of non-native crustaceans off the English coast.

The Prince Edward Island release avoided the worst of these problems. The lobsters were local animals going back into their own waters, and the people who know those waters best helped pick the spot. That is a useful model for anyone tempted by the idea: native species only, released into suitable habitat, ideally with advice from local fishers or wildlife officials.


Small ways to practise the same idea

Most of us will never buy a crate of lobsters to set free, and the monks would say we do not need to. The habits they pointed to are within anyone’s reach:

  • Slow down on rural roads at dusk, when frogs, hedgehogs and other small animals cross.
  • Carry an insect outside instead of swatting it.
  • If you eat seafood, learn how it is caught and handled, and support suppliers who take welfare and sustainability seriously.
  • Before "rescuing" any animal, check with a wildlife rehabilitator that release is safe for the animal and for the local ecosystem.

Whether you see the Wood Islands ceremony as a moving ritual or a quixotic gesture, it left a clear message: compassion is a habit you can practise in small, daily choices, and it grows the more you use it.

Sources: CBC News: P.E.I. monks buy 600 lbs of lobster to release them into ocean (photos by Jessica Doria-Brown/CBC); The Independent; Wikipedia: Life release; Wikipedia: Pain in crustaceans; originally shared via True Activist.

COMMENTS